Sigafoos
Well-Known Member
Thanks for your responses everybody.
Do you think that using close to 100% 2 row will be a bad idea? I probably misspoke, and it'll likely be closer to an amber than a pale ale.
Fat washing sounds interesting, and it'd be what Oliver would do if he ever made the beer, but it also sounds crazy and easy to mess up
I'm thinking I may want to make a bunch of small batches and compare first, but I don't know how I'd do that without it taking more effort than a 5g batch. Maybe mash/sparge the smoked malt separately, and then try a few other things? (ratio of smoked:not, different specialty malts, yeasts, etc) Bah. I'm going to overthink this til the day I brew it, I'm sure.
incutrav, welcome to the forums. And I got more of a smoked gouda out of the Urbock... I won't argue it though, because it was a while ago and no matter what it was it was tasty.
What I'm thinking now is:
11 or 12 lbs 2 row (can't remember which, and it's at home), 6 lbs of it smoked
1 lb Munich
1 oz Millennium (~12%aa) @60
The hops will give it about 35 IBUs, which should balance the malt but not make it hoppy. I might toss in a pinch of roasted barley for color (bringing it even more in line with an amber if I've got my facts right, though not on the hopping schedule)
Do you think that using close to 100% 2 row will be a bad idea? I probably misspoke, and it'll likely be closer to an amber than a pale ale.
Fat washing sounds interesting, and it'd be what Oliver would do if he ever made the beer, but it also sounds crazy and easy to mess up
I'm thinking I may want to make a bunch of small batches and compare first, but I don't know how I'd do that without it taking more effort than a 5g batch. Maybe mash/sparge the smoked malt separately, and then try a few other things? (ratio of smoked:not, different specialty malts, yeasts, etc) Bah. I'm going to overthink this til the day I brew it, I'm sure.
incutrav, welcome to the forums. And I got more of a smoked gouda out of the Urbock... I won't argue it though, because it was a while ago and no matter what it was it was tasty.
What I'm thinking now is:
11 or 12 lbs 2 row (can't remember which, and it's at home), 6 lbs of it smoked
1 lb Munich
1 oz Millennium (~12%aa) @60
The hops will give it about 35 IBUs, which should balance the malt but not make it hoppy. I might toss in a pinch of roasted barley for color (bringing it even more in line with an amber if I've got my facts right, though not on the hopping schedule)