Excellent tasting as usual tonight. Jacob was absent but Andrew and Steven combined to deliver everything we could want to know about the beers and League updates. Steven - looking forward to doing LA, Portland, and San Diego preview tastings every month?
Preface to the beers - This will probably sound like I'm being a Modern Times apologist, but it's a format-specific issue to nitro cans. Splitting them across multiple small pours tends to result in a sub-optimal mouthfeel and aroma, so my thoughts on the beers might not be entirely reflective of what we'll taste out of the cans once we get them. Not a complaint at all, I appreciate the preview tastings and it's as close as we can get, just providing some context to the scores and notes. As an example, I tried NOLA BA DT on draft and thought it was a 4.5 beer but when I got home and cracked a full can, I was immediately texting a couple friends about how it was knocking my tits off. Your mileage may vary.
BA Devil's Teeth w/ Pistachios & Coconut - 4.75 - As with the other variants, it spent eight to twelve months in barrels. 150lbs of roasted pistachios spread across the batch and over five pounds of coconut per barrel, which was blend of both toasted and untoasted coconut. Aroma is dominated by roasted pistachio with coconut being fairly mild. The palate flips the script with coconut going hard in the paint - not crossing into suntan lotion though - while the pistachio supports and vanilla and barrel notes lurk in the background. The most dessert-like of tonight's DT variants, Andrew's comment about it being liquid Rocky Road ice cream wasn't far off.
BA Devil's Teeth w/ Strawberries & Vanilla - 4.25 - Freeze dried strawberry powder and, directly quoting Andrew, "a lot of vanilla." The vanilla - 100% Madagascar vanilla beans - was added fairly early and some of the barrels aged on vanilla beans for six to eight weeks. The nose was a bit muted but as it warmed it revealed more vanilla than strawberry, with the fruit taking a slightly earthier hue. On the palate, rounded strawberry led with moderate vanilla character coming behind it and a finish of earthy, bittersweet chocolate. Of all the variants, I found this one the hardest to get a great read on. It showed all the components properly and is quite good, but I think enjoying a can to myself will be very enlightening.
BA Devil's Teeth w/ Raspberries & BA Coffee - 4.5 - Freeze dried raspberries and 90 lbs of barrel aged coffee. Nose is dominated by BA coffee character with raspberry tickling at the edges, intermingling with the coffee itself. The palate opens up with massive coffee character but quickly rolls into chocolate covered raspberries - semisweet, but far from cloying. The balance between the chocolate/raspberry side and the coffee side is well executed, with barrel and vanilla notes playing between the two. I think the mix of adjuncts works well, but I also have to admit, I probably would've preferred nitro cans of BA DT w/ BA Coffee. That has generally been my favorite BA DT variant and I certainly enjoyed the addition of raspberry - and will be buying cans - I don't think it was an improvement. I'm glad to see Modern Times experimenting and taking chances, but I definitely hope to see BA DT w/ BA Coffee make a return next year (be it bottles, cans, or nitro cans).
Palace of Paper Sacks - 4.5 - Saison base aged in both red and white wine barrels with Rose Diamond nectarines from Masumoto Farms, adjuncted at a rate of roughly two pounds per barrel. Twelve months in barrels with mixed cultures, three months on fruit, then several months of bottle conditioning. Nose is huge on nectarines, redolent of biting into a perfectly ripe piece of stone fruit - just huge, juicy nectarine with mild acidity and funk backing it up. Moderate acidity hits the tongue first, followed by more of the massive nectarine character and some mild to moderate funk. Long finish of lactic acidity and oak. Most of us agreed it was better than batch one, which was a damn good beer in its own right.
Assorted Notes:
1) An informal poll at the end of the tasting for favorite BA DT variant showed a roughly event split for NOLA and Pistachio/Coconut with a few votes for Raspberry/BA Coffee. I voted NOLA based on what I've tasted so far, but I'm curious to revisit once I've had a chance to drink a can of each all to myself. Right now, my order is NOLA > Pistachio/Coconut >> Raspberry/BA Coffee >> Strawberry/Vanilla, but I'm willing to be surprised once I've had time to assess them in a more controlled environment (namely, sitting on my couch watching concert DVDs).
2) Andrew asked if we wanted more info or less info in preview tastings. Thankfully, no one said less, but I'm curious if other people care about some of the details that they share and I try to pass on. I love getting info like dosage rates for adjuncts, sources of adjuncts, etc., but it's something they're looking for feedback on. If you like all this info, comment so they'll keep sharing it.
3) The Fermentorium has its crowler machine up and running and League members can get crowlers of anything that is also available for League fills. Not sure if/when North Park will get a crowler machine. We were also told that we should expect to see an expanded selection of options for crowlers in 2018. It will be an evolving set of rules, but essentially, we should be able to get fills of anything except barrel aged beers and the current monthly hazy IPA can release. Don't take that as gospel, but that's the rough idea. Also on the crowler front, the League will get two included crowler fills and the ToLC will get four included crowler fills. Rather than specific beers, as we got in 2017, we'll get vouchers for free fills - with some exclusions for expensive fills - that we can use on whatever we want.
4) Ice will be a year round draft beer moving forward. This pleases me. Cans would be rad, but as long as we can grab crowlers of it whenever we want (more or less), that will suffice.
5) LA and Portland are both on track to be open by 01/01/18. Steven might have provided a more specific estimate on LA, but in protest of Kurtis MacDermid of the Kings being a ******* goon and injuring Ondrej Kase tonight, I'm choosing to not relay it. **** LA.
6) Bonus beer thoughts - Almost Finally Open in LA and Night Tides are both damn good. Night Tides is a touch green but has a really nice hop profile, I think it'll be excellent in cans.
7) Bonus bonus beer thought - The new batch of Black House w/ Coconut & Cacao Nibs is dialed in, the coconut is absolutely on point. Nice to have something in the fridge on the dessert end of the spectrum that's not 13% ABV.