Homebrew Talk - Beer, Wine, Mead, & Cider Brewing Discussion Forum

Help Support Homebrew Talk - Beer, Wine, Mead, & Cider Brewing Discussion Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
Gruit…what is it? Well for those of you who are unfamiliar with this term, it represents an entire forgotten past of brewing. For thousands of years humans have been brewing with whatever they could get their hands on. Before the 14th-16th century that included an extremely wide variety of spices, herbs, and grains. I’m sure hops were used occasionally but they weren’t the staple ingredient they are in beer today. It wasn’t until the 20th century that we started realizing the preservative properties of hops. After this, it only made sense to use them as a standard in modern day brews.
Thanks to the effort of the homebrew and craft brew brewery community, Gruit has made a come back of sorts. It’s still on the slow rise but I’m sure we’ll see some of the big breweries take on mass production of Gruit at some point (some have fooled around with them but I’ve never seen one stick around for long). I myself stumbled onto Gruits looking into brewing a beer without hops, not knowing that it was already a thing. After a lot of research, I knew one thing was clear: I was diving into less known waters. Due to the wider variety of ingredients and tastes, it was hard to gauge how certain ingredients at certain amounts would taste, as I’d never really dealt with some of them before. Yarrow, sweet gale, mugwort… “what the hell is this stuff?” I thought to myself. Naturally I ended up trying them all on their own, some in teas some just straight. First off, don’t chew mugwort. It’s basically like chewing on woodchips (I’m not really sure what possessed me to do so, as it looks like woodchips...). The only way to really get a feel for what some of these taste like is to just try them yourselves. I found myself at a local whole foods store in the bulk spice and herb isle picking up all kinds of random stuff I’d never heard of. This is also how I found how dead sea salt is not to be eaten…

What to Use in Place of Hops?


preparing sage for use in my gruit
To give you a little bit of an idea of what a Gruit recipe may have used, let’s take the Viking culture as an example. The Vikings may have used a wide variety of ingredients in what was known as grog at that time, but here are some possible ingredients they would have had access to: honey, wheat, barley, local fruits such as lingonberries or cranberries, and whatever herbs they had on hand. Possibly bog myrtle, yarrow, or juniper berries. The idea was to use whatever you could to make a sugary liquid, try to bitter it, and add flavors using herbs and fruits. After reading a few books on the subject it seems most were fermented from a spoon they used repeatedly for brewing which allowed the transfer of the yeast. Probably mostly open fermentation occurred. From this we can modernize the technique, and widen the range of ingredients, leaving room for unlimited possibilities!
Just as an example, listed below are some of the common ingredients I found to be used in Gruit.
  • Sweet Gale (aka Bog Myrtle)
  • Yarrow
  • Marsh Rosemary
  • Mugwort
  • Juniper Berries
  • Wormwood
  • Labrador Tea
  • Heather
  • Spruce Tips
  • Sage
  • Ginger
  • Lemongrass
  • Horehound
  • Lavender
  • Aniseed
The list goes on and on. Just like hops, you would add them at different points during the boil to either get bittering, flavor and/or aroma, although not all of them serve both functions of course. The big difference is some of these herbs can have a psychotropic or stimulant affect if used in a certain way. For instance, wormwood is one of the main ingredients in the original Absinthe which gives it the “trippy” affect. Sweet gale also has a stimulant affect if used at flame out or “dry hopped”. Cultures throughout history made these for medical reasons due to these affects. The trick with this is finding out how much is too much of something. Some of these ingredients such as wormwood or Labrador tea could be fatal if overused. With these things I feel it’s best to use a small amount, or use them in a manner where you aren’t getting any of that extra affect, unless you know for sure what you’re doing. This part took a lot of researching as well.

