Exactly!
Good point about the modular pieces.
Do you know something about Spiedel that I don't?
I would love a smaller all in one like the 10l braumeister that had a full size mash basket. The others on the market like brewzilla and the S40 are huge. It would also be cool if they had accelerated heating ability.
IMO, the 10l version is too small, and I believe it only comes in a 110V version. The 50l version is too large for home brew sized brewing, and is essentially a 20l system fitted with a 240V heating system that’s 2x as large as the 20l with 2 recirc pumps. It’s also bulky and quite heavy.
Braumeister also manufactures much larger brewery-sized systems starting at 200l and greater capacities which are not mobile and more like ‘pilot brew’ systems for brewery application settings. Their homebrew systems were developed as an extension of their commercial brewery business.
All that said, the 20l system is a beast, built like a tank, maybe to the point of over-engineered. There have been some improvements and additions over the years, including a jacketed model designed to eliminate the need for IC cooling systems in the post-boil. I’ve heard it’s not nearly as effective as a stainless steel coil chiller or plate chiller, however. It might have been an attempt to make a true all-in-one mash, boil, ferment, cold crash device. Meh.
Maybe 5 years ago I bought a LODO kit that I found to be very useful, that also allows for slightly higher brew volumes and malt bills. Originally the ‘advertised’ maximums were 25l and about 10# of grist. Now my regular brew day is at least 4-5 liters more strike water and 12.5# of grains. I get 83-85%
mash efficiency, and 7.5 gal. pre-boil volumes with 6.3 gal. batch volumes into the fermenter, after trub and boil-off losses.
Last year I added a shortened malt pipe that allows me to brew 10l+ volumes, since just like the rest of us I’m drinking less and doing less entertaining, post Covid. It’s been a learning curve to get my proportions scaled properly from standard 5 gallon size, but my recipes are finally getting to where I like them.
Every now & then, I’ll see some other system that captures my attention, but then I come back to reality and realize that “new” doesn’t always equate with “better.” The downside of my 20l Braumeister was the 240V power requirement (amortizated years ago for less than $100) and the weight of the system. It only takes around :20 minutes to heat 9 gallons of strike water from ambient to 50C, which is about the same amount of time it takes me to crush grains in the morning.
The older I get, I realize that if it’s built like a tank, it can almost approach the weight of a tank, especially when moving it inside to transfer the wort to the fermenter. I mounted it on an 1 ½” thick hardwood base with 3” locking casters so that certainly added to the overall gross weight, but it still has to get ‘lifted’ across the threshold track of a sliding glass door to get it inside my brew area.
But, yeah, I’m a fan boi. Not trading my toy in for a new system unless this one up and dies on me. But at this rate, I’m assuming that
I’ll be the first one to quit.