Fresh MBP is still one of my favorite beers ever. Sadly, the last bottle, I opened was pretty tart and lost a lot of the honey and maple that evened out the smokiness. Same with the last tapping at homestead, but not as bad as the bottle. Bacon fudge brownies turned into cherries in an ashtray. There were also big chunks of black mass in the bottoms of our glasses after we dumped it. I think the people who have recently traded for their first bottle, or had it on tap at Huna are experiencing the latter, which is why it is getting a bad reputation lately.
It sucks because that beer in its prime holds its own against most of the big boys out there, and those people will never experience that and just write it off as an overhyped flavor of the week. It also fuels the fire when people put bottles like that up for trade before it is even released and ask for the world, because then they want to hate it before even having it. Sadly enough there are tickers out there who will trade for a hyped beer just for the satisfaction of shitting on it, whether it tastes good or not.