Results from juice, yeast and sugar experiments

Homebrew Talk - Beer, Wine, Mead, & Cider Brewing Discussion Forum

Help Support Homebrew Talk - Beer, Wine, Mead, & Cider Brewing Discussion Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
Status
Not open for further replies.
There is a 4th way stop fermentation early to leave sweetness if you have the equipment; filter the cider.

Using a filter below 0.5μ (i think, going on memory) should remove all the yeast and thus stop fermentation. I have not tried this myself though.
 
There is a 4th way stop fermentation early to leave sweetness if you have the equipment; filter the cider.

Using a filter below 0.5μ (i think, going on memory) should remove all the yeast and thus stop fermentation. I have not tried this myself though.

Thanks EricMc for pointing that out; I edited my original post to include it.
Yes, must be 0.5 micron or less to catch the yeast.
Looks like a sure-fire method. Cost may be an issue for some as it requires a kegging system (or at least some form of pressurizable container or pumping device...either way a cost) and the filter system.

And you know, I could add pasteurization/sterilization as a fifth method...

Funny, my main line of thinking was on methods relating to yeast behavior, and solely focused on kegging for carbonation, and here's two other methods that have merit.
 
Hey Kevin, just noticed your username and I'm wondering where you got all the yeasts in Charlottesville. I've been using Fifth Season for all of my brewing stuff for the three or so months I've been brewing and their selection isn't really the greatest.
 
Jer - I used yeast from Fifth Season for my last round of batches. They dont have everything, but they have some pretty good yeasts for cider, including all the good dry yeasts (S04, US05, Notty, S23) Wyeast 3056, 1010, 3068 and 3638. They have WLP005 and usually a few of the WLP3xx wheat yeasts. I also enjoy checking out their indoor basil growing operation. One of these days ....

Last season, the Fermentation trap in Ruckersville had great prices on Fermentis yeasts (S04, US05 and S23) because they bought a bunch before Fermentis jacked the price. They also have a very wide WLP selection, but I dont think they carry Wyeast.

I order from Northern Brewer a lot because they have just about all the liquid yeasts and I like their Orange blossom, white sage and wildflower honey. Its as good as anything I've found locally and very consistent from batch to batch. Their liquid yeasts are a buck and a half cheaper than LHBS, so it doesnt take much to make up the cost of shipping.

I got the UK yeasts from a UK ebay store, but I cant remember which one. The shipping was almost as much as the yeast, but the yeasts were very reasonably priced. It ended up being about $60 bucks total for 16 packets of yeast - or 3.75 each, which is about what most of the Fermentis yeast are going for these days.

If you're in town next Fall and want to get in on a cider run, PM me. I usually do 4-5 runs to the orchard each season and my truck can hold about 120 gallons, which is usually 60 for me and 60 for friends. This Fall another brewing friend with a truck may be able to make some runs as well.

JohnW - good overview of methods for residual sweetness. I'd say these are the 5 easily accessible and non-chemical routes. There are some more equipment intensive methods (centrifuge, degorging). Also, if you use a full dose of k-meta followed by k-sorbate, that is very effective at stopping the fermentation and it gets nice and clear, but it tastes like ass. The sorbate taste might work in an alcoholic root beer, but doesnt work in a cider IMHO.

I dont know if much research supports flocculation at low temps, but empirically it is true for ale and wheat yeasts. One of the listed Brewing Properties on the Nottingham spec sheet is "Shows flocculation at completion of fermentation, and settling is promoted by cooling and use of fining agents and isinglass." A lot of homemade root beer recipes call for using ale yeast and then chilling the bottles after a day to stop fermentation. Of course, causing the yeast to go dormant is only a temporary condition unless they flocculate, in which case you can filter the clear cider off the residue.

I hadnt heard that calcium helps flocculation, but I have noticed that honey helps a lot. I have a couple friends who work for commercial wineries and they use bentonite when needed. My experience is that 9 times out of 10 the cold crash will get things nice and clear, and when it doesnt, I'll just drink it cloudy and make sure to finish the keg before the haze drops.
 
Kevin, here are several links to flocculation research papers that discuss calcium, among other variables, and flocculation.

