beervoid
Hophead & Pellet Rubber
I tried a heavy dose of whirlpool, 10oz mosaic on 5 gallons with a relatively small dose of dry hop 3oz mosaic.I’m literally so sick of hearing these two statements. Whirlpool provides a lot of flavor and Aroma. You can certainly tell the difference between 3oz whirlpool and a 6 oz whirlpool. Hotside Provides a different set of flavor and Aroma than dryhoping does. A perfect example of a beer that uses higher hotside hops than DH is Sip of Sunshine from Lawson’s. Would you say that beer lacks flavor or aroma? Its just a different flavor/aroma profile than let’s say a TH beer.
Have you ever tried an all dryhop beer or an all WH beer? I have and I can tell you that the wh beer was better and still had a nice aroma. Don’t get me wrong it still seemed like it was missing something, but the DH only beer, though the aroma was great, it’s flavor was delicate and missing assertiveness. I get that people have their preferences on which ratio they like better, I’m usually 40/60 or 60/40 depending on the hops I’m using, but to say you’ll get the same flavor by halving your whirlpool in my experience is just not true.
Beer was ok but didnt stand out.
Never did whirlpool only but I have been lowering my wp additions with success. I also still play with different hop kinds (cascade, centennial, columbus, chinook) with or without citra and mosaic in the mix. Added cryo in the mix for more flavor saturation.
Kept the dry hop the same. I couldnt taste a difference between all these batches. To me it seems a decent dry hop dose overpowers everything.
I always taste my beer pre dry hop as well. It just tastes hoppy and similar. Maybe my palette is not good recognizing the difference pre dry hopped.
Not claiming that wp doesnt have a function but I dont think large amounts of hops are neccesary.
If you listen to the pro's the rates I have heard be used mostly are just a litle more then 1lbs per barrel which comes down to 2 to 3oz per 5 gallons.
Must have something to do with saturation and loss of delicate oils by fermentation.
Could you describe what kind of flavor differences you get from different amounts of wp additions and different hops? (apart from bitterness)
Last edited: