I was reading through the thread and saw Ananimity's post about forgetting to get an OG reading. I forgot, too. I just took one and it seems high (although I guess I'm not sure what high is). My Hydrometer only goes to 1.07 and it was floating higher than that. If the lines were any indication and I assume that the line gradient remains the same, I would guess about 1.085 or more.
Is that a normal reading? I used 3# of honey instead of 3.5# because that was all I had.
On the bright side, looks like another trip to the LHBS is in order.
Thanks.