Fellowship of the Drink XXVII: Welcome to the Club

Homebrew Talk - Beer, Wine, Mead, & Cider Brewing Discussion Forum

Help Support Homebrew Talk - Beer, Wine, Mead, & Cider Brewing Discussion Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.


Supporting Member
HBT Supporter
Feb 7, 2008
Reaction score
Orange County
Here Ye, Here Ye! I officially announce the 27th running of the Fellowship of the Drink! Come one, Come all.

If you’ve participated before, it’s good to (hopefully) see you again. If not, see below for the rules.

The FotD is a beer swap for members of the continental US to allow you to try some beers from outside your region. Every participant picks a few beers as their “offer.” Then we devise a draw order and go down the list until everyone has selected an offer to receive.

Here are ALL the previous rounds so you can see how this works (and some of the cool names):
So how does it work?

If you’re interested in participating:
  1. Post your interest in this thread! I will keep a list of the interested people (please also see the "Rules" below for eligibility)
  2. Make sure you are confirmed
  3. Go shopping for beer! (see "What's in an offer" and "What's in the box" below)
  4. After I have confirmed your entry, but before the “Offer Due” date, PM me a photo of your offering along with a link to something like Beer Advocate/Ratebeer/Untappd for each beer so that others can get an idea of what they are choosing
  5. Wait patiently for the offer list to be posted. A few days before the drawing, I will post a complete list of all the offerings and photos
  6. When I post the offerings, I will use a randomizer to create a drawing order. I will post a time for each participant that you are “On the Clock” with five minutes between participants
  7. Be here the night of the pick!
  8. Contact the person who picked you for shipping details
  9. Ship!
  10. Wait for your care package
  11. Enjoy it responsibly, and post a pic if you like
If you think you might not be around for the pick, send me a picklist order to put your choice in for you. I will not use your picklist until the end of your window, so you are welcome to enter a pick until that time.

On pick day, log in at your time slot to submit your pick on this thread. If you previously sent me a pick list, I’ll cover you. If you miss your window, say something in the thread when you arrive, and you can pick after the person currently picking. If you are a no-show, you will receive a randomly matched pick (or the last one, whichever applies.)

What’s in an offer?

Each offering should be:
  • At least 3-6 cans or bottles of commercial beer. Preferably, these will be local to the sender (or otherwise not widely distributed) but please - no more than 86 oz total in the pictured offer.
  • At least one non-beer item: glassware, stickers, koozies, etc. Get creative!
You may also offer some homemade beverages with the commercial offerings (we all love trying homebrew, let’s be honest).

What’s in the box?

The essential thing in the box is what you offered, but many participants also include other “extras.” It is not uncommon to receive beers not listed in the offering. Sometimes these are doubles, unique ones; sometimes, let’s face it, we are cleaning out our refrigerators.

The FotD isn’t a contest to see who can shove the most beer (or most expensive beer) in a box - whales are not required or expected. Most participants are looking to try beers they may have never known existed from small breweries local to you. Let’s think about those Untappd things.

Guidelines are just that, guidelines. Final shipments may, and many times do, exceed the offering posted. Extras are not required.

Some members have also been creative with “noisemakers.” I would never suggest that you ship prohibited items, but if you wanted your box to sound like something other than beer, the following have been used:
  • Hard candy
  • Coins
  • Rice
  • Beans
Be sure to pack well, and use ziplock or other methods to guard against leaks.

Rules (there must be rules)

Participants must also meet all of the following requirements:
  • Continental US resident of legal drinking age
  • An HBT member for at least six months
  • An active participant in the community (based on iTrader rating/activity, recent post count, participation in previous beer swaps, etc.)
  • ... or have been (or are vouched by) a previous FotD participant.
Current Timeline
  • Sunday, May 1st - Offers due (including photos & style descriptions)
  • Wednesday, May 4th - Offers and Pick Order posted.
  • Monday, May 9th - Pick day! 1st pick will be 7:00 PM EST. All others will be in a 5 min interval, according to the rules above.
Have any questions, or are you interested in participating? Post here!
Last edited:
I suppose I can't join (lurker who finally created account). Does the fact that I ponied up for a supporter account make me more trustworthy?
So, we've added @TwistedGray and a maybe from @Knightshade (nudge-nudge) in the past week.

I should do some recruiting... But instead I'll offer a mixed 6-Pack of SoCal beers to the person that brings in the most new (or returning) members. How's that sound?

I'm still sitting pretty firmly on the maybe fence for now..
@pshankstar @BAF we might have good representation from upstate. I plan on pickup up some beer from Buried Acorn in Syracuse.

Have you ever been to Seneca Lake Brewing? I haven’t been out there, but as a Brit who loves cask ale, I really need to go:

No I haven’t been there. I’m usually not out that way to be able to make the trip.
I’ve met the brewer from Seneca Lake Brewing years ago when he came out to our homebrew club years ago to do some judging with other local pro brewers.
@BAF, if we don't get major dissent from the group I don't see why you can't participate. Perhaps whoever you choose will hold off on shipping until your recipient has received their package. It'd be nice to get some new people in here.

Anyone see an issue with this?