That practice of collecting from a secondary is generally discouraged. There's a good chance the secondary doesn't contain the same population as the original yeast (starter). The more flocculent population has settled out in the primary, while the less flocculent ones get transferred to the secondary.One thing I can think is I collected yeast from the secondary and not the primary.
I'd build up a good size starter, freeze some and save some as slurries in the fridge in small 4 oz jelly jars for starters later on.I’m disappointed because i can’t get this yeast again and I really wanted to use it. I have one more smack pack I can work with and try again.
For example, I'm still using yeast I bought in 2015 (a few even older), many were partially used, still in the original (East Coast Yeast) bottles they came in. So far, they've had no problems resurrecting themselves.
Which yeast strain is it?
Yes, many of us are wishing for more frequent WYeast "seasonal" re-issues. I've missed a few I wanted and they've never reappeared. Not much one can do than moving on, and keeping an eye out. Similar for White Labs' yeast vault...