Another place that has a great (but smallish) selection is Belmont Party Supply off Smithfield Rd. It is convienently located adjacent to the Brewtensils HBS.
I picked up a bomber of Alesmith Speedway Stout, a 4 pk of Founders Rye IPA, a bomber of Ephemere Cranberry, a bomber of Weihenstephaner, and a 4pk of Fuller's ESB.
They have a lot of OH brews there, and they even get some Three Floyds there from time to time.