Here's my Irish Red. I started a batch last weekend, and it should be done by St. Patrick's Day. It's in the same vein as Smithwick's, Great Lakes Conway's Irish Ale, or even Killians (except smoother and more roast than Killians).
We do this pretty frequently and it's consistent. It's pretty smooth and malty, no hop aroma at all. It has a little fruitiness in the aroma, and a little butterscotch in the aftertaste, in a good way. (I hate sounding like a pretentious beer snob, but that seems accurate!) I attribute most of that to the yeast (WLP004). There is a little bit of bitterness from the roast barley - I wouldn't mind a little more of that almost acrid aftertaste.
I keg this now, and it carbonates in about 2 weeks or less. It really improves with 4 weeks total conditioning time in the fridge. It also tastes better as it warms in the glass. It's right about 5% ABV, and it's good with food.
3 gallons
1.049 OG
1.011 FG
2.5 lbs Maris Otter
2 lbs 2-row
10 oz Crystal 10
2 oz Roast Barley
2 oz Special B
5 oz honey (I have done it with and without; it's good either way. If you miss your gravity, use honey to make up the difference.)
.75 oz Willamette 4% at 60 minutes
.5 Willamette 4% at 15 minutes
(I have adjusted the amount for different AA levels. You want about 3 AAUs for bittering, if I understand how that works. Since the late addition is mostly flavor, I keep it the same regardless of the AA% in the hops.)
Whirlfloc at 5 minutes if I remember it
Add honey at flameout
WLP004 Irish Ale Yeast
Mash at 152-153 for 60 minutes
Ferment at 62-65 for 4 weeks. I have also started it at that temp and then let it free rise to the upper 60s after initial fermentation is done (about a week). I have better temperature control now, so I think I will let it go 3 weeks in the low 60s and then raise it to the upper 60s for a few days to a week. That might eliminate some diacetyl (butterscotch).
I usually hit the OG pretty well. FG is usually 1.010-1.012.