• Please visit and share your knowledge at our sister communities:
  • If you have not, please join our official Homebrewing Facebook Group!

    Homebrewing Facebook Group

Extremely basic first cider turned out great, almost....

Homebrew Talk

Help Support Homebrew Talk:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

TasunkaWitko

Well-Known Member
Joined
Mar 27, 2014
Messages
2,824
Reaction score
986
Location
Chinook
Hi, all -

After several false starts and a lot of other little things getting in the way, I finally got to make a 1-gallon batch of cider late last year.

I kept it very, very basic, simply using a gallon of Musselman's natural apple cider (pasteurized, but with no preservatives) and some Red Star Premier Cuvée yeast.

I fermented for about 4 weeks, then bottled with honey as a priming sugar. It was quite cloudy going into the bottles, but somewhere in there, the cider settled and it was amazingly, beautifully clear after 3 or 4 weeks - absolutely beautiful!

After several weeks of bottle conditioning, I sampled a bottle. It was very light, effervescent and clear, as mentioned above; no over-carbonation issues, but still very bubbly in a refreshing way - the bubbles kept rising after quite a long while in the glass, and never did quit that I can remember. Since it was still quite young, I was expecting a "rhino fart" smell, and it was there, of course.

The rhino farts were was also in the flavour, quite a bit. I wouldn't go as far as to say it tasted bad, because it had an honest, no-frills quality that could actually be appreciated if drinking it chilled on a hot day after doing some work outside. Having said that, it is definitely not what most people would think of, and it is probably not something you would want to serve to friends, family or the preacher visiting for dinner.

I let the cider condition another month or so, and then sampled again. The rhino fart aroma was still there, but not nearly as much. My understanding is that by the time we get well into summer, that smell will be pretty much gone. The flavour, however, was still pretty rhino-ish; it was less, but not as diminished as I expected.

Considering that there was no back-sweetening involved, is this what I should be experiencing? I really can't say that I didn't like it - it was a man's drink, not candy-sweet at all. but there wasn't much actual apple flavour that I could detect, unless it is underneath. All-in-all, it was good enough that I prefer it over a bunch of complicated engineering of the drink.

I started this looking for a farmhouse-style cider with no frills, and my guess is that this is what I got - and I want to fiddle with it as little as possible. But it was my first batch, so any guidance would be appreciated. My first try managed to get me nearly everything I was trying to get, except that actual apple flavour, which might be a myth of false expectation anyway; however, if there is a yeast or other method (such as starting with juice rather than cider) that will help with this, I am certainly all ears.
 
Unfortunately, you won't get that much apple flavour because true apple juice is very fermentable. As far as the rhino farts go, you bottled hyper early for your recipe. Most people would leave it for more like 6 months before bottling. By then your rhino far smell/taste will be gone. Even if you prime and bottle.

Checkout edworts apfelwein. It's essentially what you described with a bit of a dextrose boost. So give it more time next time and let us know how it goes!
 
Thanks for the reply, electro - i'll give edworts apfelwein a look-see.

As for the cider, I'll be sure to leave it for a longer period of time before bottling.
 
Use yeast nutrient and yeast energizer (google: free amino nitrogen for yeast) to avoid the 'fart' smell. Apple juice is almost all sugar/water, without the trace nutrients and minerals that yeast needs for a clean ferment.
Also, I use dry beer yeast (s-04 or nottingham) for my ciders. With the above, I get no yucky aromas. Worse ever was mere diacetyl in the first week of fermentation.
 
Use yeast nutrient and yeast energizer (google: free amino nitrogen for yeast) to avoid the 'fart' smell. Apple juice is almost all sugar/water, without the trace nutrients and minerals that yeast needs for a clean ferment.
Also, I use dry beer yeast (s-04 or nottingham) for my ciders. With the above, I get no yucky aromas. Worse ever was mere diacetyl in the first week of fermentation.

Yup. Add some nutrients and use a different yeast. I prefer us-05, but us-04 works well. I rarely carb mine, but thats the way I like it. If you want more apple flavor, kill the yeast with a camden tablet when its done. Then back sweeten with some fresh apple juice. It wont be carbed (unless you wanna force carb in a keg) but it will be sweeter.

I typically let mine sit in the fermenter for about a month, with a secondary in the middle. Then bottle condition for another month or two. That is plenty of time for it to mellow out. But, I also love the "fresh" taste as well. I will usually put half the bottles away for a month or two, and drink the half right away. You get it ice cold, like almost freezing, and I love the way it tastes. Dry with a bit of a bite. Im pretty sure I have had at least one gallon fermenting all the time for the last 3-4 years. Its my favorite drink. Especially in the summer, out on the boat.
 
I've ordered some of each and will give them a try next time for comparison.

So far, with the apfelwein, I have noticed no rhino farts in spite of some very vigorous fermentation; but then again, I haven't had my face right down in it, either.
 
So-called rhino farts simply point to poor technique. They occur only because you have put the yeast under enough stress and strain to produce hydrogen sulfide. If you provide the right yeast with the appropriate nutrients and ferment at the appropriate temperatures hydrogen sulfide does not occur.

As to getting good apple flavor from apples , sorry but my experience has been quite different. You get what you pay for and quality apple juice made from apples grown for traditional cider produces great flavor.
 
Well, it was pretty good for a first attempt, and I gained experience on which to learn. As for this first batch, I am sampling another right now, and it has improved yet more; it seems to me that maturity is definitely a key element here. I guess it depends on what one is looking for ~

tumblr_mgpfuwW4qi1r71icao1_400.jpg
 

Latest posts

Back
Top