Thanks for those replies. Yeah, those rings look fine and the price is right. I guess I'm not so concerned about what's causing the expansion and if it is Star San there's nothing that can be done other than just frequently change them
Existing rings are from a mix of different replacement kits. Was making an effort to keep parts from different kits together but after having enough go bad I stopped trying to keep track of what came from what kit. I've frequently have them do this, this ring has expanded enough to effortlessly push it down out of the ring indention
View attachment 815103