Cellared Beer Reviews

[barleywinefiend]

One of my favorites. First introduced to me by Libbey. This beer is layers of decadence. It had a smooth balance of light smoke, bourbon, and caramel. This beer is at prime. It's mind blowing delicious. Kapooya.

 

[harrymel1]

My, oh my. This 2013 is drinking so damn fine. Lots of chocolate, toffee, and dark fruits. The heat had tapered a wee bit.
This is, without a doubt, one of the best non BA barley wines around.

Absolutely correct. Love this beer.

My other unsung hero of the PNW: Reel Ales (fish) 10 squared. Great beer.

 

[Previously]

My, oh my. This 2013 is drinking so damn fine. Lots of chocolate, toffee, and dark fruits. The heat had tapered a wee bit.
This is, without a doubt, one of the best non BA barley wines around.

Drank a 2011 in May of this year. Was still doing great. An all-time favorite. Cheers!

 

[barleywinefiend]

Absolutely correct. Love this beer.

My other unsung hero of the PNW: Reel Ales (fish) 10 squared. Great beer.

I bought a case of these at Bargain Market in Tacoma for $60. 10 Squared that is.

 

[user 305963]

Did the The Bruery Anniversary vertical last night. All were 100% BA except for Papier.

Cuivre: A bit hot, sweet and boozy with a tough of caramel

Sucre: A bit sweeter than Cuivre but definitely less depth of flavor.

Bois: Lots of complexity and sweetness, no notable oxidation

Fruet: This is where things get interesting. This one was so smooth and didn't have any of that boozy heat. Lots of dark fruit, leather and barrel

Cuir: Similar to Fruet, very smooth and great balance of dark fruit, caramel, leather and barrel. Best of the set.

Coton: And this is where things fall off. Oxydized and has a weird berry sweetness to it. Uh oh

Papier: An oxidized mess. I've read and heard the word "cardboard" being used to descrid oxidation. This was the prime example. Barely drinkable.

 

[clegolfski]

I had a '10 a coupler weeks ago. It's still great but would not push it too much further.

 

[clegolfski]

I had a '10 a coupler weeks ago. It's still great but would not push it too much further.

My bad screwed up the quoting. That was a reference to a '10 Founder's Imp. Stout. To elaboate I dig those guys with age as the hops are sometimes raw out the gate.

 

[robertgoulet]

Just opened up a November 2012 Palo Santo Marron. It's similar to fresh, with the distinctive spicy wood note in the forefront, except now there is a ton of indistinguishable dark fruits intermingled with the spiced wood.

This beer remains predominately palo santo wood after 2.5 years, but it is becoming a little more interesting. Does anyone have any experience with these with more age? As I always seem to have a couple of these hanging around, I'm curious if there is some experience with the barrel receding with further aging.

 

[stakem1]

in honor of Fred's passing

as still as the day it was released. regardless a wonderful brew considering the discount this went for when Alan actually admitted he ****** up. anyway, in 4 years it has not started to show its age. still has layers of caramelized sugars and a noticeable woodiness and alcohol warmth. carb would do this wonders but as is, its a great raisony cordial

 

[drgarage1]

in honor of Fred's passing

as still as the day it was released. regardless a wonderful brew considering the discount this went for when Alan actually admitted he ****** up. anyway, in 4 years it has not started to show its age. still has layers of caramelized sugars and a noticeable woodiness and alcohol warmth. carb would do this wonders but as is, its a great raisony cordial

It's always amazing to me how dark BFftW and FftW are compared to Fred. Barrels to weird things to pale beers.

 

[stakem1]

It's always amazing to me how dark BFftW and FftW are compared to Fred. Barrels to weird things to pale beers.

barrels certainly make a brew darker. hell, the sanitary solution i use to put in barrels between fillings changed from clear to stained like tea. the intensity mellows out with every fill/empty.

not to downplay the color barrels impart but HOTD isnt exactly consistent with their brewing batch to batch and it wouldnt surprise me if different batches of un-oaked fred looked at least a little different too

 

[drgarage1]

barrels certainly make a brew darker. hell, the sanitary solution i use to put in barrels between fillings changed from clear to stained like tea. the intensity mellows out with every fill/empty.

not to downplay the color barrels impart but HOTD isnt exactly consistent with their brewing batch to batch and it wouldnt surprise me if different batches of un-oaked fred looked at least a little different too

That's a great point. I do think it's notable that they don't call oaked Fred a "golden Belgian-style ale" like the normal version.

