• Please visit and share your knowledge at our sister communities:
  • If you have not, please join our official Homebrewing Facebook Group!

    Homebrewing Facebook Group

The Home Made Pizza Thread

Homebrew Talk

Help Support Homebrew Talk:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
the more you need it the tougher it gets, try the no need method, raise it then stretch it or roll it out then let it rise again on the pan for an hour then bake

Ok well for what ever reason I thought you HAD to get that gluten developed by kneading it. I'll give the no knead method a shot and see what happens.
so you are mixing and just letting it set. separate into size of ball you want roll or toss to get the skin at the size and shap you want and THEN let it rise again like making bread?

I'll give it a shot.

Cheers
Jay
 
That’s a solid looking pizza. Great color.

Thanks! They taste good! I just want to perfect MY pizza. Who knew there was so much involved in making a scratch pizza?
You have to start with a good dough recipe and get that right.
Then you have to have a good sauce recipe AND get that right
Then you have to apply a good solid selection of toppings AND get that right
THEN you have to cook it right

Screw up on any 1 of those and...WELL you still have a pizza.... Baaahhhaaaaaaaa!!!

Man I had no idea the rabbit hole was so deep! LOL

Cheers
Jay
 
Thanks! They taste good! I just want to perfect MY pizza. Who knew there was so much involved in making a scratch pizza?
You have to start with a good dough recipe and get that right.
Then you have to have a good sauce recipe AND get that right
Then you have to apply a good solid selection of toppings AND get that right
THEN you have to cook it right

Screw up on any 1 of those and...WELL you still have a pizza.... Baaahhhaaaaaaaa!!!

Man I had no idea the rabbit hole was so deep! LOL

Cheers
Jay

Even with no knead you’ll get gluten development. But the web structure is much more course, which is how you get the big bubbles (and rustic look). I find it’s not strong enough to spin (but I do high hydration). I usually make a disk then toss it around on my knuckles until I feel like I’m losing control of it then get it down on the peel.

Sounds easy when you put it that way. Still trying to get even 1 of those right. Feel like I’m closest on the sauce and overall I make a good pizza but I don’t think it’s something I’d pay someone else $10-20 for. I think the oven is the most important and hardest to get right.
 
Even with no knead you’ll get gluten development. But the web structure is much more course, which is how you get the big bubbles (and rustic look). I find it’s not strong enough to spin (but I do high hydration). I usually make a disk then toss it around on my knuckles until I feel like I’m losing control of it then get it down on the peel.

Sounds easy when you put it that way. Still trying to get even 1 of those right. Feel like I’m closest on the sauce and overall I make a good pizza but I don’t think it’s something I’d pay someone else $10-20 for. I think the oven is the most important and hardest to get right.
IMG_20180309_173713405 (1).jpg


Tell me about it! It's been a very hard road to get them right. They cook in about 2-3 min in this thing. I am finding myself actually turning the oven temps down and trying to get the dough to cook a little slower.

CHeers
Jay
 
Watch a bunch of videos on stretching out the dough and I got a lil bit better however still can’t get them as round as I’d like. I am using store bought dough and letting it proof, so I bet that’s the main issue.
 
EVERYDAY IS A GOOD PIZZA DAY! LOL

Do any of you guys add spices to your dough? I added Italian seasoning to mine yesterday and REALLY prefer the straight oregano over the mixed.

Cheers
Jay
 
EVERYDAY IS A GOOD PIZZA DAY! LOL

Do any of you guys add spices to your dough? I added Italian seasoning to mine yesterday and REALLY prefer the straight oregano over the mixed.

Cheers
Jay

I don't. I'm trying to work on my Neopolitan style pizzas, which requires something similar to the Reinheitsgebot... Flour, Water, Salt, and Yeast only. :rolleyes:
 
Awesome Jaybird. Those temps sound right on. Coming in late, the no knead or a ferment of some kind was the answer. If refrigerated, letting it come to temp and gently working it is key. Plus strong heat, i wonder is also a factor. You have that covered with that sweet pizza oven. I am learning ingredients are important. The better the sauce, mozzarella, and toppings, the better the pie.
 
ok. Well the no Knead method is amazing! This is absolutely the best pie I have made to date. Dough was totally on point if what I want. Flavor and crunch and big massive air pockets! I am LOVING this dough! I also learned the parchment paper trick as well. Makes handeling the pizza durring prep so easy! Total game changer!
I also tried my hand at a white sauce for the first time. Freeken to die for!
This is the first pizza I would say I would spend $$ on that I made.

