• Please visit and share your knowledge at our sister communities:
  • If you have not, please join our official Homebrewing Facebook Group!

    Homebrewing Facebook Group

Selling homebrews

Homebrew Talk

Help Support Homebrew Talk:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
http://www.cvrd.bc.ca/DocumentCenter/View/63794

I've spoken with several breweries in the area, and as far as any of us know that seems to be the case.
The brewery that sells there may be on privately owned property, but I'm willing to bet he got that section zoned for that or went through a pile of paperwork to be able to license the secondary building.
The licensing is a bit trickier than just the 12 month lease aspect, but owning it is a step in the right direction.

I hope I'm completely wrong on this! I wish you all the luck!
Please let me know if I'm wrong, that'd be the best news! Hahaha
 
Ill pursue this one dont you worry haha, ill got talk with the brewer this weekend if i can and see what legalities are involved and how he does it. The impression i got from people ive talked with is that it was available to anyone, maybe not the case tho. Ill get to the bottom of this lol......
 
Sounds good, I look forward to hearing what you find.
Give me a shout if you ever find yourself in Vancouver, perhaps trade some pints!
:tank:
 
I'm not sure about the MN liquor laws, but in my state, technically everything would be illegal about that.

That's how Dean's Scene in Portland, OR operated for a long time....before it got shut down by the OLCC. But I guess it's back now.

Yeah, I doubt the operation in MN would last long once the authorities caught wind. But hey, laws were meant to be pushed, right? What happened to the free market. ;)
 
You can skirt around laws by setting up some taps in your basement, put up a "donation box," and provide beer for "free."

Might one day attract the attention of the authorities, but technically nothing illegal about that.

In Pa. you cannot even sell them a cup to put your "free beer" into and I'm pretty sure you cannot accept donations either.
We wanted to have a homebrew contest at our OKTOBERFEST - this is how I know.....
 
I'm not sure about the MN liquor laws, but in my state, technically everything would be illegal about that.

I practice law in MN, and can tell you that a "freewill donation" workaround will not make it legal. The authorities will see through that like glass. "For sale" is basically construed as "receiving anything of value as consideration." Whether or not there is a set price is irrelevant.

For those of you in B.C., you are fortunate to have such forward-looking legislators who created this niche. In my state, we can't even get a bill to allow alcohol sales on Sunday, though they recently passed a provision allowing Sunday growler sales.
 
Some quotes from this thread...

And quickly saw that brewing (and doing anything for work) is work, it's not nearly as fun as homebrewing.
True, but in my case the motivating factor isn't even necessarily driven by the money end of it. Sure, that's rewarding and you NEED it of course to keep the brewery and yourself going (see subsequent quotes) but the sheer joy of seeing other people enjoy your beer enough to PAY for it and in fact come back again and again is very rewarding, at least to me.

I have read many many threads and books on starting/owning/operating a brewery. The one thing I found in common is that working/owning a brewery is just an over glorified janitor position.
Absolutely true. So true in fact that we LITERALLY say this to our applicants who apply for positions in the brewery. You WILL BE doing essentially janitor work with occasional interruptions to make some beer. But truly, those interruptions are seldom and short-lived because there's cleaning to be done. SO MUCH CLEANING!

to brew professionally. It's basically industrial cleaning with a lot of hard work thrown in the mix. I have friends who are pros, and they are the hardest working people I know. If you want to go on that path, that is wonderful but keep in mind that it's physically demanding and involves from very long days.
Oh ya. When we were first learning our system, our brew days were somewhere in the zone of 15 to 16 hours long. And then we had to come back the next day for cleaning. We've improved and gotten brew days down to around 10 hours but they are still looong days.

We run a 10 bbl system and that means hundreds and hundreds of pounds of spent grains at the end of the mash need to be manually cleaned out and carted out to the bins for the rancher to load off to his cattle. And that's relatively early in the brew day...

As for the red tape etc... It's there. but there IS a way around it. You just have to wade in and start cutting. Keep moving forward and communicate, communicate, communicate. Know PRECISELY what you want to do with your brewing operation and then read up about other folks who have done something similar and succeeded. Then get ahold of those people and start asking questions. Then comes the hard part. Listen to them. Listen when they say "This is a bad idea. I'd do THIS instead."

I would do SO many things differently if I were starting again. My brewery footprint is for crap, I don't have a loading bay, my floors don't drain well because I tried to save some money... All things people told me I should try to avoid but I figured I could overcome them and save myself some startup money along the way. Now I'm saddled with 3 times the work and an eternally wet and messy floor that I have to pay somebody to constantly wash and clean or I have to do it myself three times a day. And I'm just getting started!

But don't get me wrong. I'm not discouraging you at all. I'm LOVING life right now. The brewery is doing well, people like the products and I have specific goals and processes for how to improve our beers AND our brewhaus.

As for your situation and retailing home-brew - I actually initially wanted to purchase a space and put local HOMEBREW on tap. What I wanted to do was basically consign taps and brewhaus space to local brewers so they could make beer and sell it in the taproom and I'd take a percentage. Ultimately that was unrealistic. However I still think it's a really cool idea if somebody could get enough brewers together who were passionate enough and reliable enough to consistently produce beer.