Brewing a Gruit


boiling the gruit with sage additions in a hop bag.
After looking into all of this and finding some base recipes, I decided it was time to brew my own. The biggest hurdle was what to brew. With so many options, I needed to decide what ingredients to use. The grain bill wasn’t difficult, but the herbs and spices took me some time. I finally decided on a Sage Gruit. After trying all the herbs/spices I could get my hands on, I picked mugwort as my bittering agent. I almost went with wormwood but it’s very strong, and I didn’t want to overwhelm the bittering aspect. I find sage rather pleasant so it seemed like a good starting point.
With my ingredients chosen, I’m ready to dive into a new brewing territory, and then I realize… how much of this stuff am I even to use? I had tasted all of it, but never used it on a scale larger than a tea cup, and even then how would these flavors hold up after fermentation and aging. After doing a little more research on how much was used in other recipes, I came up with the amount I was going to use. I also decided on just doing a gallon batch with these, as I didn’t want to dump more than that if I had to.
Brew day was here! I decided on a four addition schedule. I went with a 60-minute boil and added my first round of sage . At the 45-minute mark I added my mugwort in a hop bag. At 20 minutes I went head and added my second round of sage. And finally, at boil out I added the last of the sage. In total I used about 1.7 oz of sage, and .60 oz of mugwort during the boil process. I chilled the wort, took a hydrometer reading (1.060), transferred the wort to the carboy, and pitched some S-04 yeast. I tasted the hydrometer sample and it was interesting, in a good way. It was very mild and not aggressive at all. My first thought on it was that it could have used more sage. I figured I’d take a taste once it was done fermenting and see how the flavor held up.
After 2 weeks of pretty active fermenting, I was finally ready to move on. While waiting for it to ferment, I started tinkering with the recipe again, and thought it would be interesting to add some oak flavor to it. I had some Jack Daniel’s oak barrel wood, so I figured why not. I ended up soaking the barrel pieces in some single barrel JD’s to get them ready for secondary. After another reading (FG 1.022) and tasting, I decided it needed more sage flavor. However, the mugwort bittering seemed pretty spot on. I ended up racking the Gruit into secondary, and dry hopped with about another ounce of fresh sage. I also added the JD barrel chips. I didn’t use many, as I wanted the flavor to be subtle. I let the Gruit sit in secondary for about a week, and decided it was time to bottle.
I ended up with 11 and a half bottles worth. I of course just ended up trying the half bottle. I thought it was a bit sour from just coming off the oak, but I knew that would fade with time. I primed the bottles and let it sit for 3 weeks.
Here it was, the day had come to finally try my first home brew Gruit (I was way too excited for this). I cracked a bottle open, which was perfectly carbonated, and took my first taste. The oak had faded quite a bit, but it could probably use another week or two of aging. The sage was very pleasant and not overwhelming, and the mugwort added a nice mild bitterness. I’m interested in seeing how these flavors develop over time, so I continue to try one every few weeks or so. The flavors have slowly started to develop. The oak has faded and now it’s just subtle notes. The sage is the dominant flavor, and the mugwort still holds its mild bitterness. Overall I’m liking it more as it ages. Since then I’ve brewed another 2 Gruits including a lavender grapefruit Gruit, and a Gruit/Braggot type brew. As far as brewing goes, I feel like I’m in foreign territory. Although there is some information out there, there really isn’t a lot of it, considering the available information on beer, meads, wine and ciders. Hopefully with the rise of home brewing, we’ll see this forgotten piece of brewing history take flight once again.

In Conclusion


finished sage gruit
If things go right, I may be opening a brewery sometime next year, and will be focusing on Gruit as a part of that. I really want there to be more information and more brews out there for the beer community to try, and if I have to, I’ll be the one to do it! All I can say is it’s been a rewarding experience to learn, and continue to learn, about the lost art of brewing Gruit. For anyone interested in getting into brewing Gruits, I highly recommend you do as much research as possible. I also suggest once you find an herb/spice you like, if it’s doable for you, then grow it yourself! There is limited information out there, but there are some websites and books that really helped me out. ( https://denardbrewing.com/blog/post/gruit-mead/ http://www.gruitale.com/rec_modern_gruit.htm https://yearofgruit.wordpress.com/, and the book Sacred and Herbal Healing beers: The secrets of ancient fermentation
After that, it’s all trial and error. So to all the current brewers and future brewers of Gruit out there: good luck and brew on!
gruit-Feat.jpg
 
I was thinking about brewing a 1 Gal. Gruit recipe that I found in, "Strong Waters: A Simple Guide to Making Beer, Wine, Cider and Other Spirited Beverages at Home.”by Scott Mansfield"
The herbs called for are;
1 tablespoon dried yarrow
1 heaping tablespoon dried Saint-John’s-wort
1 tablespoon dried mugwort .
I've found Saint-John's-wort, (in capsules that I can open as needed), but can't find the Yarrow or Mugwort locally.
I did find some wormwood at my LHBS....
I'm thinking of using 1.5 Tbs of Saint-John's-Wort and 1.5 Tsp of the Wormwood...
Thoughts anyone???
 