Some just sat flat out no matter the yeast type calcium, even if merely small amounts, is vital to good flocculation; a few say more so for bottom fermenting types than for top fermenting types.
Didn't you have a lager strain or two that did not fully clear the yeast when cold crashed? Maybe there is something to calcium and flocculation...sounds like a good experiment to run with a lager yeast...one with and one without calcium.

www.scientificsocieties.org/JIB/papers/1997/1997_103_4_257.pdf

http://cdsweb.cern.ch/record/500702/files/0105062.pdf

www.ftb.com.hr/40-199.pdf

http://mic.sgmjournals.org/cgi/reprint/35/1/61.pdf

http://aem.asm.org/cgi/reprint/61/2/718.pdf

Also, I'd say from reading about your experiments that you are sort of on a quest for a perfect yeast for "sweeter" ciders. Have you considered writing a description of what such a perfect yeast would be like, just to help "identify the target"? Nothing fancy, just mimic how Wyeast or White Labs writes theirs.

Thanks again,
Happy brewing

JohnW
 
JohnW - I might try calcium if I had a problem with ciders not clearing. I also saw some bentonite with calcium that might be worth checking out. So far, clearing hasnt been much of a problem for me, knock on wood. The S23 and 4184 yeasts are both resistant to crashing although they get fairly clear and these taste fairly good dry. I suspect the yeasts ball up and go dormant in the cold but dont drop. I wouldnt mind the S23 a tad sweeter - like around 1.004 so I might try calcium on that and see if it helps keep it stable after the crash.

Mainly, I just avoid the yeasts that dont clear well, For that matter, I'd like to find an alternative to both the S23 and 4184 for dry ciders. S04 does pretty good for a dry cider with a good apple finish at 1.004 and it crashes easily and is well behaved. If you look at the pics on pages 31 and 26, most of the bottles are fairly clear. A couple of the malt ciders on page 26 are real cloudy as were one or two of the one on page 31. I try to avoid the yeasts that dont clear well rather than add an extra step to get them to clear.

I had a batch of juice that was Stayman and Rome and that didnt clear very well, so I try to avoid Romes. They taste great, but they are mostly an applesauce apple because of the pectin. If that was all I could get then fining might be an issue. This year, just about all of the batches I did came out pretty clear except for one batch that I hand pressed with some friends and fermented a carboy with S04. I also fermented a carboy with wild yeast on the same juice, and it came out pretty clear, but for some reason the S04 batch was cloudy. But it still tasted great and when you put it in a pint glass no one can tell that you cant see through a 5 gall carboy.

Unpasteurized juice clears much better than pasteurized.

When I started doing these experiments it was a few years ago and my goal was to have about 4-5 good recipes instead of one (ie Nottingham crashed at 1.008 to 1.012). I've been making cider for a long time with the same recipe, which was like a slightly drier version of a standard commercial cider - eg Woodchuck, Original Sin, Strongbow, etc. So now I have a much wider range, some of which is sweeter, some drier. My girlfriend and a lot of her friends like it sweet so that is a definite factor

One of the characteristics of a perfect cider yeast IMHO would be one that only had an alcohol tolerance that was in the range of 5 to 8 percent (preferably available in half percent steps eg 6.5, 7,0 etc. That would save the cold crashing step and make bottle carbonating reliable as long as someone can use a hydrometer properly.

Otherwise I'd say it would be hard to define a perfect cider yeast for the same reasons it would be hard to define a perfect beer or wine yeast because there are so many styles. I've got about a dozen recipes now that I'm fairly happy with and they range from dry to sweet. I'm doing 8 batches at a time, so I have more recipes than juice now.

Next season, I plan on making 34 keg batches, consisting of four commercial pressings of 8 batches each, plus 2 batches hand pressed.

For each batch of 8 kegs, 4 of them will most likely be the same yeasts for every batch:
Nottingham - tastes great and half the price of Fermentis. target fg 1.008-1.012
S04 - tastes great, easy to work with, can go drier than the Notty and still keep more of the apple flavor. target fg. 1.004-1.010
US05 – mostly with turbinado, but I might do another one with malt, target fg for both 1.012.
S04 or US05, adding raspberries before the cold crash. This method worked out pretty well. My favorite yeast for adding raspberries so far is US05, but S04 is good and I might try some more of the wheat yeasts.

