Just an update, I know I said I would side by side, and just to keep my word, I promise I'll give side by side comparisons soon with pictures. However, I had this beer yesterday so here are my notes:
A: Pours a hazy yellow orange with small white head (not fully carved yet)
S: Smells like citrus, tart fruit, mostly grapefruity nose, can't really distinguish strawberry
T: Absolutely delicious, fruity, some citric acid from the fruit, resfreshing. Tastes like a mix of grapefruit and strawberry, more grapefruit.
M: Light, easy to drink, dangerous...
All in all I'm calling this beer a successful batch, but absolutely nowhere near cloned to Strawberry harvest. A noble attempt though. I still stand by my original statement that I nailed the base beer. If I was going to do it again I would shrink the grain bill to get 4.2% instead of 5.2%, was a little too efficient. I would lager it with German Lager yeast, as I've come to learn that's pretty close to what Abita uses. Lastly I would juice the strawberries and rack the bright beer into the strawberry juice and leave it cold so the strawberries didn't ferment at all.
On another note, my wife, who absolutely hates beer, really loves this one!