I typed up my raw notes and added them to my previous yeast ranking:
Yeast Roundup, Version 1.3
Drinkable as-is:
1. Voss Kveik. Score: 970, 1.085OG. 0.993FG (correction: 0.995FG) Slight grapey or winelike flavor. No real aroma. Costco hone Pitched 3/6. Added 2x DAP 3/7 because smelled sulfurous. 2 hour degass 4/7. Almost clear, but very hazy 4/12. Cold crash 4/12. Bentonite 4/13. Crystl clear 4/14. Stabilized 4/18.
2. M05 Score: 960. 1.105OG, 0.995FG (correction:0.997FG). Great taste. May still be fermenting. Costco honey. Pitched 3/15. Racked 4/14. Stabilized 4/17.
3. Fresco. Score: 950, 1.103OG, 0.994FG (correction:0.996FG). Walker Wildflower honey. Not much aroma, but tastes good and very drinkable even as is. Basically a "clean" taste. Chemex filtered. Orangey color. Pitched 3/19. Fully degass 3/27. Degassed again 4/4. Super degassed 4/7. Fermentation confirmed "done" on 4/11. Racket 4/8. 4 hour degassed 4/9. Still highly hazy 4/13. Cold crashed 4/13. Bentonite 4/14. Filtered 4/16. Stabilized 4/17.
4. Wyeast Sweet Mead. Score: 945, 1.085OG. 0.992FG (correction: 0.994FG). Cherry notes. Drinkable as-is. Costco honey. Orange color. Crystal clear 4/4. Degassed 4/6. Stabilized 4/18.
5. M31. Score: 943, 1.105OG, 0.996FG (correction: 0.998FG). (0.998FG measured by TILT prior to dilution). Costco honey. Pitched 3/15. Needed some extra nitrogen. Bentonite 4/18. Stabilized 4/18. 19 hour degassing 1/19. Sleight band-aid flavor. Hot flavor.
6. Fresco. Score: 940, 1.085OG, 0.997FG (correction: 0.999FG). Clear. Not much unique taste or aroma. However, drinkable as is. Costco honey. Chemex filtered. Pitched 3/8. Done 4/1, but heavy haze never cleared. Racked 4/8. 12 hour degass 4/9. Medium hazy, cold crash 4/13. 1/2 teaspoon bentonite 4/14. Filtered 4/15. Stabilized 4/17.
7. KV-1116. Score: 850, OG 1.105OG, 0.996FG (correction: 0.998FG). Slight bluecheese aroma. Fruity, winelike taste. Drinkable as-is. Costco honey. GoFerm rehydration. Pitched 3/15. Racked 4/14. Stabilized 4/17. Hazy.
8. S-04. Score: 830, 1.085OG, 0.991FG (correction: 0.993FG). Slight dried fruit aroma. neutral taste. Needs filtering. Drinkable as-is. Walmart honey. Pitched 3/4. Repitched 3/6 with 12 grams yeast. Clear 4/8. 3 hour degassing 4/8. Confirmed done 4/14. Stabilized 4/18.
9. D47. Score: 800, 1.085OG, 0.992FG (correction: 0.994FG). Slight fruity flavor. Very faint honey notes. Faint fruity aroma. Extremely clear. Drinable as-is. Walmart honey. Pitched 3/5. Crystal clear. Degassed 4/5. Stabilized 4/17.
10. KV-1116. Score: 790, 1.085OG, 0.993FG (correction: 0.995FG). No real aroma or taste. Completely clear. Drinkable as-is. Costco honey. Pitched 3/7. Clear 4/1. 3 hours degassed 4/8. Medium hazy, cold crash 4/13. Bentonite 4/14. Filtered 4/16. Stabilized 4/17.
11. Fresco Cyser. Score: 750, 1.085OG, 0.998FG (correction: 1.000FG) Costco RAW honey. Sam's club apple juice. Drinkable as-is. Apple notes in taste and aroma. Racked 4/8. 4 hour degassed 4/9. 1/2 teaspoon pectic enzyme 4/10. Bentonite added. Crystal clear 4/14. Filtered 4/15. Stabilized 4/17.
