flyangler18
Well-Known Member
Maybe worth an experiement? I'm thinking a flask of water and introduce smoke, or something visible and heavier than air. Add foil and swirl to see if there is actually an exchange that many claim occurs. Just spitballing here.
Have at it - but why experiment to prove/disprove something that has already been demonstrated to be true in any lab that is working with microbial cultures? This has been documented in the literature many, many times.
A stirplate is the most effective way to grow up a starter because it promotes gas exchange and gets oxygen to the yeast when used with either a foam plug on the flask or foil; Mr. Malty's calculator bears this out.
For me, this isn't a theoretical discussion - it's a practical one. I follow established lab procedure for growing yeast and my beer is better for it.