 

[BulkCarrier]

Picture x-posted in 08/13/15.

The initial pour had just a film of an off white to slightly white rising up along the sides of my snifter. Gently dissipates and the lacing slides right on into the beer. The aroma has lost some of the "meaty/bacon-esque" flavor, yet a beautiful amount of cocoa blends sweetly into gentle campfire smoke. The flavor was sweet smokey cocoa, full and indulgent. I'd say it sat about medium bodied with a decent sipping to sessionable feel running about it. Carbonation definitely is starting to run lighter than fresher versions. Always a pleasurable beer to drink!

 

[stakem1]

Picture x-posted in 08/13/15.

The initial pour had just a film of an off white to slightly white rising up along the sides of my snifter. Gently dissipates and the lacing slides right on into the beer. The aroma has lost some of the "meaty/bacon-esque" flavor, yet a beautiful amount of cocoa blends sweetly into gentle campfire smoke. The flavor was sweet smokey cocoa, full and indulgent. I'd say it sat about medium bodied with a decent sipping to sessionable feel running about it. Carbonation definitely is starting to run lighter than fresher versions. Always a pleasurable beer to drink!

im down with being too lazy to cross post a pic but what were you drinking?

based on your description i guess alaskan smoked porter

edit: im bored enough that i just looked at your posting history and saw that was indeed the beer. christ im pathetic

 

[BulkCarrier]

im down with being too lazy to cross post a pic but what were you drinking?

based on your description i guess alaskan smoked porter

edit: im bored enough that i just looked at your

posting history and saw that was indeed the beer. christ im pathetic

Oh ****, I just now noticed, my bad. Yes, Alaskan Smoked porter. Thanks man, good call, next time, I'll post pic. No you're not pathetic. I didn't do that right.

 

[Der Fuchs]

Picture x-posted in 08/13/15.

The initial pour had just a film of an off white to slightly white rising up along the sides of my snifter. Gently dissipates and the lacing slides right on into the beer. The aroma has lost some of the "meaty/bacon-esque" flavor, yet a beautiful amount of cocoa blends sweetly into gentle campfire smoke. The flavor was sweet smokey cocoa, full and indulgent. I'd say it sat about medium bodied with a decent sipping to sessionable feel running about it. Carbonation definitely is starting to run lighter than fresher versions. Always a pleasurable beer to drink!

What year ASP? I started a vert. after having a 10yo bottle a few years back. Was thinking of drinking them soon. That beer ages so gracefully for a porter.

 

[iong516]

This and a WWBY consumed almost a year ago now were both doing awesome. Why crooked stave isn't still making beers like this escapes me...

 

[bsc]

$$$$$$$$$

 

[ASak10]

$$$$$$$$$

Has to be this...ever since they ended the Cellar Reserve, they've been cranking out beers weekly, it feels like. Which is awesome and amazing, but also presumably explains why they aren't taking the time/space/effort to make the WWB beers again.

 

[BulkCarrier]

What year ASP? I started a vert. after having a 10yo bottle a few years back. Was thinking of drinking them soon. That beer ages so gracefully for a porter.

I totally agree about its ageability (is that a word, he, I think you know what I mean). Yes, I lived in Juneau from 2013 til this past winter. When I accepted a job back East, I figured, time to take as much Smoked porter with me as I could. So I nabbed a good amount (not gonna say online how much I have) and came back East. Yeah, opened one up last week, saw this thread and figured, yeah, why not.

This one, was a 2013. And it was really good to me.

Its up to you, but you could probably hold off if you wanted to. Oldest I ever had was a 2002 last Summer and it tasted exceptional. There's a reason why that brewery knows what they're doing when it comes to that style.

Cheers!

Adam

 

[Der Fuchs]

I totally agree about its ageability (is that a word, he, I think you know what I mean). Yes, I lived in Juneau from 2013 til this past winter. When I accepted a job back East, I figured, time to take as much Smoked porter with me as I could. So I nabbed a good amount (not gonna say online how much I have) and came back East. Yeah, opened one up last week, saw this thread and figured, yeah, why not.