Not good for drinking as-is. Maybe backsweetening or oaking or aging or something would help:
12. DV10. Score: 675. 1.085OG. reading: 0.992FG (measured on "narrow range" hydrometer. No correction needed). Comments: Watery. no real flavor per se. Costco honey. Pitched 3/6. Clear 4/1. 2 hour degass 4/7. Medium hazy, cold crash 4/13. Bentonite 4/14. Filtered 4/15. Stabilized 4/19.
13. CdB. Score: 625, 1.085OG, 0.993FG (correction:0.995FG). Faint fruity aroma. Sleight malty taste. A bit too plain to be drinkable by itself without backsweetening. Walmart honey (overshot by ~50g). Clear 4/8. Racked 4/8. Degassed 4/8. Very hazy, cold crash 4/12. Bentonite 4/13. Crystal clear 4/14. Filtered 4/17. Stabilized 4/17.
14. 71B. Score: 600, 1.085OG. 0.992FG (correction: 0.994FG). No real aroma. Slight malty taste. Walmart honey. Pitched 3/4. Fermentation confirmed "done" on 4/4. Racked 4/5. Degassed 4/6. Very hazy 4/12. cold crashed 4/12. Bentonite 4/13. Crystal clear 4/14. emex filtered 4/14. Stabilized 4/18. Fairly clear.
15. 1388. Score: 400, 1.085OG. 0.996FG (correction: 0.998FG). No real aroma. Malty taste. Chemex filtered. Cosco honey. Pitched 3/4. Degassed 4/6. Still not clear 4/12. Cold crash 4/12. Bentonite 4/13.
16. 71B (10 grams). Score: 350, Goferm rehydration. 1.105OG, 0.992FG (correction: 0.994FG) Slight bluecheese aroma. Neutral, "hot" taste. Aroma is a problem. Goodflow Mesquite honey. Pitched 3/18. Racked 3/29 (forgot to sanitize new container). Cold crashed for a week. Looked clear. Transfered to PET bottle. Stabilized 4/18. Still looks very hazy.
Marginal:
17. EC1118. Score: 300, 1.085OG. 0.992FG (correction: 0.994FG). Sleight wet cardboard aroma. Sleight band-aid flavor. Costco honey. Pitched 3/12. Clear 4/1. Racked 4/4. 3 hour degassing 4/8. Confirmed done 4/8. Stabilized 4/18.
18. Fleishman's Bread Yeast. Score: 200, 1.085OG. 0.992FG (correction: 0.994FG). Slight fruity aroma. Slight cardboard taste. Costco honey. Pitched 3/3. Clear 4/8. Racked 4/9. 3 hour degassed 4/9. Highly hazy 4/13. Cold crash 4/13. Bentonite 4/14. Filtered 4/16. Stabilized 4/18.
19. QA23. 150. OG 1.103, 0.996FG (0.999FG prior to dilution). Costco honey. Pitched 3/25. Added additional 1/2 teaspoon DAP on 3/28. Racked 4/16. 13 hour degassing 4/17. Bentonite 4/17. Stabilized 4/18.
Bad (I didn't measure their FG, in case they were infected).
20. D21. Score: 100. 1.085OG. Borderline band-aid taste. Poured down the drain.
21. Belle Saison. Score: 70. 1.085OG. Band-aid taste. Poured down the drain.
22. Premier Cuvee. Score: 60. 1.085OG. Started 3/3. Done 4/1, but never cleared: has a heavy haze. Blue cheese aroma. Band-aid taste. Poured down the drain.
23. Premier Blanc. Score: 0. 1.085OG. Strong band-aid taste. Poured down the drain. Costco honey.
New Test Batches in Progress
Differences from earlier BOMM test batches:
- higher gravity
- Calcium Chloride
- Ascorbic acid
- Larger batch size
- Aeration by degassing wand.
24. D21. 1.105OG. 2 gallon batch. Pitched 4/22/2019. Goferm. Slight orangey color. Costco honey.
25. DV10. 1.105OG. 2 gallon batch. Pitched 4/22/2019. Direct pitch.
26. Hornindal Kveik. 1.105OG. 4 gallon batch. Pitched 4/22/2019. Stepped starter.
Planned New Test Batches
27. Hothead. 1.105OG. 3 gallon batch. Not yet pitched
28. Mangrove Jack's M05. 1.105OG. 3 gallon batch. Not yet pitched.