Sorry for the blurry pict!

Cheers
Jay
IMG_20180919_102315.jpg
IMG_20180919_102149.jpg
 
Starting to get the hang of it! Making my all time favorite pizza. A local hole in the wall General Store would make this and I haven’t had a pizza quite as delicious since. Appropriately named El Diablo, its a white pizza with minced garlic, pepperoni, hot cappocolo, red pepper flakes and jalapeño slices, all covered under a blanket of mozzarella. Sadly, that place has closed down so thankfully I partook in enough of that pie to recreate it.

IMG_3348.JPG


Baked at 550 on a stone:
IMG_0001.JPG


And the original El Diablo:
IMG_1449.JPG
 
I have not made homemade pizza in a couple of years. The dough I make is 2 cups of bread flour, 1 cup of water, a tablespoon of oil, yeast, and salt. (can't remember if it's 1/2 tsp or full tsp of salt.) I want to make one tonight because it's cool enough to use the oven, and I don't have bread flour. I wonder what happens if I use all-purpose? Probably will need a little less water and a lot more kneading. With bread flour, I hardly knead it at all and let the yeast ripen it.
 
I wonder what happens if I use all-purpose?

Try it. You'll know why you don't for next time ;)

I find it's OK to use King Arthur AP flour for pizza because that stuff is borderline bread flour compared to the standard national brands. But i don't use regular mass market AP flour for pizza because it tends to tear and is too soft.

It can work but it's not ideal.
 
Try it. You'll know why you don't for next time ;)

I find it's OK to use King Arthur AP flour for pizza because that stuff is borderline bread flour compared to the standard national brands. But i don't use regular mass market AP flour for pizza because it tends to tear and is too soft.

It can work but it's not ideal.

Thanks. That's what I decided already. I bought a 5-pounder of bread flour today and will make pizza tomorrow or the next day instead of tonight. (eating leftovers tonight to get rid of them. That's good too)
 
I make a greek pizza that gets rave reviews.. I start with a "from scratch" olive oil bread dough recipe. (well actually, it is a modified bread dough recipe that works well as a pizza crust. Essentially, it is a stickier dough that crisps up well on the bottom when cooked in a heavy pan with olive oil.) I let it rise once, then I cut two portions out of it and refrigerate for a few hours or overnight. I just use off the shelf pizza sauce and a pre-shredded pizza cheese blend.

Then of course all the toppings that a classic greek pizza would have. I bake in a 450F oven in a large pre-heated cast iron skillet with Olive oil. I blind bake my crust for a bit, pull it out, add sauce and all toppings, then bake again till bubbly! A 5 or 10 min cool down and it's good to go! Wish I could find the pics of my last round.

I do the same thing for my kids... but I make a half and half cheese/pepperoni pizza for them.

BTW... this pizza thing is just as fun as beer making. although I don't do much anymore, I had some fun experimenting with dough recipes and with toppings. I made a lot of Pizza.

The same can be said about wings. I've lost count of how many wing recipe variations I tried.
 
Last edited:
Try it. You'll know why you don't for next time ;)

I find it's OK to use King Arthur AP flour for pizza because that stuff is borderline bread flour compared to the standard national brands. But i don't use regular mass market AP flour for pizza because it tends to tear and is too soft.

It can work but it's not ideal.

Thanks. That's what I decided already. I bought a 5-pounder of bread flour today and will make pizza tomorrow or the next day instead of tonight. (eating leftovers tonight to get rid of them. That's good too)

Before I acquired my Caputo 00, AP flour is all I used. Both King Arthur and Store Brand. I believe AP flour is what Peter Reinhart recommends in American Pie as a replacement for Italian 00.

In my opinion, 100% bread flour brings too much gluten to the party.
 
Before I acquired my Caputo 00, AP flour is all I used. Both King Arthur and Store Brand. I believe AP flour is what Peter Reinhart recommends in American Pie as a replacement for Italian 00.

In my opinion, 100% bread flour brings too much gluten to the party.

What style pizza are you usually making ?
 
Back
Top