I did make a starter. It is only my second starter ever made.
Here is what I am worried happened. After I made my first starter, I dumped the entire solution into the wort.
I started reading that this isn't necessary and that it can be better to stick your starter in the fridge and let the yeast settle out, then decant a majority of the liquid.
Well, I made a dumb drunk mistake and decided to use this technique. Problem was I did it like 90 minutes before I needed to pitch.
I did see a large amount of yeast in the bottom of the Erlenmeyer flask but my guess is I probably dumped a decent amount of yeast down the drain because I was in a hurry to make some beer and excited to use a new technique
Sent from my iPhone using Home Brew
What happened here is you likely selected for less attenuative members of the population by only pitching the yeast that settled first. High flocculation is typically correlated with lower attenuation. The yeasts still in solution that you dumped are also the yeasts more likely to stay in solution in the beer and chew through the fermentable sugars before dropping out.