Objectionable Reactions to Homebrewing

[ludomonster]

If my beer doesn't taste good, I don't let anyone drink it. On the other hand, if my beer is really good, nobody else gets to drink it either.

 

[bigdaddybrew]

I like my brats cooked in a beer....hmmm brats in my beer? 4 taps through the walll? Okay maybe I'm not the guy in the commercial but we are gonna hang out!

 

[HopSpunge]

If my beer doesn't taste good, I don't let anyone drink it. On the other hand, if my beer is really good, nobody else gets to drink it either.

Amen.

 

[guldalian]

They are just pissed cuz we can make great beer for like 50 cents a bottle so we dont have to go there and spend $9 for a pint of guinness. And yes the commercial is hilarious.

 

[emjay]

The commercial was kind of funny, but the commenters on YouTube getting their panties in a twist are hilarious.

 

[PeckerWood]

So...Bratwurst in the mash or secondary? ;-D

 

[emjay]

Bratwurst in the mash or secondary?

Cooked bratwurst filling in the randall :rockin:

 

[willness33]

I thought the commercial was pretty funny. I've not had any negative reaction from anyone except my girlfriend when I took the lid off the bucket on her Hefe. After racking it to the keg, carbing and letting her take a drink, she changed her mind. The krausen still grosses her out, but she'll drink it up later. Now my friends, on the other hand, will drink my kegs dry if I turn my back on them. Even the BMC drinkers will go back for thirds on my lighter session beers.

 

[Zamial]

What I do not like about this commercial is that homebrewers have had to overcome LOTS of obstacles, stereotypes and misinformation; some of this as far back as prohibition!

Was it cheeky fun intended to lightly amuse a niche crowd or more? Do you think BWW sells more BMC products or craft beer? I just see this as another attack on homebrewers from a corporation.

I would say I will just boycott BWW but the last time I ate there was the last time because their prices are stupid high. We have MUCH better places than BWW to get food for "The Game".

 

[broadbill]

my wife refuses to try anything i made in the basement. not so much an anti-homebrew thing as she is just kinda snobby about food. looking at the bucket my porter is blowing off into i can't say she is completely without merit, but it smells goooood! she's a bmc girl if she drinks at all so...

Its obvious your wife has never to a farm and seen where food is actually grown (not that I'm picking on her or anything, most people haven't). She'd be looking at your beer in a whole different light after coming home from your local factory farm!

Another thing to think about: Our vegetables are grown in big open fields and are picked by migrant workers. You know what aren't in those big open fields? Bathrooms. Think about it.

 

[signpost]

The BWW near me (Detroit metro area) has a new menu card on the tables listing craft beers and imports. The entire top half is dedicated to Michigan craft beers. They have about a half dozen and rotate a seasonal or two through the mix. Last time I was there, they had stuff from Bell's, Founders, New Holland, Rochester Mills and maybe one other Michigan brewery. And they've always had things like Sierra Nevada and Sam Adams, along with imports like Guiness, Newcastle and others.

I haven't seen that commercial on TV, but I think it is hilarious. I don't think many people I know would be dissuaded from trying my homebrew based on that commercial. Pretty much everybody I know that is interested in beer at all has wanted to try my brews. And most people have liked them fairly well, so far.

 

[nutty_gnome]

I thought the commercial was a great caricature of how the uninformed public imagines homebrewers. I especially liked the cat and the foam taste test. Hoses everywhere and the 'chunky' beer had me giggling. The secret ingredient kinda looked like seafood salad. I liked the commercial and watched it several times. That said, I wouldn't go to a BWW anyway, they aren't local and I don't eat at chain restaurants.

 

[Phyrst]

I'm wondering how many people out there see that commercial and think they will give homebrewing a try since apparently you can have a batch of beer ready in "two minutes".

 

[Xpertskir]

If people don't want to drink my beer then that's less I can brew.

There, fixed that for you

 

[lindenboy]

My father in law is a miller lite or nothing guy. Might try this just to see if he honestly doesnt like my beer or just negative.

I love this idea! Let us know how that goes...I have a feeling that blind taste tests on "blind" BMC lovers would surprise everyone!

This hits home for me too: I once poured a Bud Light can that had been in the fridge for a few weeks from a buddy's golf trip into a pint glass. I was tired of looking at it, so it was time to choke it down My wife came thirsty into the kitchen and asked if she could have a drink. Now, usually I am pestering her to try different beers -- not anything too extreme because she's not a craft beer lover -- but she does have a pretty keen sense of taste when it comes to ingredients and flavors.

