Okay, so we didn't get a lot of traction on "rate the teams you don't want to face" question. But we're still in the honeymoon period where we've drafted a team, we haven't seen a bunch of players go down injured, and we're all hopeful to crush our opposition through the use of our expert draft strategies. I always like to hear about other people's thought processes. So here's a new task.
Take us through your draft. What did you expect to happen going in? Why did you take certain players in certain spots? When all is said and done and you look at your roster, how do you think you did?
For me, I've always tended towards ZeroRB builds. Usually if you're early in the draft order, that can sometimes become HeroRB, because having the top RB in the league is always valuable. That's how I ended up with CMC last year picking 1.02. Late in drafts, though, usually find that the no-brainer RBs have already been taken and some quite valuable WRs have fallen to that spot. So when I rolled in and saw that I was picking 12th, I immediately expected that it would be a ZeroRB build.
The other thing that worried me about picking 12th is that it meant that after 1.12/2.01, I wouldn't pick again until 3.12/4.01. As I mentioned in my last post, I've come around on the value of an elite QB. Not so much that I'll force it, but that I'll take a top 4-5 QB if they're there. Well, in various ADP places I'd looked, Allen, Hurts, and Mahomes were all going before that 36th pick. So I was thinking I'd end up having to push downward and get a guy I liked later.
So what happened when my picks were up? Let's look into it. I'll group them since I picked back to back.
- 1.12 / 2.01: Ok, ZeroRB, right? Yeah... Not so much. I liked Garrett Wilson and thought I'd have a shot, but he was gone at pick 10. I'm not picking MHJr this high as he hasn't proven he's worth the risk yet. I feel like Puka is set to regress. I like Davante, but he's getting older and I don't like that team. And then Drake London... Nope. New QB coming of a big injury, new coaching staff, and maybe with Bijan/Pitts might not return that level of value. And then who's there? Well, two running backs who have the potential to finish RB1 overall, because both have done it in their careers. Saquon is finally on a good team, and JT is going to be a bellcow. Nobody else on the depth charts worries me. If these two can stay healthy, they could possibly finish as the top two RBs at the end of the year. If they don't, well, I'm probably screwed.
- 3.12 / 4.01: Okay, surprised this happened. As mentioned I didn't see Mahomes falling to me here. I had to hit smash on that. Was amazed that nobody (other than Fury) had made a run at QBs yet. I think Mahomes is going to have a big year, has some serious talent at WR, still has Kelce, and with our scoring, a high-volume passing offense is great. Also needed a receiver. DK Metcalf is a guy that has sometimes caused me a lot of heartburn. He is an absolute physical freak. I think he's got the physical skills to be a top 5 WR. But it hasn't come together. My hope is that with a new coaching staff, including the OC coming in from University of Washington having run a high-flying fast paced passing offense, it'll unlock Metcalf's value. Behind him I was also considering Jaylen Warren, because any piece of that Miami offense is valuable. But Metcalf's upside if the new coaching staff does what I think they're capable of doing is just huge.
- 5.12/6.01: Okay, now we're getting into the nuts and bolts. Kelce was off the board between 3.12, which might be better as he's getting old (although I took him in the 2nd round of my 20-team league). Behind him I really like Evan Engram. He's got a really strong rapport with Trevor Lawrence, basically plays as a WR in TE body, and gets a lot of targets. You could call this one a reach, but I think he's undervalued per ADP. Some draft boards had him going in the 7th, but I didn't pick until 7.12, so I went with him. Then, another WR. Ended up with Terry McLaurin. Somewhat speculative here, but Terry is someone who can take the top off a defense and Jayden Daniels is known for throwing a beautiful deep ball. Where I worry, though is that his average finish has been WR24 over the past 5 years, with his best ever finish being WR14. But I think it's a safe pick, because he's going to get target volume and his worst ever finish was WR32. I think the QB upgrade should make that low-end WR2 / top-end WR3 area his floor. Hoping for upside with a new QB.
