user 40839
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Jul 13, 2009
- Messages
- 1,176
- Reaction score
- 86
That's true - the initial platform was open source, he sold the boards to those who were unwilling/unable to make up one a DIY board on their own. In that sense, having boards printed would have been technically been "competition" against him. So suppose the question then is if he's no longer making, distributing, or selling the boards, is it still the case? If someone is willing to purchase a BrewPi Spark, would being able to get a pre-printed Arduino board (granted, they'd still have to solder the components on themselves) dissuade them from doing so, and cause them to go DIY? Probably not, thinking about it.I took the initiative and removed the Arduino entirely. No PCBs, no shields, everything wired directly to Pi GPIO with DuPont cables.
All you really need is a Pi and a dual relay board, then you can do everything via the web interface. Adding an LCD is easy, as there are many modules that will plug in to the GPIO (I used an old Nokia cellphone display as they are very cheap).
The long-running "How to make a BrewPi controller for cheap" thread may or may not have been taking money out of Elco's pocket. It certainly has raised awareness of BrewPi, but it was his decision to open-source it, which comes with benefits and drawbacks. Hopefully the benefits outweigh the drawbacks and he's doing ok.
For me, I really liked the old interface - I (and this is a personal thing, everyone's mileage varies) loved the LCD display because while the web interface is nice, being able to just glance at it when in the garage, as I was passing was useful. As was being able to use the rotary dial to initiate a cold crash instead of having to root for a phone or laptop. There's something just nice about seeing mine sitting there. I mean...