Then of the remaining 4 kegs per batch, two will be sweeter style wheat yeast batches from following list (one regular, one cyser), which I'm planning to rotate through:
Wyeast 3068 Weihenstephan Wheat. target fg. 1.016-1.022
Wyeast 1010 American Wheat Yeast. target fg. 1.012-1.020
Wyeast 3638 Bavarian Wheat Yeast. target fg. 1.012-1.020
Wyeast 3333 German Wheat Yeast. target fg. 1.012-1.020
Wyeast 3056 Bavarian Blend target fg. 1.016-1.020
WLP380 Hefeweizen IV with turbinado target fg. 1.016-1.020

The remaining two kegs per batch will be drier pub style ciders and come from following list
WLP005 British Ale Yeast. target fg 1.006-1.012
Brupaks Ale yeast. target fg 1.008-1.012
Wyeast 2001 Pilsner Urquell. target fg 1.008-1.012.
Ritchies Real ale yeast. target fg 1.008-1.012
Ritchies Real lager yeast. target fg 1.008-1.012
Gervin English Ale yeast. target fg 1.008-1.012
Youngs Lager yeast. target fg 1.008-1.012
Youngs Ale yeast. target fg 1.008-1.012
S23 Lager Yeast?. target fg 1.002-1.004

Even though I already have more recipes than I can make at once, there are still a few more yeasts that I want to check out, so I'm planning to do some small batches of the following as well. If they come out well, then they might make it into the keg list rotation for some of the last batches:
Wyeast 1084 Irish Ale Yeast.
Wyeast 1098 British Ale Yeast
Wyeast 1272 American Ale Yeast II
WLP023 Burton Ale Yeast
WLP028 Edinburgh Scottish Ale.
WLP041 Pacific Ale
WLP810 San Francisco Lager
Wyeast 2035 American Lager
Wyeast 2112 California Lager
Wyeast 2206 Bavarian Lager
Wyeast 1728 Scottish Ale
White Labs WLP800 Pilsner Lager

I'd be interested in hearing any feedback on these or other good cider yeasts.
 
Kevin,

Have you ever thought about using a trappist yeast in your ciders? I just tried crispins trappist cider and it was very interested. the fruity yeast charactaristics gave it some complexity even though they let their ciders dry out pretty much to like apfelwein.

Just a thought
 
wcarter - yes, I used the WLP500 trappist yeast on some batches. I thought it was pretty good, but it didnt get much love from my friends, so I probably wont make it again. I've still got a few bottles of those left and will try them out at a later tasting. If they get a better response, I might do the 500 again.
 
I did a few experimental batches with the WLP565 Belgian Saison. They all fermented out very fast, so that by the time I checked them, they were already fully dry and very little flavor. They might have tasted better if I had caught them earlier. Personally, I wouldnt use the WLP565 again - I like the slower fermenting yeasts because they are easier to manage and I suspect that anything that fermented so fast would be tough to crash. If you use the 565, make sure to check it very often. I havent tried the Wyeast Saisons.
 
ok, read through this whole thread a few months ago, and i'm too lazy to do it again. so was there a difinitive conclusion? a gold, silver, bronze combo that you have come up with, or is the testing still in progress?
 
The testing is still a work in progress, although there have been some really good ones so far. I wouldnt say that there was a gold, silver and bronze, mainly because tastes vary so much. My current "A" list is on the previous page - thats the current list that I'm planning to make keg batches with next season. Any of these will work great, depending on what you are going for
 
