I've reused Notty for a number of IPAs, so any American-style IPA recipe should be fine. Probably would work fine with English IPAs as well, but I've not tried it. Lots of attenuation, but you probably know that already.
As for volume to use in your next batch, I would suggest consulting
www.mrmalty.com, which has a calculator (
http://www.mrmalty.com/calc/calc.html) you can use to determine how much of the harvested yeast to use. It will differ slightly for each recipe. I sometimes use about 1/2 cup and call it good if I don't feel like being too technical, depending on the recipe. No, you definitely don't need to use all 2.5 qts unless you're making a huge barleywine or something like that. You might let it warm a little at room temp prior to pitching...maybe an hour or so, but make sure it's not sealed tight. I did that once and it started buckling the lid on my mason jar...then overflowed once I opened it.
Also, if you haven't used it in awhile (maybe a few months), you may want to make a new starter to wake it up. I don't think it's always necessary, and I rarely take this step, but it may get fermentation started a bit quicker. I know lots of people here on HBT recommend a new starter with reused slurry.
These are just my personal opinions and observations...I'm sure others who are more astute will provide different recommendations.