This one, was a 2013. And it was really good to me.

Its up to you, but you could probably hold off if you wanted to. Oldest I ever had was a 2002 last Summer and it tasted exceptional. There's a reason why that brewery knows what they're doing when it comes to that style.

Cheers!

Adam

what i really want to do is find some older bottles to drink with the newish ones but i have no clue where to start the search. anything pre 2009 would work.

 

[BulkCarrier]

what i really want to do is find some older bottles to drink with the newish ones but i have no clue where to start the search. anything pre 2009 would work.

As of last Summer, ABC hooked up with a distributor in South Dakota and started putting their beers in Michigan (that's the farthest East), they're at now. And I'm pretty sure, they go all the way South to Texas.

www.seekabrew.com might be able to peg down distro location (I'm not sure how correct it is these days). But then again, distributors aren't always going to ship out older batches either. Hmmm...maybe even posting a thread in the "FT forum" on here or checking out beerexchange. I'm sorry but I don't have any to trade right now or I'd help you.

 

[Der Fuchs]

As of last Summer, ABC hooked up with a distributor in South Dakota and started putting their beers in Michigan (that's the farthest East), they're at now. And I'm pretty sure, they go all the way South to Texas.

www.seekabrew.com might be able to peg down distro location (I'm not sure how correct it is these days). But then again, distributors aren't always going to ship out older batches either. Hmmm...maybe even posting a thread in the "FT forum" on here or checking out beerexchange. I'm sorry but I don't have any to trade right now or I'd help you.

Yep, I've been getting them from tx the last few years. I've looked for them old ones via trading in the past but came up empty handed. Maybe it is time to look again after I finish taking care of a few folks I owe boxes to.

 

[stakem1]

All this alaskan smoked porter talk is making me want to put my last bottle in the fridge and drink it fireside tonight...

 

[trickytunadicky]

2012 Eccentric Ale. Pumpkin, Sweet Potato, Butternut Squash, spices, honey and maple syrup.

Thin, off-white lacing. Not a great glass for aroma, but it mostly smells spicy.
Whatever under "spices" Bell's uses to jack up the bittering, it has lingered much longer than hops ever would. There is a light vegetal flavor on the back end if you look for it, but it is entirely characteristic of the squash used in the beer. There is some residual sweetness from the added sugars, but mostly they fermented out.

The beer is holding up well, considering the purpose of Eccentric Ale is not to be particulary good (though I would chug 2008 on the regularr).

 

[trickytunadicky]

Almost a decade old. Still stunning! Really great! Super pleased with this bottle. Glad I held onto it. No residual heat. Just caramel notes and liquid amazing. Drink em if you got em.

 

[ASUBeer]

This is not much of a review but I opened a 2010 Pannepot last weekend (after a few too many beers) and I was getting this really interesting stout like roastiness from it. Unlike any Pannepot I've had before.

Will revisit another bottle this weekend and post a more detailed review.

 

[Lognar]

Never had this beer before but it tastes damn good to me. A tiny bit of oxidation, but it's a benefit here as it balances the port and the dark fruits. Not overly sweet. Subdued roast, chocolate, and dark fruits.

I think the beer still has some good legs on it.

 

[trickytunadicky]

Never had this beer before but it tastes damn good to me. A tiny bit of oxidation, but it's a benefit here as it balances the port and the dark fruits. Not overly sweet. Subdued roast, chocolate, and dark fruits.

I think the beer still has some good legs on it.

Thanks for invite.

 

[nebuck]

Just opened up a November 2012 Palo Santo Marron. It's similar to fresh, with the distinctive spicy wood note in the forefront, except now there is a ton of indistinguishable dark fruits intermingled with the spiced wood.

This beer remains predominately palo santo wood after 2.5 years, but it is becoming a little more interesting. Does anyone have any experience with these with more age? As I always seem to have a couple of these hanging around, I'm curious if there is some experience with the barrel receding with further aging.

Sorry I'm a little late to the game replying to this. I had a 2010 and 2011 in January. The '11 was fine, but the '10 had fallen off quite a bit.