Try to post a picture so we can see what you have captured.
How does it smell?
As far as having anything, my main determinants were visual growth and smell. Then eventually taste.
so here's exactly what i did. i made a starter from light dme but did not pitch yeast. i poured the wort into a coke can that i removed the top from. i covered that with cheesecloth and made a tin foil hood for it that let air pass freely through, but would keep rain out. i then left this in my backyard for approximately 2 weeks during weather ranging from about 37F to about 63F. after the two weeks, i made another starter, poured the contents of the can into it and covered the top with tinfoil.
at first it did nothing, sitting in my 68F kitchen. So i moved it down to my 58F basement and within a few days I had some thick gunk around the edges. no mold at all, but a nasty looking white substance.
then it did nothing for a while after that fell. since, i have closed the jar and it has sat for a couple months now, and gotten much darker in color. the side by side photo is of it next to a new starter, obviously the difference is dramatic.
i had not smelled it until today for fear of contamination, but i did a quick whiff just now, and it smells fruity, sweet, and slightly tart.
so i guess i may have something. should i test with another starter? risk ruining a beer with it? if i use it, should it be as my primary yeast, or should i pitch it in a secondary?
thanks!