Hey...just posting a little follw-up on methods to stop fermentation before the must hits 1.000 or less. I just racked another batch of two-week ginger mead to a carboy for cold-crashing, so I had a 3 gallon carboy of yeast sediment available for something new. Reading this thread put me in a mind for making a quick cider, so I bought three gallons of apple juice in the refrigerated section of the grocery store. I was shopping without eye-glasses, and could not read the label, so I took it that juice that needed chilling would be nothing but juice...WRONG! The juice has potassium sorbate...and I should have known better because in the past I have had frozen raspberries sit in the crisper of my fridge and ferment from the wild yeasts that were on the berries...so duh, apple juice could have the same thing happen.
Anyway, what the hell, I had the juice and a carboy with a healthy yeast cake, so in went the juice...and just for good measure a packet of fermentis saflager W34/70.
Three days later and it's fermenting along quite nicely...dropped from 1.048 to 1.038 already, which goes to show you that potassium sorbate does not "stop" fermentation...just reproduction of the yeast.
So what do I do to ensure this ferments out? I've made up a 1 quart starter using some honey...if the cider appears to slow too much, in goes the starter with just enough left behind to add more honey and have a follow-up starter, and so on. But I really doubt I'll need to add much more yeast to bring this down to 1.008 or so. (follow-up: 6-25-2010 gravity reads 1.020, yeast still eating away, airlock bubbles every 5 -10 seconds, no additional starter added)

When it hits 1.008, I'll rack it onto about 1 dozen finely crushed Granny Smiths and cold crash it...hoping to add some tartness and apple complexity. (I live in Savannah, GA...I think I once saw an apple tree around here, but it had sad looking blotchy apples, and only a very few at that...so freash-pressed apple juice is a twelve-hour round-trip drive kinda thing for me...so cider is not so big around here as a home-made alcohol delivery system)

Kevin, how about a little advice for me on where to stop my gravity and have a nice semi-sweet cider?
 
Hey John - the best place to stop fermentation is a matter of personal taste, and is also influenced by the amount of acid in the apples. 1.008 seems to be a good average number although most commercial ciders are a lot higher. I find that after 1.004, most of the flavor starts washing out, but some folks like it real dry. My advice would be to taste it around 1.015 and then every couple points or so after that to find the optimal point for your juice.
 
Kevin, thanks for the advice..I'll do what you suggest.
Just checked the gravity on the cider I mentioned in my post, and its come down another 8 points in one day...so I'd say potassium sorbate can be overcome...or so it seems when a 1.048 or so must is hit with a large population of yeast.
 
The commercial presses wont be starting up for another 3 weeks or so, but yesterday some friends and I got 15 bushels of early season apples and pressed a little less than 35 gal of juice. The apples were Gala, McIntosh and Prima, which made a pretty good mix. It looks like this is going to be another good year for apples. These were the best looking #2 cider apples I've seen.


before.jpg


We had about a dozen people helping, so it went real fast. The actual pressing took about 2 hours, plus an hour before and after to clean and sanitize the press. My friends John and Michelle have a really nice press with two baskets so we could pulp one batch while squeezing another. Afterwards we finished off 6 liters of hard cider from last season

during.jpg


The juice doesnt have much bite in the finish but has lots of flavor in the middle. The pH was 3.5. and Sg was 1.45. I got three carboys. One batch has 3lbs wildflower honey and S04. One has turbinado/dextrose mix and US05, the other has turbinado/dextrose mix and 3056. No sulfites.

It is still really warm in my basement - about 80 degrees when I pitched the yeast, although it cooled down some last night. The two ale yeast batches had airlock activity within 4 hours and the 3056 was going in 12 hours. This is the earliest I have ever made cider. These should ferment out really fast so I'm glad I only have 3 batches to deal with.

after.jpg


When I went to the orchard to get the apples, they told me that this week they would be picking and grading Northern Spys, so I might have to do this again next weekend
 
Kevin,

Have you ever used danstar munich dry yeast or safebrew t58 in cider?

Also ive been looking at a thread about bottle pasterizing carbed cider, have you ever done this?

Last but not least im going to an orchard next month to pick up more fresh cider and going to ferment it with wild yeast. As for apples what would be a good apple mix? I really love pink lady but what else would you mix with that?
 
I've used both of the munich and t58, but didnt get good results with these yeasts.

I havent tried bottle pasteurizing. I can fill bottles from kegs, so it would just be extra work for me. But it does seem like this method would work very well for someone who does not have a kegging setup and wants to bottle condition a sweet cider.

