Adolf Wagners was actually the place I went to. I only went once but I still dream about their onion beer cheese with pumpernickel bread. It's the only Apfelwein I've ever had but it was really good.
Three reasons: (1) Most Ale yeasts will go dormant and drop to the bottom of the carboy if you cold crash the cider. This makes it relatively easy to remove the yeast so that you have a semi sweet cider. (2) They generally use more nutrient, which make crashing more reliable and often causes them to stop on their own at higher gravities (although an ale yeast can easily take a cider down to 0.996 with high nutrient juice) and (3) They produce a cider that tastes better (that is subjective, but most folks who like a semi-sweet or sweet cider agree)
Those are the short answers. You can use the search function to find longer explanations of these points
Adolf Wagners was actually the place I went to. I only went once but I still dream about their onion beer cheese with pumpernickel bread. It's the only Apfelwein I've ever had but it was really good.
Is headspace important at all when making ciders?
If you are using a top fermenting beer yeast like Wyeast 3333, 3056 or 3068, then yes, you will have more yeast/foam/kreusen than you can handle and want at least 1/4 of your container empty headspace WITH a blow off tube
If you use wine yeast like SN9, VR21, or others then not nearly as much.
Sorry, I should have specified. Could I ferment 1 gallon in a 4 gallon container? Would it matter with cider? Or mead??
Would crashing say 1,015 be ok with s04?
Could I ferment 1 gallon in a 4 gallon container?
Just finished binge reading all 104 pages of this thread. I had to register it was so great.
I started my first cider two weeks ago with just some store bought apple juice and bakers yeast (Fleischmann's). Strangle enough it turned out - like a white wine but it turned out. Three of my friends gave it a test drive and all thought it was good, I thought they were crazy, it didn't taste like apple to me. That's obviously because i fermented dry and the apple taste gets digested under 1.005 it looks like.
My next step is to do another batch and try to catch it around that range for a semi-sweet, my plan was to use Nottingham so i could crash it and not use chemicals, but my questions is this. My apartment is really warm here in NC. It probably hasn't been below 75ºF in my place for months. Do you think it would be ok to pitch Nottingham at that range and let it go. The higher temp is going to be hard to catch at the range i want, but will it also produce off flavors?
If not any suggestions? I still have one packet of Fleischmann's left (came in packet of 3, used 2) which is a lot cheaper than buying new yeast for a 1 gal carboy.
You posted a couple years ago about using some cider specific apples, but the results from your tasting party didn't seem like they made much of an impression ... just wondering if you had any further thoughts on this. I'm going to plant several cider apple trees this winter, with several more eating apples the next year
Trees are more than 60 years old, never fertilized, mix of five different old varieties (Herrnhut, Bankroft, Beforest and some unknown).
should I add some (maybe 1/4 or 1/2) nutrient to avoid making fart-cider or it will somehow mellow in following days of fermentation or even after bottling?
I'm glad that so many folks are finding this thread useful! I've definitely learned a lot from everyone who has contributed.
I got my first juice of the season a couple of weeks ago. The mix was Cortland, Gala and Jonathan, which has become my early season mix of choice. One of these days, I'm hoping to add some Hewes Crab to this mix as a few orchards around here have planted them but no one is selling them yet.
The SG was 1.057, which is the highest that I've ever got from an early season mix. Partly that is because it was a dry summer and partly its because now that the orchard where I get my juice is making their own hard cider, they are letting the apples hang on the trees a little longer. I still bumped it with 3oz/gal of turbinado/dextrose mix, which turned out to be a good thing because even with the extra sugar, these batches fermented out really fast.
![]()
I did two batches each of Brupaks and Wy3056 (sufited & non sulfited), non sufited BRY97 and a sulfited Notty batch. The weather for the past two weeks has been great for fermenting. By opening the basement windows at night, I was able to keep temps between 62F and 66F, which is a good range.
This batch still fermented out really fast and I crashed them all after 9 days. Last year, same juice from same trees and same temps fermented out in 12-13 days. The main difference seems to be the starting SG of the raw juice, because in both years I bumped the SG up to about 1.065 before pitching the yeast - I just had to use more sugar last year. So its possible that the higher sugar content seems to be correlated to higher nutrient level in the fruit (given same trees). I called the orchard to see if maybe they had fertilized this year, and they did apply some phosphorus and potash this year, but no nitrogen. Last year they didnt add anything. So either the phosphorus and/or potash has a similar effect on the yeast as nitrogen, or the same process that concentrates sugars in the fruit is also concentrating nutrient
![]()
Go to sleep yeasties... nothing but dreams now.
One of the batches, the sulfited WY3056 batch, would just not shut down. It blew the bung out of the carboy twice.
![]()
Back into secondaries and clearing at room temperature, all of the batches except the sulfited WY3056 batch seem fairly stable. The six on the right are the ones from this season, right after the crash
![]()
Unsurprisingly, the sulfited WY3056 batch started back up after a day. I'll need to throw that one back in the fridge. Its not unusually for the WY3056 to need two crashes to stop in the beginning of the season