Ive had a few oyster stouts that I really enjoyed. Others were meh.
It's interesting to think that what is being pulled is perhaps a minor salinity from the oysters, proteins, and calcium from shells. Very easy to replicate the profile with standard ingredients.....
Makes me think of years ago we were brewing the perfect pumpkin ale. Tried a number of styles at our sitting table building the recipe. My buddy went to the bathroom and I pulled out a miller lite from the back of the fridge, added some pumpkin pie spice, and mixed up good. Had it ready in a pint glass when he got back and handed it to him for the next sample to decrypt the flavor profile.
I said this one came from an organic brewery that only sources their pumpkins from local farmers then return a percentage of their proceeds to programs helping our small farms keep afloat. Even grow most of the spices that go into this in a temp controlled greenhouse to limit carbon footprint on supply chain.
He immediately said, wow - I can really taste the pumpkin in this one. Fresh nutmeg really comes through....Ginger profile is prominent and can tell its fresh. my favorite yet! I broke him the news....
Moral of the story, the narrative is what controls
