• Please visit and share your knowledge at our sister communities:
  • If you have not, please join our official Homebrewing Facebook Group!

    Homebrewing Facebook Group

Who's smoking meat this weekend?

Homebrew Talk

Help Support Homebrew Talk:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
This isn't the happiest of posts, but I fall on the sword to warn you all away from a specific recipe that sounded great, but did NOT work... At all.

Last night I made this smoked pork loin recipe from Meat Church. Seems like it would be super flavorful. Marinated a store-bought pork loin in the bag for about 5+ hours (they recommend ~4, so I figured I was good). It's marinated in orange, lemon, and lime juice, so there should be a ton of citrus / acid hit. It also includes onion, garlic, and spices. So there should be plenty there. Then after marinade it's pretty heavily doused with lemon pepper seasoning, and put on the smoker.

I have no idea how it would be possible for something with THAT recipe to come out basically tasteless, but it did. It didn't seem that the marinade flavor came through at all. Got a tiny amount of lemon pepper. But it being pork loin, sliced, the surface area around the edges where the little bit of flavor existed simply didn't have enough to match the size of the piece of meat. And the recipe called for cooking it JUST on the smoker, but it didn't get any color despite my smoker running a constant 240 degrees, so at about 125* IT I pulled it off and seared it in a pan with olive oil, then finished it in the oven.

I know with any new recipe, there's a question of whether to blame the recipe, or whether to blame the cook. And believe me, I've had some times where I know it was my execution getting in the way. But I don't think this was one of them. I think it was just a weak recipe.

It *might* do a little better on a smaller and more flavorful piece of pork like a tenderloin, with a smaller cross-section than a loin. Or it *might* be something that could be modified and pivoted to cook with shoulder in a slow cooker, where the meat would be shredded and allow some of that flavor in the marinade to permeate everything. But this? It just didn't work at all.
 
This isn't the happiest of posts, but I fall on the sword to warn you all away from a specific recipe that sounded great, but did NOT work... At all.

Last night I made this smoked pork loin recipe from Meat Church. Seems like it would be super flavorful. Marinated a store-bought pork loin in the bag for about 5+ hours (they recommend ~4, so I figured I was good). It's marinated in orange, lemon, and lime juice, so there should be a ton of citrus / acid hit. It also includes onion, garlic, and spices. So there should be plenty there. Then after marinade it's pretty heavily doused with lemon pepper seasoning, and put on the smoker.

I have no idea how it would be possible for something with THAT recipe to come out basically tasteless, but it did. It didn't seem that the marinade flavor came through at all. Got a tiny amount of lemon pepper. But it being pork loin, sliced, the surface area around the edges where the little bit of flavor existed simply didn't have enough to match the size of the piece of meat. And the recipe called for cooking it JUST on the smoker, but it didn't get any color despite my smoker running a constant 240 degrees, so at about 125* IT I pulled it off and seared it in a pan with olive oil, then finished it in the oven.

I know with any new recipe, there's a question of whether to blame the recipe, or whether to blame the cook. And believe me, I've had some times where I know it was my execution getting in the way. But I don't think this was one of them. I think it was just a weak recipe.

It *might* do a little better on a smaller and more flavorful piece of pork like a tenderloin, with a smaller cross-section than a loin. Or it *might* be something that could be modified and pivoted to cook with shoulder in a slow cooker, where the meat would be shredded and allow some of that flavor in the marinade to permeate everything. But this? It just didn't work at all.
I've never found much flavor in a liquid brine, not that I've tried more than a handful. They are always lacking in flavor to me. I really like the dry rubs and finishing glazes/sauces much better.
 
Ti's the season, literally... smoked 2 trout, caught from a small creek, not lake trout, these boys were fighters, 20 and 18 inch, fed 5 of us tonight with leftover, smoked at 210 for 2 hours had to bump up the temp at the end to finish them. Excellent, I shoulda took a pic once the skin was off, a nice pinkish color to it, perfect.
20250409_194614.jpg
 
Not exactly smoking, but I put homemade German bratwursts in a dark homebrew and onions and simmered them outside on the wood stove. Afterwards, I drained them (the dogs loved that on their dog food 🤣), added fresh onions and beer and let them sit in the fridge overnight. Now, they are on the stove, simmering in my homemade kraut!
 
