Reusing yeast
- Thread starter KENfromMI
- Start date
Help Support Homebrew Talk:
The best method is determined by cage match. The sponsors of a given method are given blunt weapons and fight to the death. 
There are many posts about this and you would probably be best served reading a few to figure out which apply to your specific situation.
I would seriously consider just dumping the new batch right on top of the cake from previous batch but this may not always be the best.....like if your last batch was a double chocolate bacon stout that you Oaked.....I wouldn't reuse it for my kolsch.
Brew on!
There are many posts about this and you would probably be best served reading a few to figure out which apply to your specific situation.
I would seriously consider just dumping the new batch right on top of the cake from previous batch but this may not always be the best.....like if your last batch was a double chocolate bacon stout that you Oaked.....I wouldn't reuse it for my kolsch.
Brew on!
- Joined
- Jan 28, 2013
- Messages
- 3,926
- Reaction score
- 3,028
the best method is determined by cage match. The sponsors of a given method are given blunt weapons and fight to the death. :d
there are many posts about this and you would probably be best served reading a few to figure out which apply to your specific situation.
I would seriously consider just dumping the new batch right on top of the cake from previous batch but this may not always be the best.....like if your last batch was a double chocolate bacon stout that you oaked.....i wouldn't reuse it for my kolsch.
Brew on!
+1
I say go for it! If the worst thing that happens to that Oktoberfest is that it lands on a cake from a rye pale ale then I would be quite happy to drink it with you when the time comes.
1 common suggestion is that you avoid pitching "delicate" beers onto a cake from an aggressive beer (see earlier reference to reusing a cake from an Oaked double chocolate bacon stout). I don't think you're really guilty of that in this case so go crazy. It makes for great discussion when explaining to others about the making of Oktoberfest.
Brew on!
Maybe pour off half the old yeast cake (and save it for a different batch) so you won't start with so much old trub and yeast.
![Craft A Brew - Safale S-04 Dry Yeast - Fermentis - English Ale Dry Yeast - For English and American Ales and Hard Apple Ciders - Ingredients for Home Brewing - Beer Making Supplies - [1 Pack]](https://m.media-amazon.com/images/I/41fVGNh6JfL._SL500_.jpg)
Dumping on a fresh yeast cake from a similar size batch equates to about a 3x-4x overpitch of yeast. Severe overpitching (4x and above) can subdue flavor a little. If you can scoop or pour out half to 2/3 it would be better. It's not critical, as long as you don't underpitch, which can be way worse.
slym2none
"Lazy extract brewer."
Do it!
My Oktoberbeast Ale is sitting on a yeast-cake made up of the Notty I used on my last batch (a blonde) and I plan on pouring the wort I brew next (from an RIS) right on top of this yeast cake. That will be all for that half-a-pack of hydrated Nottingham, however.
My Oktoberbeast Ale is sitting on a yeast-cake made up of the Notty I used on my last batch (a blonde) and I plan on pouring the wort I brew next (from an RIS) right on top of this yeast cake. That will be all for that half-a-pack of hydrated Nottingham, however.
Don't do it!
Seriously though, I have re-used the "harvested" yeast from previous batches at least 4-5 times this year, but I am always paranoid about the outcome - it has turned out just fine, but in the end I am leaning towards that it's not worth the effort. You may be ok if your sanitizing practices are impeccable and if you re-use the yeast soon afterwards.
But my general feeling now, after experimenting with this for a bit - it may not be worth the effort. You need to make sure no bugs get in, and be very careful about how you harvest it, how you wash it, how you keep it etc. You probably have no idea about how much of that "harvest" to pitch, and you are probably pitching a lot of dead yeast, and perhaps over- or under-pitching by a lot.
You will be spending a lot of time doing this, if you want to do this right. All to save $6.99 or so in yeast purchases, and risking ruining your entire batch. And what if your new recipe calls for a different kind of yeast?
I love experimenting, but after all the effort, I may be just getting a vial of yeast in the future, having a starter going and doing it in risk-averse fashion. Your beer and your tastebuds will thank you.
^ I do agree on good sanitation practices or your next batch may get ruined.
Many pitch on previous yeast cakes and harvest it, without any trouble. You're the judge.
Many pitch on previous yeast cakes and harvest it, without any trouble. You're the judge.
It's not a big deal and it's not a big risk. $7 isn't much but 5 repitches = $35 worth of yeast.
I rarely do subsequent brews that use the same yeast but when I have there have been no issues.
EcuPirate07
Beer is a food group
Why not yeast washing.
https://www.homebrewtalk.com/showthread.php?t=41768
Once I wash then I break them down into small 50ml tubes and freeze them like this.
https://www.homebrewtalk.com/freezing-yeast.html
Works great for me. Turned $6.99 into $100 worth of yeast.
https://www.homebrewtalk.com/showthread.php?t=41768
Once I wash then I break them down into small 50ml tubes and freeze them like this.
https://www.homebrewtalk.com/freezing-yeast.html
Works great for me. Turned $6.99 into $100 worth of yeast.
I use yeast over and over and over, and buy it about twice per year.
There are good ways, and also not-so-good ways to do this.
Here's some food for thought: https://www.homebrewtalk.com/showthread.php?t=166221
Much better (and easier) is to pitch the correct amount of yeast by consulting a yeast pitching calculator (free on the internet), and saving the rest in a mason jar in the fridge. That way, you get three batches at least from one yeast cake, and you don't risk overpitching or underpitching. It's a win-win.
There are good ways, and also not-so-good ways to do this.