Pink Lady mixes great with Stayman. I havent tried to mix PL with Northern Spy yet, but I hope to do so this season. The three of those together would likely be awesome. Cameo would also be good. You could make all sorts of three apple mixes with PL and one that is more tart, and one more sweet

I've had best luck with wild yeast later in the season when its colder and the ferment is slower. I did a batch in September that refused to crash and within 2 weeks was fermented completely dry, watery and nearly tasteless. Early Oct batch was meh, late Oct was good. Jan took 3 1/2 months to ferment and was best.
 
chillin.jpg


This week it got to mid 90s outside. Wed afternoon it hit 80 again in my basement which was too high for the ciders and they were putting off a little bit of sulfur.

So I moved them in front of the AC. That has kept the temp to 72 max and the ciders smell nice and appley again. The SGs all dropped from ~1.060 Sunday to ~1.035 by Wed, so I expect that I will cold crash these this weekend. I'm planning to check them out this eve as soon as SWMBO gets home.

update - the US05 and 3056 batches were at 1.022 and S04 with honey was at 1.028. They all tasted good but still too sweet. This is day 5, so they will probably finish out in 6-10 days. I plan to crash the 3056 first, followed by US05 then S04.
 
So Im gonna try bottle pasturizing my cider as I racked it today at a gravity of 1.010.

I know that i have a chance of bottle bombs so i bottled them in some belgian bottles and corked them. I have an old chest that I am storing them in until i get the right carbonation and then gonna try to see if i can stabilize them by pasterizing. I tried a sample today and it tastes kind of like a better tasting woodchuck. Ill post pics in a few weeks if I have any luck
 
I got six more carboys of juice yesterday. Mostly Cortland, Mac and Gala with some Honeycrisp, Grimes Golden and Jonathan. sg 1.050 and pH 3.9. This tastes like a good cider mix. The Galas give off a smell when they are pressed that is like cinnamon, and you get a little bit of that in the juice, along with the Mac aroma. Not much sweetness up front but a lot of flavor. It seems to me to be more tart than the last batch even though the pH is 0.4 higher.

One carboy has nothing but S04 yeast. I'm planning to let that one go on the dry side to 0.004 or 0.006. One has 3lb orange blossom honey and Wyeast 1010. I added a pound and a half of sugar to each of the other four carboys, with Brupack Ale, WLP005, US05, and Wy3068.

I pitched the yeast about 24 hours ago and they are all going strong. The two wheat batches 1010 and 3068 both needed blowoff tubes.

In the meantime, it looks like all three of the first carboys from this season are resisting clearing on the cold crash. I'm pretty sure that the culprit is the Prima apples. I havent used these in a mix before and it turns out that they are a popular applesauce apple. I suspect that like Rome apples they have a lot more pectin than the Macs and Galas. All of the carboys dropped a lot of trub during the crash, but it is still very hazy, even the one with the honey. I crashed US05 and 3056 at 1.010. S04 was 1.008. After a few days at room temp I'm getting some yeast activity at about a bubble per minute. So I'm going to re-crash these. The US05 batch tastes great and could be kegged right now if the situation warranted. The 3056 still tastes a little yeasty and the S04 batch needs some more time to mellow
 
Hey there, thanks again for all the insight over the past year or so as I've started playing with cider-making. I've got an orchard I've been working with who's very helpful, but not experienced with hard-cider making.

Do you have any rules of thumb for varietal / brix / etc decisions. I can get a pretty good selection though it's skewed to fresh and non-hard consumption. They go through a lot of presses, so I can probably be more specific on my brix requests.

Any info helpful. Thanks.
Ivano
 
Do you have any rules of thumb for varietal / brix / etc decisions.
not really. I know what I like. What varieties can you get now? Not knowing the apple types, the best thing is to sample all of them, make some notes on the flavor and aroma, then take the best flavor and/or most interesting ones, cut them into very thin slices and see how they taste in combinations of 2-5 slices at a time. I'd avoid sauce apples like Rome and Prima even though they add some nice flavors because they are less likely to clear
 
Hi Everyone, Here's a stupid question. I've never kegged before and am still relatively new to home brewing. I finally bought my first corny kegs and was wondering if I could backsweeten the cider with concentrated apple juice after fermenting for two weeks and add it to a keg without having to add potassium sorbate. I used 3068 for the yeast. Will the taste just ferment away? Thanks!
 
