I don't know if I'll be able to figure it out. I tried to stick to the recipe, but had to make a couple close subs. And I brew BIAB, so I upped the amount of the base grain by one pound, to hit efficiency...that *might* have been my mistake in flavor... and my mash temperature is tough to regulate. Then I ferment at room temp in my house...usually around 69-70F in Nov through May (a few degrees higher in warmer months). I haven't nailed down my carb issue yet. I replaced my racking tubing and I'm using carboys instead of bottling buckets for fermentation, but I've always been a nut about cleaning and sanitizing. I've decided to start running my bottles through the dishwasher, too; instead of just using the bottle washer with Starsan. If you haven't been experiencing any issues with your system, I would say you will be safe following Yooper's recipe as closely as possible...read through the thread! Sorry to rattle on!
So, to close out the birthday, Yooper's Oatmeal Stout w/ Gingerbread. Same carb issue; fresh ginger is strong in the nose and flavor...the "bread" part is way in the background still. Better drinking beer, though. Ginger covers the twang.