I am with Lizard here. For ales, I have found great success with storing cold water in my lager fridge to use on brewday. I have three 3 gallon tubs that I keep filled with water. I then put the water from chilling right back into them and they go back in the fridge. So a little bit of conservation going on.
For lagers I use whatever it takes to get down to 80F ish then put ice cubes in my reservoir and recirculate the water back out from the chiller into the reservoir. The key is to only have enough water in the reservoir to keep the loop going. You want the cubes to melt because the melting water is the coldest. If you have too much other water in there the melting water temp is wasted on the water, not the wort. So you have to have a glass or container to catch and remove the return water to keep the level low.
I have lowered a lager wort to 44F in my garage on a 100F day using this method. It works!
For lagers I use whatever it takes to get down to 80F ish then put ice cubes in my reservoir and recirculate the water back out from the chiller into the reservoir. The key is to only have enough water in the reservoir to keep the loop going. You want the cubes to melt because the melting water is the coldest. If you have too much other water in there the melting water temp is wasted on the water, not the wort. So you have to have a glass or container to catch and remove the return water to keep the level low.
I have lowered a lager wort to 44F in my garage on a 100F day using this method. It works!