Any brewers here that have lost their sense of smell?

Homebrew Talk - Beer, Wine, Mead, & Cider Brewing Discussion Forum

Help Support Homebrew Talk - Beer, Wine, Mead, & Cider Brewing Discussion Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

jleiii

Well-Known Member
Joined
Sep 9, 2013
Messages
582
Reaction score
114
Location
Rock Hall
I came to the realization late last year that I had some level of loss of smell, but it apparently was a gradual change and I have no idea when it started. I've been to a specialist, had an CAT scan, MRI, and endoscopy, but nothing was found in any of them.
There are basically 4 things that are attributed to causing this, head trauma, sinusitis, other sinus issue, and unknown. Seems I fall into the latter as I've never had any other conditions. I don't have allergies, don't smoke, and don't huff foreign substances. I can't say 'never' to all of them, but it's been 30+ years....
Probably due to job and personal stresses I developed high blood pressure which required medication starting about 2 years ago. I researched the meds I take, and both have had reports of smell loss in a tiny fraction, like 15 in 20,000, but that may not even be as high as the general population, so I'm not convinced there it's related, yet. I will be talking to my cardiologist though. I've done some research, and there could be some (many?) other options, but I'm not sure I want to go the route of some, and have to consider the blood pressure impacts as well.

Getting on to the brewing aspect, I grow my own hops, and can't smell them but slightly. I thought last years crop was a bust as there was no aroma, and I even posted about causes for that here on HBT, but in the end, I think it was my own lack of smell at fault. My current crop is about ready for harvest, and again I can barely smell them. It just occurred to me that I should bring some to the next club meeting and get some feedback from brewers. My wife and son really can't judge them for me.
I've been continuing to brew, although not very frequently, and have managed to make some good beers. I've made it through 3 rounds in our club head-to-head competition, One round took a bronze at another club, and gold in another. The latest round didn't place in another competition, but I got a 31 & 32, so I can't complain. In spite of not being able to taste them very well, I'm doing OK with them.
At this point I'm beginning to wonder if it's worth the effort to continue. I have spend a good some of money building an electric setup and glycol chilled fermentation chambers, but for me the project aspect is also a significant part of my interest. There are a few more things I'l like to work on, but I can't decide if it's worth the effort. I have other interests that could use the time, and that's beginning to weigh heavily in the decision process. I've been on Untappd for years, and always looking for new beers to try, but the luster of that is wearing thin lately as well.

I by chance was talking to a fellow club member at the last meeting, and learned that he has also lost his sense of smell (FYI, much of your taste is also lost....), but in his case it was due to sinus surgery. He is also a partner in a local microbrewery, and that's got to be really tough for him. While not -all- smells are lost for me, he pointed out one I'd not thought about, natural gas/propane. For him it's a critical problem as he can not/will not brew alone on their system. With my electric setup it's not a concern for me, but I do have gas at my shop, and viola, I can't smell it either. Some things I can't smell aren't so bad - skunks and porta-potties, but many others can be considered a health risk. My wife accused me of trying to kill us when I was cleaning the bathroom recently - chlorine based cleaner. While that's not a huge risk, I do use bleach for periodic cleaning of my keg cooler. Initially I thought my old cheap bleach was bad, so I got some fresh stuff from the laundry, and still nothing. There's no telling how bad it really was as I was home alone, in the basement at the time. Once I realized it was me, I put on an exhaust fan, and know better now. There are a multitude of other things that most people take for granted, but once you can't smell most things you begin to realize the significance.

So fellow non-smellers, any advice to offer on your experiences, and or solutions?
 
I seem to have lost a little of my sense of smell - age related, I think. For me, it seems the only real problem is that I have a lot of trouble identifying off flavors (I guess because a lot of what we taste is related to smell). My feeling is that if you still enjoy the beer, stay with it as long as you can. You might get to the point where you're getting infections or other off flavors and can't trouble shoot the problem. Then you might have to give it up. But the other brew club members might be able to get you back on track.
 
I've never been good at off flavors. At this point I really can no longer even distinguish between similar styles. Stouts and porters are still obvious by taste, but pale ales, most IPAs, and other 'lightly' flavored beers are all a wash. Only the super hoppy IPAs will come through a little. And I miss them! Lambics/sours stands out as the tongue detects them, but I don't like them. I did find that skunks, gas odor and some off flavors are all related by 'thiol' compounds. I can also smell 60's car exhaust pretty well, although it does not smell right, so it seems to be smell specific, not everything.
While I can't discount age at 57, I'm not convinced that's it, yet. I had a head cold with a mild sinus infection 2 yrs ago, and had to fly before it was 100% gone, and as we approached cruising altitude there was pop in my nasal passages and a rush of smells descended upon me. It was very dramatic but I just assumed that it was related to the cold and never gave it another thought. I get a mild head cold maybe every other year, but it's usually gone in a few days. That last one lasted like 10 days though, and nothing more than a few sniffles last winter.
My specialist suggested I look for hospitals and universities that do smell and taste studies and see if I can get into one.
I'm not ready to throw in the towel yet, and hoping others have some insight to offer.
 
My wife lost a large proportion of her sense of smell and the hearing in one ear from car accident head trauma when she was a teenager. From my understanding it had something to do with hood surfing.

Awesome for me, I don't have to shower on the weekends. And I can grumble under my breath with impunity...as long as I'm on her left hand side and slightly to the rear.

Perhaps that is why she only likes the hoppiest of the hoppy IPA's...nothing else gets through.
 
Perhaps that is why she only likes the hoppiest of the hoppy IPA's...nothing else gets through.

Good possibility of that.
My sense of smell isn't very good and i favor big bold flavors as subtle ones are usually lost on my palette.
 
Back
Top