You'd be selecting out the least flocculant cells if you harvest from secondary, so you want to avoid that.
If you do primary/secondary, consider that harvesting from primary leaves some of the highest attenuating cells behind, and you keep the highest flocculating population. Which do you prefer?
Think about harvesting from your starter - then you have all the flocculating and attenuating cells...
Bummer about the infection. My two cents: get your sanitation practices dialed in. Certainly. But then you may want to read the first post in each of these threads before you give washing another go:Made a rookie mistake. Didn't have time to do full wash, so just threw the slurry into two mason jars.
Left to settle over the weekend, decanted beer off, filled up with water and let it settle again for a few days.
Went back today to do actual wash + separate from trub, damn jars smelled sour and rancid.
Sanitation fail!
Really hoping that the infection wasn't present before I started my modified-lazy-man-wash.
Just a note, I tried using yeast that I washed 5 months ago, and it did not work. After 24 hours there was no sign of fermentation.
And I just had a starter bubble for 2 days using 3.5 month old rinsed yeast.Just a note, I tried using yeast that I washed 5 months ago, and it did not work. After 24 hours there was no sign of fermentation.
What's the difference between 2 and 3?I was inspired by this thread to give rinsing/harvesting yeast a try (I harvested this batch of WLP002 yesterday). I'm sorry if this has been answered, but the thread is 200 pages +. Please tell me if i have this right, I included some pics of my harvest
1. As long as I use the yeast within one week I can pitch it directly (after bringing it to room temp) into the cooled wort
2. If I use it within two weeks, I need to add some wort or DME to wake up yeast and pitch
3. After two weeks a starter will be required
What's the difference between 2 and 3?]I was reading from several sources and it seemed like a good average. I guess the difference (other than 7 days) is there has to be a cut off somewhere, and I'm trying to make this as simple as I can. Hopefully, after some experience I can refine the practice a little. I am planning on making high gravity brew this weekend with one of the collected jars and wanted to make see if anyone has success with pitching it straight from the jar (after brought up to room temp)
To me making a starter is the same as adding DME, so that's why I was confused.What's the difference between 2 and 3?]
I was reading from several sources and it seemed like a good average. I guess the difference (other than 7 days) is there has to be a cut off somewhere, and I'm trying to make this as simple as I can. Hopefully, after some experience I can refine the practice a little. I am planning on making high gravity brew this weekend with one of the collected jars and wanted to make see if anyone has success with pitching it straight from the jar (after brought up to room temp)
Here's what you'd enter in Mr. Malty:Matt, I rinsed it according to the original post. However, I split the batch in thirds rather than fourths. I'm going for a 1.075 OG.