- 7.12/8.01: Another pair of WRs. Also a pair that are highly speculative. Ladd McConkey is a rookie who is thought to be the WR1 in the Chargers offense. An offense that is expected to be run-heavy with HC Jim Harbaugh and OC Greg Roman. But... I don't think this team can win with that, and they have Justin Freakin' Herbert at QB. They're going to have to throw the ball, and it's just a matter of who catches it. So this pick might come back to bite me in the ass, if the targets end up going to Palmer, Johnston, and Rice. But Palmer's never been "the guy", so there's opportunity. This is an upside pick but felt after the way the rest of my roster was coming together, one I needed. Then I get Xavier Worthy. Another rookie, this guy known as a speedster. And on the Chiefs, where we know the quality of the team and the QB will give him opportunities. That said, if Mahomes is zeroing in on Rashee Rice and Travis Kelce, it could meant that the opportunities aren't as numerous as I'd like. At the 7/8 turn, you have to take what you can get. Hoping at least one of these two pays off at >WR3 value.
- 9.12/10.01: I can't leave a draft with only 2 RBs, of course, and now we're starting to get into the part of the draft where you're looking for players who at least have a path. I need another RB. Tyjae Spears might be in an RBBC on a bad team, but he's going to be part of that offense. It might be a 1A/1B situation and he's the 1B. However, its not clear how good Tony Pollard really is at this stage of his career. What happens if Spears becomes 1A? And looking at who was behind Spears on the RB board... I didn't have a choice. So maybe I'm just talking myself into this one. Then I took Khalil Shakir. As I saw it he was falling down the board and was just too much value to pass on. With Diggs no longer being in Buffalo, I think he's going to return more than 10th round value. I could make an argument for Sutton/Samuel who went after him. And if someone who doesn't have such severe burn scars from Jerry Jeudy as I do wants to make the argument that his talent will be unlocked in Cleveland, I'm not gonna argue. But I'm not touching Jeudy lol.
- 11.12/12.01: Okay, I've got one TE. I was looking at both Chubb and TJ Hock with the idea of grabbing them, stashing them in reserve, and making room for lotto tickets. Chubb was gone before I had a chance, but I got Hock. This is one pick that I think might be useless, though. Let's say he comes back once healthy and now he and Engram are coin flip of each other. There's not a lot of trading in this league, so I might not have a great way to unload him and get value back but also not have enough sitting on the waiver wire to justify dropping. But I'm going to hope that he comes back, shows value, and I'll figure it out then. Behind him I've got Romeo Doubs. This is another situation like the Chargers. SOMEONE in Green Bay is going to be catching passes. Right now we don't have any good idea who "the guy" will be. But it might be Doubs, and getting hm at 12.01 could pay off a lot more value than expected. That said, there are a couple guys taken right after him that I could make the similar argument. Adam Thielen has always been a bit of a surprising volume play. Big Mike Williams (BMW) on the Jets with Rodgers chucking him deep balls could pay off. Dontayvion Wicks also in GB could end up being "the guy" and has a lot of hype around him. But I felt good with Doubs.
- 13.12/14.01: And here we get to my screwup. I could have sworn we were in the final 2 rounds. So I took defense and kicker. I guess this explains why I got the Jets, who are a MUCH better defense than I'd have gotten if I'd waited until 15.11. So at least I did get ONE benefit out of my own stupidity.
- 15.11/16.01: Lotto ticket time. I said up above that getting pieces of the Miami offense is smart. This is one of those pieces that may not see a lot of action as long as Achane is healthy, but Jaylen Wright is basically an Achane clone drafted to be his backup and slot directly into the gameplan if Achane isn't available. And then Wan'Dale Robinson, who honestly was just picked because he's there. The biggest issue with Robinson is that the Giants might just suck. He's supposed to be a very shifty slot receiver, going into his third year, and maybe he'll have a breakout especially now that Saquon isn't there.
Overall, I was pretty pleased with my draft. I realize those first two picks are risk/reward. Just gotta hope they stay healthy, or my RB corps is decimated. But if healthy I think they're both going to produce above 1.12/2.01 level results. I'm happy with where I ended up with QB, TE, and Defense (even if unintentional). I've got a depth at WR but the question remains whether there's going to be big payoffs from any of them, or if I'm basically rostering a collection of WR2/WR3/borderline Flex guys.
Would love to hear from everyone else how and why you did what you did as well...