I've got a batch of this fermenting now. Woot! I played with the grain bill a bit since I was short on vienna, but otherwise it's pretty close. We'll see in a few weeks.
I made this one a few weeks ago and have had it on tap now for about a week. Very nice beer with great color. I went the traditional route and went all Cascade. Hit all the numbers exactly. Used WLP007 (dry English ale).
I'm wondering if anyone has ever put this into a BJCP comp in the APA category? It is a very malty beer in terms of malt flavor (not sweetness) - bready, nutty. I used MO and Munich and Vienna as listed in the first post. I like the flavors and it is a highly drinkable beer, but the malt flavors almost fit more in the English pale ale category (despite the obvious use of American hops). So I was just curious if anyone had ever sent this to a competition as an APA and the results.
Wow,7 months bottled and this is still great,use the Ivanhoe hops. I think I may make this again my next batch using all Columbus-this time. May try that new Bry-97 if avalible also.
The BRY97 yeast is pretty good, but be warned, it takes a while to get going, finishes fast once it starts, and takes a bit longer to clear. Leave a bit of a yeasty-ish finish on the nose of the beer if it's not dry hopped heavy.
I'm wondering if anyone has ever put this into a BJCP comp in the APA category?
RugenBrau said:I don't have any Vienna. How would this work with 5lbs of Munich?
I was going to dry hop with 2 oz. for 5 days
I don't have any Vienna. How would this work with 5lbs of Munich?
try half pilsner half munich or I would use like 2/3 pilsner 1/3 munich of your 5 #. Its about as close as you can get maybe without using vienna. I dont think I would use that much 5# to be close to this recipe. Not saying you may not like it, but just to be closer dont think I would use more than 3 if you dont have pilsner. I would think 2.5 and call it good with straight munich. Just my opinion.
Chuckabrewski said:So the LHBS didnt have any vienna and subbed it for 2 lb caravienna
Chuckabrewski said:Yea i just looked it up. I wish I knew that earlier I cut the recipe down to 10lb so its 2lb caravienna in place of 3lb vienna. What is that going to do to the taste slightly sweeter?
Chuckabrewski said:How did yours turn out?
It was my first AG, so I was amazed by it. I do not know what 30% crystal will do in a pale ale though. If it was your LHBS idea to sub caravienne for Vienna, call them and take it back. They should know better.
*edit- I'm assuming this was mixed and crushed together
Chuckabrewski said:sure is
I would call them and take it back, if it was your idea (they still should have questioned you) you would have to add 20lb of base, mix it well and divide it by 3 to come close to what the author intended. Or you can make it and let us know what 30% crystal is like in a pale, I have no clue what it would be like.
I have been drinking, so my math is most likely flawed.
Chuckabrewski said:They are closed already and not open till Tuesday so I'm just going to brew it up. I have some corn sugar laying around ill toss in there too. At the end of the day it will still be beer.