tnlandsailor
Well-Known Member
This thread is for all you competition entrants out there. We have all seen the traditional BJCP scoresheets. These are the "essay" type ones where all the feedback is handwritten and a score assigned in each judging category. For anyone who made it to the AHA National Finals, you got a scoresheet back that was a "check sheet" type with very little hand written feedback.
Of the two, the essay type is the most often used. But it is also abused and massacred often. We have all seen the illegible, 4 word descriptions of flavor or aroma with some arbitrary score assigned. Don't get me wrong, I've gotten some real quality feedback on these, but the scoresheet itself just lends itself to vagueness depends too much on the judge to be descriptive and verbose. The check sheet is just about useless and is mostly built for speed. There is little or no written feedback and the results tell me just about nothing.
Is it just me, or does there need to be a new way to provide feedback to competition entrants? Something that is useful, descriptive, and legible? And, as a BJCP judge, something that is easy to fill out but gives me the flexibility to provide useful feed back to the brewer?
What kind of scoresheet would you all like to see? Improvements? Wholesale change?
Of the two, the essay type is the most often used. But it is also abused and massacred often. We have all seen the illegible, 4 word descriptions of flavor or aroma with some arbitrary score assigned. Don't get me wrong, I've gotten some real quality feedback on these, but the scoresheet itself just lends itself to vagueness depends too much on the judge to be descriptive and verbose. The check sheet is just about useless and is mostly built for speed. There is little or no written feedback and the results tell me just about nothing.
Is it just me, or does there need to be a new way to provide feedback to competition entrants? Something that is useful, descriptive, and legible? And, as a BJCP judge, something that is easy to fill out but gives me the flexibility to provide useful feed back to the brewer?
What kind of scoresheet would you all like to see? Improvements? Wholesale change?