im my studies, it seems to me that ale was never carbonated in any concious way... that once fermented didnt last more than a few days so once the fermentation vessel was opened, it was consumed as is... yeast and all... i think thats how i want to do mine at first... drink it when its done fermenting without bottling or carbonating.. right from the carboy...
so im going to take my ingredients, boil them down to syrup, add more water and the hops, boil it down to the 1 gallon i need... then let it cool, syphon it into the carboy i have, cork it with my little gas release device in it.. let it ferment a specific period of time... then open it up and have at it... when i find the recipe i want to stick with i will have find some way of preserving it without too much carbonization or refridgeration
something i should mention.. i have an issue with my esophagus... the lower 2/3 of it have nerve damage, and as a result i havent drank carbonated drinks in a very long time as the carbonization, as well as cold temperature liquids tend to agitate the issue which is another reason why im curious in beers made before carbonization and refridgeration