So she tastes it and her immediate reaction was "Oh, man, this is my kind of beer. What style is this?" I just couldn't help myself to break the news to her that this new beer she thought I brewed was a Bud Light. What do I have to do around here to get her approval?! : ) Haha.

I'm not offended if people don't like my beers -- even my wife. Like many have said, it leaves more for me.

PS. I thought the commercial was funny -- how awesome is that set up behind them on the wall? LOL.

 

[AmandaK]

There are a few stigmas about homebrewers I don't like, though.

1. "Am I going to get E-coli?" No, my homebrew will not make you sick. There is nastier stuff living in your refrigerator than in that glass of homebrew.

2. "Wow, you must get drunk a lot." Hey, I see you're grilling a cheeseburger. I bet you weigh 400 lbs? Well, you're cooking food, so you must eat until your buttons pop at every meal, right?

3. "Why would you make beer when you can just buy it at the store?" I don't know. Why would you grill a 16 oz. porterhouse steak when you can just go to McDonalds?

4. "I would offer you a beer, but I bought it at the store so you probably wouldn't like it." Yes, because no brewery anywhere ever made a good beer. Just because I homebrew doesn't make me a beer snob.

I think I have gotten every one of these in the past. Now that I've distributed my beer and honed my craft, word has gotten out. My parent's neighbors, people at church, my friends around the country (I've shipped to Elko, NV before for a friend who was hankerin' for some "Beer-Amanda" beer), my old pastor (I taught him to brew), my co-workers, etc, etc all ask for my beer. It's a blessing and a curse.

The only bad thing said about my beers in recent memory was about my award winning lambic... I accidentally gave some to someone at work who wasn't ready for a sour beer. LOL. Now they call it my "Stinky Beer".

 

[DPBISME]

Cute.... I know guys like that....

I have brewed beer I don't like! I mean not just a little but stuff I thought was foul!

Funny thing is someone else has loved it and said it was better than all my other beers.

I say "baby, don't leave with out a few filled Growlers".

DPB

 

[jwitt]

That was pretty funny. I must be lucky, because I can only think of one friend who won't try my brew, and he's one of those odd types who eat 3 kinds of food- eats frozen soft pretzels but won't try my homemade ones!!! I'm by no means a great brewer but my "friend problems" are 1) pulling 24/7 guard duty so the stash isn't depleted and 2) convincing people that it's OK to "waste" that last 1/4" of yeasty funk at the bottom of a bottle.

As far as BWW, I don't usually go to chain restaurants to spend my tiny bit of spare cash...and my wings are better, and not even fried (brined then smoked)

 

[Daddio]

The guy does have an awesome brewing room

 

[CastleHollow]

What's been the most objectionable reaction that you've experienced after telling people that you brew your own beer? Have you ever had anyone refuse to try some?

I think the increasing popularity of craft brew has really helped change people's perception of beer & brewing, so I don't ever get anything objectionable. Lots of interest in the process, and have even been able to convert a number of neophytes into brewers over the past few years.

When I first started brewing back in the mid-90's, would get tons of skepticism, funny looks and people who would go out of their way at parties to avoid any beer that wasn't poured from a recognizable bottle. Most common question was "isn't that illegal?!" Next most common question was "how much alcohol can you put in this?!"

 

[ZombieBrew83]

I had mixed feelings to this commercial. It does reinforce some of the negative preconceived notions people have about homebrewers. But at the same time it seems like BWW feels threatened by us. I did ponder what type of grain would best compliment a dry-bratted beer. ::

I've always enjoyed BWW. I've been to a couple bad locations and a few good ones. They always have a decent beer selection, in my opinion, compared to most other places.

 

[unionrdr]

