Ok, so I'm feeling like I can write a scoresheet that has good descriptions and feedback, but I'm not confident I'm really tasting what I'm supposed to taste.
Here's a scoresheet I filled out for a Vienna Lager (that I brewed):
Aroma (8/12): Malt dominates aroma, with faint fruity esters in the background. Hops are not perceptible.
Appearance (2/3): Brilliant amber. Head is coarse and dissipates quickly.
Flavor (10/20): Definitely malt-forward: biscuits, toast, toffee. Fruity esters or a small amount of acetaldehyde -- neither is to style. Bitterness is balanced, no hop flavor.
Mouthfeel (3/5): Crisp, light body, with medium high carbonation. Some alcohol comes through. Slight astringency in aftertaste.
Overall impression (5/10): Pleasant-drinking beer, but too much fermentation character for style, esp. esters. Watch fermentation temps. (cold!) and pitch rate (remember, lagers pitch at higher rates.)
28/50
and here's what a (certified) judge made of the same beer at a recent competition:
Aroma (7/12): Moderate sweet bready malt, little to no hops noted, very light fruit pear esters, no phenols.
Appearance (3/3): Dark gold nearing light amber, crystal clarity, moderate head, mixed bubble size, off-white color, moderate retention.
Flavor (14/20): Simple malt profile, very singular, bready little to no toast, low bitterness, floral hops, possibly very light esters, no phenols, balance is malty, finish is crisp and dry, some lingering malt sweetness but fruity sweet too.
Mouthfeel (5/5): Medium-light body, medium-low carbonation, not warming, not creamy, not astringent.
Overall impression (6/10): Very good beer, clean fermentation but has some light fruity character, malt should be more complex and have strong toast flavor, probably should have a more crisp finish.
35/50
What do y'all think? Did we drink the same beer? Do I know anything about what I'm talking about? How is my exam prep. going?
Thanks for listening!