Was eating too much meat. Forgot to post the final product. Full sheet pan from just three butts. Carolina Gold Sauce and slaw. Made pintos and some smashed taters. Rest went to the freezer. Happy with the smoke flavor from the pellets and enjoyed the fairly hands off cook. Was snowing and raining most of the day and that woulda been an issue with the WSM.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_7926.jpeg
    IMG_7926.jpeg
    1.7 MB
  • IMG_7916.jpeg
    IMG_7916.jpeg
    1.9 MB
  • IMG_7900.jpeg
    IMG_7900.jpeg
    1.5 MB
  • IMG_7898.jpeg
    IMG_7898.jpeg
    1.5 MB
  • IMG_7907.jpeg
    IMG_7907.jpeg
    1.5 MB
  • IMG_1188.jpeg
    IMG_1188.jpeg
    2.6 MB
  • IMG_7899.jpeg
    IMG_7899.jpeg
    1.8 MB
Yesterday, smoked trout, also in the garage dodging the rain.
View attachment 874821
What's your tips for smoking trout?
I'm still a N00b with meat and would hate to mess up on fish. I don't usually smoke when I go on my fishing trips but I just got a nice little Oklahoma Joe thing i wouldn't mind bringing. I'm always a simple is best kind of person. Pan fry.
 
What's your tips for smoking trout?
I'm still a N00b with meat and would hate to mess up on fish. I don't usually smoke when I go on my fishing trips but I just got a nice little Oklahoma Joe thing i wouldn't mind bringing. I'm always a simple is best kind of person. Pan fry.
Trout is easy, set the smoker up for 200f ish and about 2 hours it should be ready... I can give you some more detail one I'm home but that's the general gist of it... some people do the brine and fridge til you get a pellicle but I don't bother with that.. I just smoke with butter and lemon in the middle, skin on, no fileting or anything.. they can be finicky to filet .
 
I usually smoke salmon or very large trout, and I like to cut it up and brine it overnight (dry brine in fridge usually). I think Bailey Mountain's technique would work quite well, and seems like it would be a lot less prep.
While out on a trip pan frying is a my favourite. Fast and keeps the fish juicy. Another good method while camping or shore lunch is stuffed with lemon a bit of butter salt and pepper or whatever and wrapped in foil directly on the coals of a campfire (my Dad used to swear by wrapping in a wet paper bag). Extra bonus if you make biscuits or cinnamon rolls in a dutch oven over the same coals to go with them. On canoe trips my partner Lori would roll the cinnamon roll dough out on the bottom of an upside down canoe.
 
I had to replace my car tire the other week and found my filet and oyster knife in the back trunk. Add IG posting of ice out and I'm itching to hit the lakes.

I bought one of those higher end Lodge cast iron skillets and that's what's usually in the back of the trunk with the rod to fry with lemon and butter/dill. I like those pans. Easy lightweight packin'

I'll have to give smoking a try as my first google search came back with low and slow for fish doesn't give good results. I know cold smoking is good
 
Last edited:
Like @acrowe my standard method is stuff with butter and lemon and season with a little pepper or whatever you like and wrap in foil, throw it on the grill or campfire. Easy and comes out great. I didn't follow any specific recipe when I started smoking them, I just set the smoker for 200 to 220 and let it go for 2 hours, put some water in the tray to help keep it from drying out and it came out great, skin peels easy and bones pull right out. I did his method in the past with brining overnight and that works too but I just skipped that step to see what happened. I leave salt out of my cooking when possible, bad for my ticker...
 
I'm smoking 7 pork loins, around 5lbs apiece, for a graduation party this weekend. I filled the pellet hopper just before 2am and woke up to the thermometers reading slightly over 140°F. I increased the temperature of the cook chamber 5°, and 90min later it looks like we're in the home stretch. If I remember I'll take a picture and add it to this post when it finishes up.

Edit:
PXL_20250522_143446970.jpg


I learned something today about the hot spots in my smoker. I pulled the bottom left one before I took this picture, as my thermometer read over 170°. The other two on the bottom are also wrapped and resting, since they were both a little more than 165° (the one with a probe in was 6° higher on my other thermometer). The top two are almost done, and the middle two will be a while.
 
Last edited:
Doing beef cheeks for memorial day weekend. Taco's with barbacoa meat and... Kimchi!!

Pre flip pic after two hours @300° and post flip pic for two more hours at 250°. Then it's on to the braise in the crock pot for 4 more hours (stock and tallow liquid) 🤠😍😎
 

Attachments

  • IMG_20250525_123633929.jpg
    IMG_20250525_123633929.jpg
    1.5 MB
  • IMG_20250525_123314181.jpg
    IMG_20250525_123314181.jpg
    1.4 MB
Back
Top