One Lake Brewing opened pretty suddenly about a week ago and today I finally had time to take an extra long grocery store trip to try them out. I saw the tap list a couple days prior online and it didn't give me confidence. The beers themselves didn't change my mind.
I'm not looking for a hazy-pastry hype brewery but, at the very least, pretend the last 20 years of American beer happened. In 2019, you maybe should have something more adventurous than a dark mild, which was absolutely the most unique thing on the menu. It also had a tinge of diacetyl so there's that. The pale ale (cascade and centennial, straight out of 2004) was soapy. The schwartzbier was pretty bitter on the backend. The milk stout had no discernable milk stout characteristics- at that point I would have been happy to have discovered it to be pastry-like- and was just... bland. I know blonde ales appeal to a big portion of the populace but... is there any way to differentiate that from the place on the other side of town?
This is the 3rd brewery in the area that basically brews the same things, though at least Exit Strategy tries to be interesting (and is overall well crafted stuff). Is appealing to neighborhood people who don't particularly care about beer the basis for a long-term business plan? Because that's the only thing I can see keeping places like that afloat.
Not every place needs to be Off Color but at least be ******* Begyle.
They're walking distance from me and have a menu so I'll definitely hit it again, probably with the family for dinner or something. But if it wasn't as close as it was, I'd say stay away at least for a while and hope they're better in the long run.
ETA: I just thought of this: maybe there's a retro portion of the beer community that is like "I would like Chicago beer to be like it was before Three Floyds showed up."