FWIW, I was on the "unpackaging" team for a couple of 400+ entry events in 2017-2018.
Even then, the advice in #3 and #4 (above) was the simplest approach to getting bottles, unbroken, to the event.
FWIW, back then, packaging material was either re-used or re-cycled. So a pro tip: find a bottle sort event and help with unpackaging.
Yeah, I feel ya. I hate electrical tape for this very reason. I use Gorilla tape over duct tape instead...no residue.
Srrrrsly though. I will use electrical tape to prep for transit, but I will double-back a third of the sticky side on itself, then wrap. That way, no sticky part on the bottle and no residue. Limited effort to remove the tape and you don't have to worry about the cap puncturing the Ziplock/suck & seal bag.
My experience with "unpackaging" was that very few bottles break during shipping. I didn't saw a failure when packaging products, like the ones mentioned in #3 & #4, were used (and they can be re-used). Filling the box with "air bags" or "packaging peanuts" was also effective - but a PITA for the unpackaging team and for the home brewing / craft brewing business that offered space (and dumpsters) for the bottle sort.
Any "limited effort to remove" is additional effort. And additional handling of the bottle. Which slows down, un-necessiarly, the "unpackaging" process.
Help make "unpackaging" as simple as opening the clam-shell, removing the bottle, applying any further routing label, and placing it in a larger container. Just say no to extra tape.