Course after that you'd have to go through ALL the process of getting a licensed brewery, then you'd have to register all the home-brew beers with your state and fed government (ABV, IBU and Style) and your brewers would have meet those numbers consistently. You'd have to hire and train servers, you'd have to train the brewers to follow consistent cleaning and sanitation practices in the brewhaus and they'd have to learn to play nicely together. But how cool would it be to have a co-op of say 20 or so brewers who all put 10 or 15 gallons of beer on tap each month for consignment.

Anyway, that was INITIALLY my idea. That eventually morphed into the full-blown brewery that is Muddy Creek.

Sorry, didn't mean to hijack. Just found this thread interesting. Carry on.
 
Can you give beer away to friends and let them donate to the cause if they wish? Not in your home, but say for instance a friend wants a keg for a party and he insists on paying for ingredients?

Not legally. In some states, you can't even take "home"brew out of your home for your OWN use let alone give it away. You can't take homebrew out of the home in which it was legally brewed to take to your cottage or your campsite, for example, in those areas. In some states, you can give a limited amount away legally, but if you barter or trade for it, or receive cash for it, then it is not considered a gift and that would make it illegal.

In Michigan, you used to be able to give away 1 6-pack per year to an individual, but now it is raised to 20 gallons per year that you can give away.

Each state sets their own laws, and they vary wildly. But barter for homebrew is illegal in all of them.


Give him the keg for free, but charge him for your help planning the party.

Let's stop talking about ways to skirt the laws, as this forum won't condone illegal activity or ways around the laws. I would encourage everyone to join that AHA and work to change the laws that they don't agree with, but let's get back to the topic discussed here, which is legal means in the OP's province to sell his beer. Thanks!
 
But hey, laws were meant to be pushed, right? What happened to the free market. ;)

The free market is alive and well. If it weren't then BMC would have squashed all these nice craft brewers long ago.

It's no free market when you give a competitive advantage (no licensing fees or taxes collected) to a guy selling homebrew out of his basement.

Every one gets permitted. Everyone gets licensed. Everyone pays taxes. Let your product stand on its merits. There's your free market.
 
The free market is alive and well. If it weren't then BMC would have squashed all these nice craft brewers long ago.

It's no free market when you give a competitive advantage (no licensing fees or taxes collected) to a guy selling homebrew out of his basement.

Every one gets permitted. Everyone gets licensed. Everyone pays taxes. Let your product stand on its merits. There's your free market.

They almost got away with it down here in FL. **** Stargel.
 
Not trying to hijack this thread but....

It is also not a free market when the government sets licensing fees such that only BMC type brewers can afford to make and sell their wares. I got hit with this fact many years ago when trying to license my dairy. Had to have a minimum storage capacity of 250 gallons on site. That was more than a weeks worth of production for my small herd. Why was it set that high? To prevent small producers from getting into the field. Nobody could give me a reasonable explanation otherwise.

Free Market = Everyone gets permitted, everyone pays taxes based upon production and/or sales, product stands or falls on its own merit.

I really hope for the OP's sake that the laws in BC some how favor the small producer.
 
The free market is alive and well. If it weren't then BMC would have squashed all these nice craft brewers long ago.

It's no free market when you give a competitive advantage (no licensing fees or taxes collected) to a guy selling homebrew out of his basement.

Every one gets permitted. Everyone gets licensed. Everyone pays taxes. Let your product stand on its merits. There's your free market.

Give me liberty or give me death! In all honesty, I don't give two craps about the market. Just making a joke, hence the winky face.
 
Some quotes from this thread...

True, but in my case the motivating factor isn't even necessarily driven by the money end of it. Sure, that's rewarding and you NEED it of course to keep the brewery and yourself going (see subsequent quotes) but the sheer joy of seeing other people enjoy your beer enough to PAY for it and in fact come back again and again is very rewarding, at least to me.

Absolutely true. So true in fact that we LITERALLY say this to our applicants who apply for positions in the brewery. You WILL BE doing essentially janitor work with occasional interruptions to make some beer. But truly, those interruptions are seldom and short-lived because there's cleaning to be done. SO MUCH CLEANING!


Oh ya. When we were first learning our system, our brew days were somewhere in the zone of 15 to 16 hours long. And then we had to come back the next day for cleaning. We've improved and gotten brew days down to around 10 hours but they are still looong days.

We run a 10 bbl system and that means hundreds and hundreds of pounds of spent grains at the end of the mash need to be manually cleaned out and carted out to the bins for the rancher to load off to his cattle. And that's relatively early in the brew day...

As for the red tape etc... It's there. but there IS a way around it. You just have to wade in and start cutting. Keep moving forward and communicate, communicate, communicate. Know PRECISELY what you want to do with your brewing operation and then read up about other folks who have done something similar and succeeded. Then get ahold of those people and start asking questions. Then comes the hard part. Listen to them. Listen when they say "This is a bad idea. I'd do THIS instead."

