Yes, boiled tap water, boiling water sterilizing the container and boiled steam cleaning the saran wrap.Did you boil the water that you froze into ice? Did you cover it with Saran Wrap in the freezer? I dot want to incite panic but tap waters got all sorts of microbes, and your freezer prolly has a good amount floating around too.
I might not have aerated to the best. At about 80 I lifted the entire fermenter and shook it for one minute. I think I may have had problems with not aerating enough and relative high final gravities (1.012 vs 1.007 say) so it's something I'm going to work on, but for now my priorities is getting a sanitized work area for cooling. I just didn't really have it. Did better today. Will help in future to maybe pour back and forth between kettles and fermenters but I need to perfect sanitation before I can afford to worry about that.Also, you should let it cool to 80 in the kettle then splash all hell out of it when racking to he fermenter. Over 80 F there's a chance of HSA (I know it could be a myth but I like to play it safe) and you gotta aerate the wort well to ensure enough dissolved O2 for your yeasties to build strong cell walls to withstand the osmotic pressure of an alcoholic environment.