srm775 said:
You think that the population of Madison Wisconsin hasn't changed, if not dramatically then significantly, in the last say 30 years (since you were a child)?
2003 Census estimate has the population of Madison doubled since 1980.
Regardless, because of industry consolidation the choices to shop are getting fewer and fewer while the super-mega shopping stores take over ... fewer places to shop means higher densities (pun intended) in those places still around.
I am not an idiot. Yes there is a higher headcount in Madison today tan 10 years ago.
there is a difference between population and density.
I'd venture to guess that the density of the population in developed areas in madison wi hasn't changed much in 10 years. There are many areas of madison that were cornfields 10 years ago. Now they are suburbian cookie cutter housing.
I think it is safe to say that on a daily basis I see about as many people as I did 10 years ago. This means that wile there might e a higher headcount in city limits, I am exposed to the same number of people. Unless there are more children per capita, I still see the same number of kids as before.
Census data doesn't tell the whole story any more than anecdotal stories do.
As for 'reduced shopping choices'-- I don't see that at all. The choices have changed but I don't see much change there. In fact, in many cases there are more options in terms of stores than before (although produts in the US have homogonized, but that is not a fuction of population density in the city).
Take Grocery stores: There were once 3 major choices: Woodman's, Willy St coop and Kohl's. Now there are LOTS of choices: Woodman's, Pick n Save, Whole Foods, Trader Joes, Target, Cub's, Sentry, Willy Street... and that's without counting any smaller corner stores (I can picutre but not name 3 different mexican groceries alone).
Now, has Madison lost the nice, convienent little strip of quirky specialty stores on state street? Largely, yes. As rents climbed an the downtown area revitalized, the small stores couldn't make it on their thin margins anymore. So those stores got scattered and, unfortunately, this also means that many folded, since the loss of the 'quirky stores' were not a destination store and they depended on the foot traffic that a central 'quirky store distirct' brought them.