That's the exact capper I used that I had two, of which both broke. I actually came across that last post by searching google...funny how it didn't pop up when I used the forum search before making this thread.
Thanks, everyone!
Edit: I also found the most recent patent for a bottle cap (they really aren't that old) and, according to the patent, they're designed to take about 450 psi for standard caps, and about 500 for twist-offs.