That **** blew me away. Arb, you're welcome to come by our rental if you get bored/thirsty at some point. Have to try to return the favor after I randomly showed up at your place beerless.
Nah, don't feel guilty about that. It's cool to get new blood and meet new people. I was just trying to highlight that it's pretty easy to think I do this stuff purely to stir up ****, and it's easy to overlook that I'm into beer. But I generally get along with people in person even if our opinions clash online. Just different opinions with similar passions.
Bottom line - I used to agree with you but now I don't (100%) because your stance is predicated on support of the law with which I do not agree. Also, the outcome of the illegal activity is insignificant at best.
Tbh, this discussion, which made me defend an ideology that I formed in 2008-2010, has made me realize I don't really agree with myself anymore, either -- or at least I'm more pragmatic about it. When there were fewer stores out there, it made much more sense to complain about the ones pulling underhanded **** and potentially hurting their competitors.
But now? Every Whole Foods is a destination bottleshop, Safeway carries Bourbon County, City Beer has lost their best accounts (c'mon guys, Midnight Sun sucks now), and all sorts of little stores have popped up. You're absolutely right that the outcome of illegal activity is insignificant NOW, though I maintain it made more sense 5+ years ago.
The only people this activity hurts are competing retailers. And they can police these issues. Honestly, however, it's not worth the time spent as the profit from legal product is larger proportionally.
Also agreed, 100%. I think I came around to analyzing it from a perspective of monetary alignment during those growler arguments a few years ago. Bottleshops are incentivized to police each other, but don't. I shouldn't bother, either.
And I'm willing to pay extra for convenience (capitalism!)
I'm torn on this. On the one hand, I see that, but on the other -- stores like Perry's are the equivalent of scalpers, or rats in the grainery. I don't know how much value is generated by their parasitic nonsense. But that gets more into political/economic issues.
TL; DR I vote with my wallet
Just to reiterate, I think a purchase (or lack thereof) is such a multifaceted decision, that simply doing so doesn't send the clearest message. It's spending AND giving feedback why, that makes a difference.
I've never been to perry's, but I also never go to russian river and have plenty of friends who can't ever go up there either.
So? You're not entitled to get your hands on everything they release. Either sack up and get in line like everyone else, or go without. You're not special. If the guys from SoCal can do it, someone from San Jose most certainly can.