Finally! I got my hands on some Northern Spy #2 cider apples yesterday! The orchard did not have very many #2s, but I got enough to make about 3 gallons, to which I added about a gallon of Gala (for aroma) and a gallon of Jonathon (for a little more tartness). So now I have a 5 gal batch of Northern Spy, Gala Jonathon mix bubbling away with some S04.

The juice tastes great. The NS apples themselves were not quite as tasty as I remembered last season. I think they might have benefited from another couple of months in cold storage, but since these apples are in short supply around here, that wasnt going to happen. We'll see in a month or so if it was worth the effort.
 
OG was 1.050 and pH was 4.0. I'll probably crash it around 1.008 or 1.010. I'm also thinking of stopping the previous S04 batch around the same point and not let it get as dry as what I was planning. That way I can compare the two at similar fg and see if its worth the extra effort to get more Northern Spy juice next year.

edit - too late, I just checked the Cortland-Gala-Mac-S04 batch and it is already at 1.000 after six days! Damn, I wanted this to be a dry batch, but not this dry. It was still fermenting so I crashed it. It tastes pretty good for so dry. No sweetness at all up front, but nice body, a decent amount of apple, and not too much acid in the finish. I think my dry drinking friends will like this one, but I really wish I had checked it last night.
 
Kevin, after you cold crash do you let it get up to room temp before kegging or do you keg it cold? Sorry for all the questions, I'm just new at this and wanted to get everything right.
Thanks! Kerry
 
Kerry, usually I let it go up to room temp and get a little more clear for a couple weeks, and make sure that the ferment doesnt start back up. However, if I dont have anything on tap, I'll rack it right into the keg after the crash
 
Kevin, I have a 4 gallon batch that I've cold crashed too late...what's the best way to salvage? Fresh juice, 1 camden/gallon, 3 lbs. orange blossom honey, started with s-04 but no activity after 3 days, so shook and added wyeast 3184. Started at 1.060, fermented out real fast at 5 days, then crashed at 1.000. So tart is undrinkable at this point. Cysers take a while to mellow, right?, but would like reasonable sweetness at some point.
Mike
 
Mike - Did you mean Wyeast 4184? That yeast makes a very good dry cider, but it will probably not be drinkable until next summer. I've made several batches with this yeast and had the same experience as you, in that they were all too tart to be drinkable for many months. They didnt get drinkable until the spring and werent really good until the summer. I've never tried to backsweeten the 4184 batches, but I suppose it can be done. 4184 is tough to crash though, so if you backsweeten, you'll want to drink it soon.

I've found that its actually kinda useful to have a few batches that dont become drinkable until the summer, because I wont be tempted to drink them all over the winter. I realize this doesnt help you now though. I'd recommend saving at least some of this batch till next summer and maybe start a new batch with the S04.

Catching the cider at the right point at this time of the year is tricky unless you have a way to keep them cool and slow down the ferment. Of the 6 keg batches I started a couple weeks ago, I ended up crashing 4 of them lower than I wanted to go. We had a couple of hot days and they went from a little too sweet to nearly dry in 24 hours.
 
Kevin - supply company markets it as 3184 but only 4184 is reflected on wyeast.com so thinking it probably was 4184. So this batch will be long term. Should be safe to bottle right...can't be much sugar left to ferment.
 
Mike - its the sweet mead yeast, right? In that case, yes, its safe to bottle at 1.000, although you might want to give it another week or two in the secondary just to make sure it doesnt move. You could add a little priming sugar if you want, as I doubt that it would ever get much below 0.998 between now and next summer.
 
Looking at some options in the next week that include Granny Smith, Jona Prince, Jona Gold, Pink Lady, and Fuji. Didn't use the Fuji or Jona's last year, any thoughts?

Just bought a used Buon Vino Mini-Jet filter-pump on ebay, I plan on using this in lieu of cold-crashing and / or chemicals and/or keeving. We shall see how it goes, got my finger's crossed.
 
This may have come up before, but are any of you worried about the pesticides they spray on the apples. I am mostly an organic guy, but I would think this would be particularly important in making cider. Have any of you ever noticed off flavors or stuck fermentation that you thought might be from the chemicals.

The reason I ask is that I am getting ready to make some more cider and I am having a problem finding Organic apples that aren't 2 hours away. Just wondering what everyone's thoughts were on this.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Latest posts

Back
Top