I was like the cigar smoker to an average person when #2 son would walk in when momma & I were having a brew day. "Sniff sniff,dam! It smells like cat wizz in here!". We were doing hop additions atm. Then he comes over for a holiday or some pit bbq,tries our latest brew,& says this is friggin good,or this tastes like______.
He really likes my whiskely ale now that he's hooked on some darker craft ales. He thought my wifes first try at summer shandy tasted the most like leini's. I don't have friends within a couple of states anymore,& my neighbors...well,...fagettaboutit. They're too good for an old retiree who's house doesn't look like a dubai palace from the outside. Oh well,so much the better for me.
As for BWW,I used to like the food with beer. That's what it's meant to go with anyway. But it is too expensive,as are the pints. Decent imports,bmc's for that crowd. It's been since the smoking ban since I've been in there,so I can't speak about craft beers with them. I like to smoke while I drink,great way to relax,even with a crook cigar like mark twain used to smoke. Those are good with my dark ale. I think they're called back woods smokes. The tobacco is sweated 1st to take out the harshness before hand rolling.
But BWW lost my business since I can't smoke & the prices got even higher.
The commercial is a bit of tongue in chek humor,but it's also saying "you know you can't do it as good as we do". All in the name of profits. Don't drink his hooch,drink our $6 a glass swill. We'll just make you think it's the emperors new cloths sort of thing. You have to think of it like joe average would that doesn't know anu better. Put that home brew in a negative light so they'll spend there off time & dispensable income with us. I went to a business college & the longer I stayed & the better I got...the less I liked what I was becoming.
It's funny on one level,but a direct assault on the next. It's just exaggerated to make the point obvious to joe average. More laws are coming up against public watering holes,& they gotta gett the public back. Home brewing is just an extension of that decline in their business.

 

[whitehause]

Don't have a BWW near me, but whoever made that commercial must have some idea about hombrewing based on the equipment.

I'm my own worst critic when it comes to my beer. If I make a batch that seems a little off for some reason, I just keep it for myself. If I were a chef and made a really crappy sauce, I wouldn't say "F-it, serve it anyway".
The few craft beer drinkers I know really like my brews....the BMC crowd....not so much, but they wouldn't like the commercial versions either.

I really don't care what the miller 55,or bud lite lime, or super cold triple filtered, never hopped,less filling, filler removed crowd thinks about my beer, I'm not doing it for them anyway.

 

[unionrdr]

My point,anyway,was how joe average is led to think of home brew vs there commercial stuff. It's kinda funny,but a kick in the slats just the same. I care about what he thinks,since what we do was de reguare a long time ago. He just isn't aware of that,even though most people know beer has been around a very long time. We're trying to make positive changes in this world by attempting to make sure the old ways aren't forggoten. If not for being put in a modern context. I'm not michael jackson,God rest his soul. But I see were I have to try when the opportunity presents itself to change people's percweptions of what we do. We are craft beer brewers that do it out of love for a good beer. not the golden idol. And that's the real point of focus here.

 

[bigdaddybrew]

Your aunt's homemade lasagna vs chef boyardee?
Grandmas apple pie vs Hostess apple pie?
My neighbors fresh maple syrup vs Aunt Jamima table syrup?
Your uncles New England clam chowder vs Campbell's clam chowder?
My grandma's tamales vs tamales from a can?
Homebrew vs ____________light?

We have the high ground!

 

[huge1s]

I would say the only objectionable comment I have had was offering some of my homebrew to some friends that were over and them responding with a story about how they got really sick the last time they had someone's homebrew. I didn't have the heart to tell them that it was probably the undercooked chicken (or something similar). They tried mine anyway and have asked me several times to come over and brew beer with me.

 

[whitehause]

My point,anyway,was how joe average is led to think of home brew vs there commercial stuff. It's kinda funny,but a kick in the slats just the same. I care about what he thinks,since what we do was de reguare a long time ago. He just isn't aware of that,even though most people know beer has been around a very long time. We're trying to make positive changes in this world by attempting to make sure the old ways aren't forggoten. If not for being put in a modern context. I'm not michael jackson,God rest his soul. But I see were I have to try when the opportunity presents itself to change people's percweptions of what we do. We are craft beer brewers that do it out of love for a good beer. not the golden idol. And that's the real point of focus here.

Joe average is just that....Joe average. Not that he can't change, but that's not my goal. I think we get too wrapped up in getting people to change their minds about what they like. I brew because I like to, not to impress anyone or "enlighten" them as to what beer should be.

I'm going to assume you've had a few, because I'm not sure what most of your post is getting at, and I'm not sure what Michael Jackson has to do with anything...... well other than being a lot of things I think are completely offensive.

 

[captwalt]

I just seen that BWW, in addition to hating homebrewers, also doesn't care for parents

 

[signpost]

and I'm not sure what Michael Jackson has to do with anything...... well other than being a lot of things I think are completely offensive.

I'm pretty sure he was talking about this Michael Jackson, and not the one you thought of.

 

[whitehause]

I'm pretty sure he was talking about this Michael Jackson, and not the one you thought of.

Lol...yea...I hope so, cause the other one makes no sense