Here's some food for thought: https://www.homebrewtalk.com/showthread.php?t=166221
Much better (and easier) is to pitch the correct amount of yeast by consulting a yeast pitching calculator (free on the internet), and saving the rest in a mason jar in the fridge. That way, you get three batches at least from one yeast cake, and you don't risk overpitching or underpitching. It's a win-win.
TheMerkle
Well-Known Member
As mentioned above: if the previous beer wasn't hugely alcoholic, and it's successor isn't terribly mild mannered, just dump it on the cake.
When I bottle I pour the trub/yeast cake into a sanitised jar, screw the lid on and put it in the fridge. When I pitch I sanitise a table spoon and take two scoops of the trub/yeast cake and throw it into the fermenter.
The fermentation has gone well every time I have tried it and all the beers have tasted fine at bottling.
I won't do it with yeast that has been in the fridge for more than 3 months though.
Some (a small proportion) of these batches have however come out foul after a bit of bottle conditioning. From what I read about autolysis it's a similar flavour, but then what I have read about autolysis is that its highly unlikely in homebrewing - i think i had some bad lunch with my sanitation at bottling.
The fermentation has gone well every time I have tried it and all the beers have tasted fine at bottling.
I won't do it with yeast that has been in the fridge for more than 3 months though.
Some (a small proportion) of these batches have however come out foul after a bit of bottle conditioning. From what I read about autolysis it's a similar flavour, but then what I have read about autolysis is that its highly unlikely in homebrewing - i think i had some bad lunch with my sanitation at bottling.
I've never pitched fresh wort on an entire yeast cake. From what I understand, if you do, you should make sure the beers are at least similar in style and the new batch of wort being poured onto the yeast cake is AT LEAST as high an OG (if not higher) than the OG of the cake. For example, brew a pale ale at 4.5% and then brew Dead Ringer IPA at 6.5% and dump the Dead Ringer wort onto the cake from the pale ale. Which strain of yeast did you use for the Rye? Will it be a good one to match with the Oktoberfest? The two Oktoberfests I made with "ale" yeasts were done with WYeast 1007 and WYeast 2112. Both did well. 2112 is really a hybrid yeast, but it did fine in the mid 60's. Personally, I'd wash and harvest the yeast, pour off into several mason jars, make a starter with one of the mason jars and pitch that. That's what I've been doing with brew since mid 2014 and have always had beer that finished at least 1.014 and pretty mild lag times.
I just started back brewing after several years off. Like a rookie I didn't log the number that was on the yeast so I can't tell you the strain. I'd have to stop by the shop. It was an American Ale smack pack but I'm not sure of the numbers on it if that helps. I'll probably just spend the $6 on a fresh pack and do some more research before giving it a shot.
My GUESS - if it was a dry yeast - was that it was Safale 05. You're probably safest just doing what you say - buying new yeast since you're not even sure of the strain. Even if you pitched a safe amount, it could result in a funky flavor if the strain doesn't go well with the ingredients. Good call
...and the cage match begins! Where"s my blunt weapon?
I would definitely save it! Yeast is like $7 a pack, and a big part of the cost of a single batch.
Seriously, saving it and reusing it is the way to go. I have tons of yeast in my fridge, and only buy yeast twice per year.
It's super easy, and makes great beer since you don't overpitch or underpitch when you save the slurry in mason jars and just use the amount you need.
Here's a quick pictorial with instructions: https://www.homebrewtalk.com/showthread.php?t=519995
TheMerkle
Well-Known Member
Yooper, do you ever save/reuse dry strains?
PrinceOfThePoint
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Dec 12, 2013
- Messages
- 209
- Reaction score
- 55
I re-use dry US05 and Notty with great success. "Yeast Washing Explained" thread here on HBT is good. Need mason jars.
I agree with that sentiment. Perhaps my tongue-in-cheeck "Don't do it!" counter-argument post was a bit over the top. Do it, but be careful/thoughtful about the process and do it to learn about yeast, not just to save money.
I do reuse the yeast myself - last 3 or 4 batches I re-used WLP-001 for my brews, even though I had to get a new vial of yeast for two recent batches - rye saison (French Saison yeast) and oatmeal stout (Irish Ale yeast) - those I may not re-use any time soon since I don't brew those styles enough, so I didn't bother harvesting it (should I have?).
But for anyone relatively new to home brewing - as I was when I did it first, they need to understand the tradeoffs and maybe even risks. Namely - this has to be the right kind of yeast, and it has to be reasonably fresh, unless you freeze it properly which is a whole different can of worms. You need to be very meticulous about the process of sanitizing/washing yeast, understanding what is happening, as well as storage/record keeping. You need to understand that viability will drop with time during storage, and be good at "guesstimating" the cell count, to pitch at the right rate.
As Yooper said (who am I to argue with her?) - you can save some substantial $ if you brew regularly and re-use or propagate the basic type of yeast that is compatible with your recipes. $7 or so per vial can add up over many batches. But a single ruined (or somewhat taste-compromised) batch can easily negate 10 batches of yeast savings, especially if you take into account the labor that went into making it. This has never happened to me yet (knock on wood), and it could easily happen from other things, but that's something to keep in mind when reusing yeast.
It is fun though!
Yes. But I only use a couple of dry strains anyway- BRY-97 and S05- and I'm not crazy about either of them. They are more "emergency back up" strains that I don't love and rarely will use if I can avoid it.
I'm just wondering if the 1007 some of u recommended might be better than the one I was going to use. I could still save some of this 1056 American Ale for the batch after I guess.....Yooper any comments on these strains?
I don't use 1056 very often (it's basically the same as the dry S05), but 1007 is a nice strain for many types of beers. I don't use it very often either, though, unless I'm making a German ale (kolsch). I tend to like strains that drop bright without filtering or gelatin.
Similar threads