I would do SO many things differently if I were starting again. My brewery footprint is for crap, I don't have a loading bay, my floors don't drain well because I tried to save some money... All things people told me I should try to avoid but I figured I could overcome them and save myself some startup money along the way. Now I'm saddled with 3 times the work and an eternally wet and messy floor that I have to pay somebody to constantly wash and clean or I have to do it myself three times a day. And I'm just getting started!

But don't get me wrong. I'm not discouraging you at all. I'm LOVING life right now. The brewery is doing well, people like the products and I have specific goals and processes for how to improve our beers AND our brewhaus.

As for your situation and retailing home-brew - I actually initially wanted to purchase a space and put local HOMEBREW on tap. What I wanted to do was basically consign taps and brewhaus space to local brewers so they could make beer and sell it in the taproom and I'd take a percentage. Ultimately that was unrealistic. However I still think it's a really cool idea if somebody could get enough brewers together who were passionate enough and reliable enough to consistently produce beer.

Course after that you'd have to go through ALL the process of getting a licensed brewery, then you'd have to register all the home-brew beers with your state and fed government (ABV, IBU and Style) and your brewers would have meet those numbers consistently. You'd have to hire and train servers, you'd have to train the brewers to follow consistent cleaning and sanitation practices in the brewhaus and they'd have to learn to play nicely together. But how cool would it be to have a co-op of say 20 or so brewers who all put 10 or 15 gallons of beer on tap each month for consignment.

Anyway, that was INITIALLY my idea. That eventually morphed into the full-blown brewery that is Muddy Creek.

Sorry, didn't mean to hijack. Just found this thread interesting. Carry on.

Muddy creek-one of the first to respond to this thread attached a link to your thread, which i read with complete excitement, i definitely find what youre doing inspiring. Not sure if i will ever get to that point, but who knows, i dream of one day having a brewpub that i can share with my town and show people how amazing fresh craft beer really is, so for now i can dream. As for all the other responses, thank you for your advice and positive encouragement, its awesome to have a site like hbt where so many like minded people help you along your path :) im not interested in finding loopholes or skirting laws, if i decide to do this i wanna be in it for the long haul and do it right. That being said, if anyone knows more in detail about bc's new laws and what i can do to get the ball rolling, let me know. Cheers everyone
 
Thanks for the responses all :) ....the good news for me is the region in canada i live in just made it legal to sell home made craft beers and wines at local market (farmers markets) with permission by the market owner and a certification obtained by the province. .....

So what are you waiting for? Get your paperwork done and go for it!!!
 
Not trying to hijack this thread but....

It is also not a free market when the government sets licensing fees such that only BMC type brewers can afford to make and sell their wares. I got hit with this fact many years ago when trying to license my dairy. Had to have a minimum storage capacity of 250 gallons on site. That was more than a weeks worth of production for my small herd. Why was it set that high? To prevent small producers from getting into the field. Nobody could give me a reasonable explanation otherwise.

Free Market = Everyone gets permitted, everyone pays taxes based upon production and/or sales, product stands or falls on its own merit.

I really hope for the OP's sake that the laws in BC some how favor the small producer.


FWIW the federal tax laws favor small producers in the US. Excise tax is much lower, per barrel, for small brewers, and they jump dramatically once you hit some big threshold. Its still probably easier to be big overall, of course.

This farmer's market law in BC (if it requires you to already be a licensed brewery) sounds a lot like the one in Washington state.
 
So just out of curiousity, how many of you have ever dreamed about one day selling your beer, even having it turn into a business? I have. I think about brewing all the time. I am an automotive mechanic by trade, but my dreams involve brewing. I know what most of you are thinking-yeah we have all thought about that at some point, dont do it, its not simple like you think, etc., i know. Trust me, i am a realist. Im not naive enough to think you just decide to make beer one day and away you go. However i do believe you should have a dream and some goals in life and this is mine. Are any of you selling your products or brewing in a financially rewarding way and if yes how did you get started?

I am...well kind of;) I think the biggest draw for us is getting our beer out there in a public space. I think it can be equated to a musician/band that gigs around town. The fun is getting others to listen/dance to your music and not so much to make money. The same can be said for homebrewers. The fun part is seeing others enjoy your beer and having others tell you how much they like your beer. So........Thanks to a new law here in California I am allowed to donate beer to non profit charity events. The charity sells my beer and I get the warm fuzzies that not only do I get to help a worthy charity raise money.....people are drinking my beer and loving it! I can't say it is really financially rewarding however I do sell brewery merch at these events. That helps to pay for all my supplies and it give me a ton of great name recognition if/when I decide to go pro.
 
Thats awesome, its exactly what i want to do. As much as it will sound tacky, for me it is truly about seeing others experience a beer i made and love it. Every person that has tried my beer says the same thing, it doesnt taste like any other beer theyve hadì. Its not that im making some crazy beer better than any other homebrewer, its that a lot of people have never tasted a fresh, handcrafted beer and its cool to see people experience that for the first time.
 
Back
Top