Not-So-Secret-Santa Christmas Swap

[sfgoat]

I'm just hoping to get some good feedback on mine. Be forewarned, I'm not a BJCP judge, but I'm going to be brutality honest with my reviews, as I hope others well be with mine.

This is of the utmost importance IMHO.

 

[BGBC]

I really don't mind doing it. In fact I already went into it knowing I'd ship to at least 2 people if we wound up with an odd number.

No, you shouldn't have to do this either, unless you're planning on pairing people up.

Think of a swap between three people. One possibility: 1 ships to 2, 2 ships 3, 3 ships to 1.

 

[poptarts]

This is of the utmost importance IMHO.

agree fully 100%

 

[poptarts]

No, you shouldn't have to do this either, unless you're planning on pairing people up.

Think of a swap between three people. One possibility: 1 ships to 2, 2 ships 3, 3 ships to 1.

http://namedrawing.com/index.php

This is a really good tool to set up swaps like this. although im totally down for getting beer from finsfan.

 

[coyote68]

http://namedrawing.com/index.php

This is a really good tool to set up swaps like this. although im totally down for getting beer from finsfan.

yes... finsfan has some really good beers!!
I've also had real good brews from sfgoat and Liquidflame

 

[finsfan]

yes... finsfan has some really good beers!!
I've also had real good brews from sfgoat and Liquidflame

Dont be so humble, your beers are incredible! I would love to try beers from most of this group, very excited to see who I have and who got myself! Give out the names already!!!

 

[Weezy]

I don't see the need to cap imho... but I think we should require everyone to come Vback here and give honest feedback on the beers.

(and coyote does make good beers)

 

[coyote68]

I don't see the need to cap imho... but I think we should require everyone to come Vback here and give honest feedback on the beers.

(and coyote does make good beers)

Thanks weezy...haven't seen ya in a while.

 

[bford]

I'm more in this for fun, the spirit of giving, the holiday season....etc.


Sorry if you are the person that gets my mostly average beer. I've been doing this for about a year. I don't use any water chemistry.... or liquid yeast and starters...I make small batches on my stove top... bottle by hand... try to keep things on schedule, but sometimes life gets in the way. Still I enjoy it.. but I'm not worried about getting a gold medal anytime soon.

 

[jrowland74]

I'm more in this for fun, the spirit of giving, the holiday season....etc.


Sorry if you are the person that gets my mostly average beer. I've been doing this for about a year. I don't use any water chemistry.... or liquid yeast and starters...I make small batches on my stove top... bottle by hand... try to keep things on schedule, but sometimes life gets in the way. Still I enjoy it.. but I'm not worried about getting a gold medal anytime soon.

I agree, bford, but I also want honestly brutal feedback. I have been brewing for about a year and trust me, life often gets in the way. I am still very proud of my creations and look forward to some experienced feedback. I'm sure whoever gets yours will be happy with it. Doesn't have to be perfect. That's the beauty of this obsession er... Hobby. I believe everyone on the list is doing it mostly for fun and with holiday spirit.

 

[jrowland74]

Double post

 

[sfgoat]

We have one spot left to get in on the swap.

 

[sfgoat]

Need to fill one more spot in the swap by the end of the day. Let me know if you are interested.

 

[BGBC]

Bump

 

[poptarts]

Bump

 

[sfgoat]

Alright, I have sent out the addresses via PM to everyone. I used the online tool provided by poptarts to select for everyone so it was completely random. Just remember to have your packages sent out no later than 12/15/2014 and lets enjoy the swap.

 

[jrowland74]

Package shipped via FedEx to Marckw. Scheduled delivery in 2 business days. PM with tracking number sent.

 

[cmoewes]

Wow is there a prize for first to ship

 

[pointcity-homebrew]

I have some bottles ready to ship, but I want to get another batch bottled and at least carbing before I ship. I will be cutting it close to the deadline.

 

[LiquidFlame]

I have some bottles ready to ship, but I want to get another batch bottled and at least carbing before I ship. I will be cutting it close to the deadline.

Kind of in the same boat

 

[Hello]

I want to try and bottle from the keg for this. I have two stouts so hopefully my guy likes stouts.

 

[finsfan]

I have some bottles ready to ship, but I want to get another batch bottled and at least carbing before I ship. I will be cutting it close to the deadline.

I think as long as its bottled, I Would send it. You can always have your recipient hold onto it for a few weeks before drinking.

I should have mine all packed up and shipped today! :rockin:

 

[pointcity-homebrew]

I think as long as its bottled, I Would send it. You can always have your recipient hold onto it for a few weeks before drinking.

I should have mine all packed up and shipped today! :rockin:

Yeah, I was in the same situation on the last swap. I just have not had time to brew during the year.
Things are starting to slow down, here at work, so I was able to brew 3 batches. I bottled one last week and plan to bottle 1 this week and 1 next week. I am doing this hoping they are at least drinkable. "fingers crossed"

 

[sfgoat]

I'm kind of torn right now on my porter. it had an OG of 1.078 and finished at 1.029 using Wyeast 1469 (West Yorkshire). It tastes good at 6.5% ABV but I've never had a beer finish that high. What do you guys think. Bottle it as is? Or pitch some Nottingham on it and hope it does more work?

I was planning to ship this one out but now I'm not so sure.

 

[LiquidFlame]

I'm kind of torn right now on my porter. it had an OG of 1.078 and finished at 1.029 using Wyeast 1469 (West Yorkshire). It tastes good at 6.5% ABV but I've never had a beer finish that high. What do you guys think. Bottle it as is? Or pitch some Nottingham on it and hope it does more work?

I was planning to ship this one out but now I'm not so sure.

What was your intended FG?

 

[sfgoat]

What was your intended FG?

Style guidelines say between 1.016 and 1.024.

 

[jrowland74]

I was planning to wait as well. The first beer I have brewed using my own made up recipe is in primary right now. I use the set and forget kegging method, so by the time it's done in primary, dry hopped, and carbed, the deadline will have long passed. Oh well, I replaced it with some good local craft beer.

 

[BGBC]

I think as long as its bottled, I Would send it. You can always have your recipient hold onto it for a few weeks before drinking.

I should have mine all packed up and shipped today! :rockin:

I'm sending at least one that won't be ready to drink for a little bit. Samples have all tasted good so far though, and I know my recipient is a fan of the style, so I don't think he'll mind too much.

 

[coyote68]

All packed up shipping tomorrow morning.
only had 7 ready so added a couple commercials... just to balance out the box

 

[finsfan]

All packed up shipping tomorrow morning.
only had 7 ready so added a couple commercials... just to balance out the box

Haha same here, only had 7. I thought I had more but 7 isnt bad.