Why wouldn't it be about making the playoffs this year though? I could see this line of thinking if the Pirates were last in the division, had zero chance at a playoff spot, and were in the midst of a full-blown rebuild.
Chris Archer might improve the team, but the Pirates do not bend over backwards to try to improve the team at all costs. They only will if the price is right. They also can't draft and they will never sign a marquee free agent. I think that prolonged success in MLB compared to the other three major sports is the toughest, and with a "small market" team like the Pirates who look to shed payroll every chance they get and will never be able to compete with other NL teams like the Phillies/Cubs/Dodgers when it comes to acquiring talent, swinging for the fences at the trade deadline when competing for a division title is their best chance at competing for a championship.