Shaun of the Dead VS Tucker and Dale vs EVIL

Only vote if you've seen both.

If you haven't seen one or the other, do yourself a favor and go rent it.

OH HELL!!!!

I was TORN!

Tucker and dale by just a hair.

I'm not voting. It's a protest.

I voted twice, once for me and once to spite TxBrew's protesting self

T and D v E!!

I voted for SotD because it's one of those movies I can see over and over again. I've seen it about 5-7 times and TDvE only once. They are both good movies, but there's a clear winner here.

I now hate myself for choosing.....

IT'S LIKE CHOOSING ONE OF YOUR CHILDREN OVER ANOTHER!!!"!!WHY DIDN'T I LISTEN TEX? WHY????!

cheezydemon3 said:

I now hate myself for choosing.....

IT'S LIKE CHOOSING ONE OF YOUR CHILDREN OVER ANOTHER!!!"!!WHY DIDN'T I LISTEN TEX? WHY????!

Click to expand...

And which did you go with?

I can't choose and you can't make me. My first thought was SoTD, of course, it's a classic. And then I thought, but T & D vs. Evil is so good. So I stared at the choices for a few minutes while inner conflict raged and then I thought, "This is stupid. They can't make me choose." And life was once again good.

Shaun of the Dead, no contest.

While I appreciate the concept, Tucker and Dale was just too stupidly unrealistic to be enjoyable.

bierhaus15 said:

Shaun of the Dead, no contest.

While I appreciate the concept, Tucker and Dale was just too stupidly unrealistic to be enjoyable.

Click to expand...

While in Shaun of the dead however, they calmly react to the zompacolypse with dry British humor...

Shaun of the Dead, all the way. I found Tucker and Dale vs Evil rather boring. I fell asleep. Sorry to those of you who loved it.

Uziyahu said:

Shaun of the Dead, all the way. I found Tucker and Dale vs Evil rather boring. I fell asleep. Sorry to those of you who loved it.

Click to expand...

Maybe you were already asleep and watching a boring version in your dream?

bierhaus15 said:

Shaun of the Dead, no contest.

While I appreciate the concept, Tucker and Dale was just too stupidly unrealistic to be enjoyable.

Click to expand...

DOES NOT COMPUTE.

NO supernatural, no preternatural, a few coincidences VS

Zed apocalypse where the dead rise and do humorous things amidst a fair number of coincidences.

punkerdru said:

While in Shaun of the dead however, they calmly react to the zompacolypse with dry British humor...

Click to expand...

And kill zombies with vinyl! (You've got some red on you!)

Uziyahu said:

Shaun of the Dead, all the way. I found Tucker and Dale vs Evil rather boring. I fell asleep. Sorry to those of you who loved it.

Click to expand...

does you have a freaking PULSE???????

Kidding. But you liked Sean of the dead, right?

TxBrew said:

Maybe you were already asleep and watching a boring version in your dream?

Click to expand...

Or maybe he really digs the dry british wit so much (like me da') that he could actually like SOD without liking the genre.

ONLY explanation.

Anyone else?

I went with TADVE but it was a tough choice.

They won due to having a really hot chick.

TADVE was awesome. Sad to say I have not seen Shaun. I'll have to correct that and cast my ballot.

American comedy trumps British comedy everytime....

Blasphemy in this thread, I'm sure, but I never cared for SoTD. Just watched Tucker & Dale this weekend with the wife, and we both laughed constantly. So that gets my vote!

Homercidal said:

I went with TADVE but it was a tough choice.

They won due to having a really hot chick.

Click to expand...

Man you aren't kidding. She is the girl you could fall in love with in 4.5 seconds.

jeepinjeepin said:

TADVE was awesome. Sad to say I have not seen Shaun. I'll have to correct that and cast my ballot.

Click to expand...

Godd on you, and yes, you will be glad you did.

NervousDad said:

American comedy trumps British comedy everytime....

Click to expand...

Monty Python anyone??????????Hot Fuzz????

CastleHollow said:

Blasphemy in this thread, I'm sure, but I never cared for SoTD. Just watched Tucker & Dale this weekend with the wife, and we both laughed constantly. So that gets my vote!

Click to expand...

Equally Blasphemous my friend!!!!!!!



SOD was my FAVORITE movie for 9 years or so!!!!! AWESOME!!!!!

"She's engaged"
"That was fast"

Tucker and Dale is a hair sillier, but no less ingenious!!!!

"Well Howdy doo Officer! Are We glad to see you!"

*shocked that we have a tie, I now feel that SOD should be winning....a reversal of my vote*

I would like to reiterate my position on not voting.

I demand to not be heard!

T and d all the way. Sod was good, but not nearly as good as the other.

TxBrew said:

I would like to reiterate my position on not voting.

I demand to not be heard!

Click to expand...

Um, not reading you then good buddy.......10-4.....over and out......

I guess I wanted to hear differing opinions.

I am amazed that people are not like you and I.

I casually mentioned that T and D was on par with SOD and got some passionate responses.

I would like to hear those that prefer one over the other, and why.

Why do i have to pick only one???? Why can't i like both of them equally? Why does this have to be so hard????????

DAMMITTTTTTT!!!!!!!!!!

OK. Not an attention whore, but Tex and static have convinced me FLAWED POLL!!!!!!!!!!!!

DAMMIT DAMMIT DAMMIT.

I pride myself on complete polls....

https://www.homebrewtalk.com/f19/tucker-dale-evil-vs-shaun-dead-version-2-0-a-347595/

FIXED