Question

[jake b]

Am I in trouble if my beer is a little lighter than it should be? I just brewed my first batch and the initial hydrometer reading should have been 1.044 or something close to that and it was probably closer to 1.036.

 

[Yooper]

No, it would just mean that your efficiency isn't what the recipe was set up for. If you post the recipe, I can give you better advice!

 

[FlyGuy]

It also really depends on the style of beer you were brewing. Undershooting your efficiency means that the beer is going to have a little less maltiness and body than expected, and the hops may come through a little more. If this was an American Pale Ale, it will be fine. If it was something that requires real balance, like a Dortmunder, then you might find it a bit off.

It is always a good idea to have a bit of dry malt extract (and some brewing software!) on hand for AG brewing, especially when you are starting out. That way, you have the option of 'topping up' your wort with extract to hit your target OG.

 

[Deege]

It just means you need to drink more to get drunk.

Seriously, it shouldn't matter that much. It will be fine. It really is hard to screw up beer, unless you are trying to win a competition.

 

[jake b]

It's a pilsner from a kit.

 

[Yooper]

What was the recipe and the mash schedule?