The use of hops also has the advantage, in perception or fact, that beer made with hops lasts longer and resists spoilage better than that made with gruit.
 
Nice article. I am now read to try this distinct style of brewing. Thanks.
 
I got an idea I need people to chime in on this one I have several ideas about it , it will be something weird but hopefully delicious. I am thinking as far as my wort goes I have a pound of malted wheat flour and a pound of sprouted red rice ,10 lb of pearl barley some of which I have roasted to a dark brown color some of which I have roasted to a light brown color and a small amount I smoked in the smoker until it was yellowish, all together the roasted and smoked portion is about 3 lbs , also I plan to add apples not only for sugar and a little flavor but also for their amylase , and I plan to add between 3 and 5 lbs of white rice and some honey (more amylase available adding sugars and hopefully some more body to the mix, I plan to do a really long slow mash probably start at 144 or so for an hour then 148 for an hour then 152 for an hour then finally 157 for an hour(apparently to break down rice starches the mashing needs to be really long also I figure it will give plenty of time for what amylase is available to break down the pearl barley along with the malted wheat flour and sprouted red rice starches also, after a very long mash I plan to sparge it well and boil it all the way down to 4.5 gallons, I have coriander,juniper berries,cloves, and home collected from a friend's tree grapefruit peel (I figure also remember the apples which I know apfelwien has a bit of a weissbier like flavor at times) which I'm not sure how much of each I plan to add yet ,what I want people's ideas and opinions on is other herbs to add, how much of the current herbs and spices should be added I'm also hoping to make it somewhat of a lightly moderate body to it(which the rice I know will lighten the body a lot along with the apples so I'm not certain how to add body my plans on yeast will explain my relatively high carb in a moment) I figure I could add honey to boost the body and I don't mind it being nearly a gruit braggot(i am actually considering adding some rolled oats for body idk how that would effect it over all since it will not have high srm I like oatmeal stouts a lot but this will be a little different, and I don't want a big oatmeal flavor over powering the main part but I have 5 gallons of mead(all in secondary currently several flavors) I was considering only making a small wort after a lot of boiling cutting out the rice for the most part and adding a gallon or so maybe even more to the wort and letting it ferment that way just ideas ) I also have a whole vanilla bean I was thinking I might some how use in this gruit preparation as well maybe using just a little in the secondary on it I could just add honey if I could find a good bittering agent(i know hops is great and all but I am on purposely avoiding convention on this project so hops are a no no) I want ideas thoughts opinions I know I am going very low on atlases containing grains but I figure long mash with lots of rest plenty of sparge water and boiling it down quite far I don't know I mean I've brewed several beers so far all except one has come out great but this one in particular is meant to be both grocery store challenge worthy with a coriander grapefruit(in place of orange peel )peel with some sahti like notes(one of the reasons I got clove because I particularly like to do my secondary fermenter with quite a bit of pressure it makes my beer really effervescent and it keeps the yeast from going beyond where I want it to on various scents and taste(also I have in my last two brews used irish ale yeast then in secondary after a couple weeks I add a pack of bread yeast(which really ups the carbonation) I plan to either use bread yeast or a yeast cake I already have around(of course this is to prevent from breaking the rules of the grocery store brewing ) , I hope for it to have some spicy notes(a lot like a wit but also with the grapefruit like notes(i have gone mad about this wonderful beer tangier southern tier ipa it says brewed with tangerine peel but it taste so much like grapefruit in the best way possible I plan to attempt a clone within my next 5 batches) pretty much I am aiming for something unique that is hopefully delicious also I have fresh ginger sitting around if anyone has thoughts on that I want your ideas feed me your thoughts please
 
I know to the forum, but have been brewing regularly for the past three years.
Hoos, I think the honey will thin it out more than add body. I know that's what candy sugar does in my Belgian ales and the two meads I have brewed were both very thin.
I plan on making a gruit with Frankincense and myrrh, and perhaps some additional perfume aromatics, perhaps rose oil and lavender. I've read somewhere that the myrrh is very bitter, I plan on using this for the primary bittering agent and the other aromatics for taste/aroma. What do you think?
 
how did the experiment(s) turn out? I have several nice herbs waiting to make some gruit...I just don't want to wast them or the beer by not following a tested recipe. I'm thinking I will use a brown ale base and just add the herbs...
 
Back
Top