Glad someone updated this thread! I'm still making soap; each batch is just a bit different from the last until we settle on a type that we really like. It's all been good so far, though.
I use micas for dye, and fragrance oil, so I'm not all natural. But I am experimenting with some natural colorants. Cocoa is sitting in olive oil, as is some tumeric. I'll use those later on and see how they affect the coloring of a batch.
This is some of what I've done recently. A few months ago we caught a Halloween clearance at a craft store and bought an adorable bat cupcake pan. Since it's far from Halloween, I couldn't make black and orange soap, but I really really wanted to use the bats! So instead, I made fruitbat soap. The bats are orange with bergamot fragrance, and the soap surrounding them is blue-grey with lavender fragrance. They're absolutely adorable.
The swirl on this is light green and purple, but the pic washed some of the color. Fragrance is rosemary. The small bar is a light green with lemon verbena scent. This is a great scent; we have a bit lemon verbena bush in the back yard that smells amazing every year.
Wish we could make our own deodorant, but we work out way too much and I stink something awful afterwards. :cross:
Something I would like to try is liquid soap, as well as our own shampoo and conditioner. Browsing some shampoo posts in other forums, it looks like a whole lot of different chemicals goes into them, and that's what's keeping me from starting down that road. I bought a small shampoo bar off etsy just to try it out, and we didn't like it at all. That was disappointing, but glad we tried it out.