Good performance from the dry yeast at 1.008
Yep. mine brewed at 66 ish and was def clove dominant and lacking in banana. Thanks for the udpate!!View attachment 858603
Update: I can confidently say this is the best hefeweizen I have ever brewed. The moment the beer was poured into the glass, an intense aroma of bananas immediately hit my nose. The aroma is sweet and very banana-forward with a slightly bready quality from the light munich I prefer to use over the Carahell that Weihenstephan supposedly uses. The cloves come across in the flavor, noticeable spicy bite. IBU's are just right. Sulfur is very low for the style, significantly lower than what I was getting with the Omega version of W68. Additionally the beer is not too tart or overly citrusey.
I would use this exact fermentation temperature and pitch rate again. I think if I was to ferment any hotter, I would risk excessive fusel alcohol production, which this strain is very prone to in my experience.
The batch details are all contained here:
https://share.brewfather.app/yFXBxCrJbeXX8q
Thanks for the update!View attachment 860474
So here's that second version of my above hefeweizen where all I did was swap the white wheat malt for Weyermann dark wheat malt. I was shooting for 5.8% where the original version above came out at 5.5%. It ended up going from 1.055 to 1.009, for a result of 6.0%.
My observations:
-It's always incredible to me with this yeast how as soon as you push the OG past a certain tipping point, that this strain starts throwing some pretty crazy esters, and this one is for sure in Weizenbock territory in terms of not just yeast expression but in terms of just being way bigger on flavor. Bottom line there's some bubblegum to go with the bananas. It's definitely not like the Ayinger Urweisse at all - I will need to either prop up their strain somehow or try a different strain in the future. Their ester profile is very different. But bottom line, I went with the same pitch rate exactly as the hefeweizen above and the esters are crazy. Keep the pitch rate LOW - 6 grams per 5 gallons, keep the temperature higher - 68F+, and keep the pressure low.
-Despite the SRM being 7.7 vs 5.4 (hefeweizen above) on paper, you can tell this is simply way darker than it should be. My guess, Weyermann's Light Munich tends to run lighter than their specs suggest, as my hefeweizen above is pretty pale for something with 2.5 pounds of Munich malt in it.
-I don't like the malt character, frankly. It's just too much for a Hefeweizen. Weyermann's dark wheat should basically just be a munich malt on paper, but it's much sweeter, a bit less bready. I prefer actual munich malt. Not that it's bad, I've medaled with a similar beer to this in the past, and I'm sure this one will also medal as a weizenbock. But the assault of the esters and sweet maltiness combined just affects drinkability to a degree. If I were forced to brew this exact beer again, I would pull a Schneider-Weisse and hop it up like their Hopfenweisse which is an absolutely brilliant beer. That would give some bitterness and phenolics to stand up to the malt and ester sweetness.
Great thread. I’m fermenting a dunkelweizen with w-68. Cooled wort down to 60f, pitched 3 packets (6 gal batch) and let free rise to 71 at peak fermentation. Big pitch on 1.048 wort.. Letting this finish up and can’t wait to drink. I’ll try to remember to report back w/ yeast flavors
I was expecting a higher final gravity (1.056)… even then I understand it’s still a healthy pitch (didn’t read SG until Tilt was tossed in). We’ll see. Will likely harvest the yeast and brew again anyway so.. experiment it is. I haven’t overpitched a hefe to tell you the esters will be completely gone, but have underpitched and warm fermented a hefe and still haven’t gotten the banana I wanted. If it lacks flavor I’ll be severely underpitching the next one lol. On the bright side, I’ll have hefe yeast for a whileWhy did you pitch so much? I cannot imagine you will get any significant ester character with that much of an overpitch.
That's a waste of about 2.5 packs of yeast. Seriously, I would have pitched no more than 1/2 a pack. Save money and get more flavor.pitched 3 packets (6 gal batch) and let free rise to 71 at peak fermentation. Big pitch on 1.048 wort.
I hear youThat's a waste of about 2.5 packs of yeast. Seriously, I would have pitched no more than 1/2 a pack. Save money and get more flavor.
Thanks for the update! I've fallen off the w-68 brewing after getting more into hazies and pils for the hot months But plan on having a big Weizenbock ready end of September!I haven't posted in here in a while. I continue to make pristine authentic Bavarian style wheat beer with this yeast, at the same pitch rate (1 gram per gallon), with various fermentation profiles. I am absolutely in love with this Dunkelweizen I just made. Even though it's dark in color, it goes down just as easily as any of my Hefeweizens. Give this recipe a shot. It's a winner.
View attachment 879552
https://share.brewfather.app/HUboMt91wpbEAG
The key with these styles is getting them DRY. I want to see 1.008 on the hydrometer, 1.010 at the absolute maximum.
Sounds like my type of yeast! I like Schneider Weisse, I think the regular is called Nr. 7. That also has virtually zero banana but a lot of clove.I just bought this W-68 yeast to try it out in my attempt to make some hefeweizen.
I've been recently trying out some different classical hefeweizens and had noticed that most of, if not all of them had the banana aroma and flavor quite restrained. It was there but quite subtle, I had to look for it a bit so to speak. I found these beer much more dominant on the phenolic side paired with lovely wheat malt flavors and aromas. The beers I had tried were Schneider dunkel, Ayinger Brauweise, Franziskaner HefeWeiss, Weihenstephaner and some others which I can name here later. Is that normal or am I getting these beers not fresh enough? Supposedly the isoamyl acetate can disapear relatively quickly.
I am familiar with doing a ferulic acid rest in general. I'm wondering what kind of profile regarding phenolics do you guys/girls get from the W-68 yeast? Is it strong on phenolics? Should I do the ferulic acid rest or would I be making a totally unbalanced beer? I've read that some of these german wheat beers can be more or less expressive on either banana or clove side. I do like the banana restrained like in the beers I had tried and that's the profile I'm looking for.
I am disappointed in the attenuation of this yeast. I brewed a smoked dunkelweizen that started at 1.050 and finished at 1.015 for 68% attenuation. Mashed at 147 for 30 minutes and 162 for 30 minutes and used 1 package of yeast. Water chemistry was adjusted properly and fermented between 68 and 71 degrees. It's conditioning now so I haven't had a chance to taste it yet.
Granted, this is the first time I did a 147/162 mash.
What's everyone else getting for attenuation with this yeast?
That's what I have thought. I'll make the usual wort I make with 50% wheat malt, including ferulic acid rest, and proceed with pitching the whole sachet and ferment in the basement at around 20-22 degrees celsius. Will report on the results here.Overpitching would favor the clove vs banana. You can ferment cooler to favor the clove as well. Say 62F.
I am always unclear on how many actual cells are in dry yeast packets. So pitching the entire packet is not necessarily a bad thing. The best approach is to pitch the entire packet, pick a fermentation temperature and see how it turns out. Then adjust for your next brew.
Great tip! Will consider that for sure. I have rice hulls on hand so I should be safe enough regarding lautering. The other half of the grain will be pilnser malt which should let the wheat flavor shine I presume.I like to push the wheat to 60 or 65% to bring out the wheat flavor. As well as double mill just the wheat. But that is if your system can lauter this without a stuck mash.
Yep. The wheat, if a large enough percentage of the grain bill, adds a unique character imho. Kind of tangy/spicy? I just try to make the hefeweizen taste different from the barley beers as it is a unique style.